Cannes Film Festival 2013

Review: 'Last Resort' - 'Nuke It Out': Hide a key

Marcus and Sam hunt for the missing missile key, and Serrat causes more trouble for the crew

<p>The SEALs have words with Sam (Scott Speedman) on "Last Resort."</p>

The SEALs have words with Sam (Scott Speedman) on "Last Resort."

Credit: ABC

A review of tonight's "Last Resort" coming up just as soon as I compare you to Kurt Cobain...

"Nuke It Out" was another episode of "Last Resort" where some parts worked better than others, and that left me wishing the show would try to do less so it can focus more both on what it's best at and what needs the most attention, story-wise.

The big snoozer this week was the Grace/James/Tani love triangle, which doesn't work because the show has given us no reason to care about Tani (other than whatever pre-existing affection a handful of viewers may have for Dichen Lachman from her "Dollhouse" days) and because Tani feels more far removed from the series than Christine and Kylie, even though she's on the island and they're way back in Washington, D.C.(*)

(*) I actually found myself enjoying, and not just tolerating, the D.C. stuff this week, as Christine took so readily to the spy game.

But I also think that a lot of the action on the island this week didn't entirely click. Because we're jumping between so many different storylines, there wasn't enough time to properly handle Sam and Booth's attempt to play each other, or to deal with whether or not Booth is starting to sway Sam on the subject of Marcus. And the show continues to do a poor job of justifying Serrat's continued existence as a freestanding alive person. When he boasts that the people of the island love him because he's done nothing, Marcus doesn't bother to point out that Serrat participated in a chemical attack on the entire population. This is leverage they could have used against a guy who murdered one of their own, but Sam stupidly let him go last week, leaving Julian free to keep abducting sailors and doing things like getting the COB to fall off the wagon. He's a means of generating tension and plot, but not one that feels in any way plausible at this point. And the revelation that Cortez was the CIA mole with the missile key was telegraphed by the earlier scene where she goes to Marcus to swear that she's with him to the end. The earlier campfire scene would have been enough to remind us that Cortez mattered without underlining her importance until it became clear that she had to be the mole.

On the plus side, I quite liked Sam pumping up the crew with corny old Navy jokes and an old football game, Andre Braugher threatening people is always excellent (even if Marcus needs to start carrying out some of those threats against people like Julian), and the bomb defusal scene was one of those old tropes, like any of the show's submarine chase sequences, that pretty much always works if you do it even vaguely right.

But there's still a lot of work to be done here. A bunch of people who work on the show said on Twitter this week that the ratings for tonight's episode will help decide whether the show gets a full-season order or goes away after 13 episodes. There remains enough good raw material here that I want "Last Resort" to stay around long enough for Shawn Ryan and company to figure out how to fit it all together. But "Nuke It Out" was a reminder that the show isn't there just yet.

What did everybody else think?

Alan-sepinwall-sm
Alan Sepinwall
Sr. Editor, What's Alan Watching
Alan Sepinwall has been reviewing television since the mid-'90s, first for Tony Soprano's hometown paper, The Star-Ledger, and now for HitFix. His new book, "The Revolution Was Televised," about the last 15 years of TV drama, is for sale at Amazon. He can be reached at sepinwall@hitfix.com

Comments

  • Option 1

    Comment instantly as a guest Guest
  • Option 2

    Connect
  • Option 3

    Login or create a HitFix account Login Signup
  • Mastershake_talkback_profile

    War Chief Shake Zula

    I'm certainly still enjoying it overall. I do think the love triangle crap is unnecessary and ridiculous. But I'm starting to think my threshold for implausible plotting is much higher than Alan's. I'm somewhat engaged by Serrat's crap - although Chaplin pulling a Judge/Jury/Executioner on him will be much appreciated when it does arrive.

    The D.C. plotline this week was the kind of gooey espionage goodness I love in all shows of this type.

    November 15, 2012 at 10:31PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Dillon

    This episode annoyed me on many levels. The first is the telegraphing of the mole. Then how easy it is to kidnap crew members. You would think after the first 10 were taken they would be more careful. I also wonder why Christine's house is not bugged.

    As for the seal and Dani I am assuming he is only developing a physical relationship to get closer and to further his own causes.

    November 16, 2012 at 12:42AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Tom M

    I'm engaged in this show, but I'd be lying if I said that wasn't based more on my opinion of Shawn Ryan's pedigree and my loyalty to people like Braugher, Speedman, and Autumn Reeser than on anything this show has actually done on its own merit.

    The continued existence of Serrat, to me, threatens to (if not actually does) undermine anything else the show is doing well. I confess I don't have perfect recall, so this may be factually inaccurate, and if it is, please correct me, but to this point Serrat and/or his cronies have abducted FIVE naval officers...and I'm pretty sure the audience hasn't been shown onscreen the actual abduction of any of the five...and I hate to point a storytelling finger, but I feel like the reason for that is because they want to achieve a particular storytelling outcome, but haven't figured a plausible way HOW to get there, so they just skip the "how". I'm not a Navy veteran, so if anyone is and what I'm saying in unsound, please correct me, but, these people aren't home on leave, they are in unfamiliar territory under persistent threat in a situation that could change wildly at a moment's notice (both big-picture off-island and little-picture on-island). They should be HYPER-aware, yet FIVE separate individuals have all fallen victim to the same amateur warlord? It just isn't plausible to me, not with the considerable suspension of disbelief I'm already engaging in to accept this show's broader premises.

    Serrat isn't a foreign head-of-state, someone you'd have to walk on eggshells around or behave diplomatically to or concede even the slightest ground to. He's barely three-dimensional...a Machiavellian, clever, long game-playing sort of island villain would be of tremendous value and interest on this show, but Serrat is not that. This is the kind of villain you waste in the pilot to illustrate exactly how big the new sandbox has grown with the arrival of the U.S. Navy and just how insignificant the island's former "ruler" is in the new power structure. Leaving himnot just alive, but roaming with seemingly free rein to abduct and kill naval officers just seems like bizarre, almost comically bad plotting.

    And yet, again, as damning as that all sounded, there're enough goodwill points elsewhere in the show for me that I'm still able to grit my teeth through his onscreen appearances...for now. Thanks, as always Alan, for the forum to express.

    November 16, 2012 at 1:29AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      John Well, let's see: Cortez and the two others, the soldier who had the bomb strapped to her, and now COB. Yep, that makes five. You make some great points. Julian probably should have been executed after he killed the first one. He has no real leverage.

      November 16, 2012 at 6:01AM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Critic

    Kill Serrat immediately or cancel the show. It's just the stupidest plot advancer possible. Maybe have a kinder gardener hold the entire sub hostage and kill half a dozen crew while we are at it.
    Serrat surviving first encounter.. Maybe... second? Seriously? And now the 5th? For what? If the people rebel you can literally put every single person in the village down in one day. It's sent Vietnam or even a city it's an Island with a tiny village, if Serrat is alive at end of next episode I'm not watching anymore.

    November 16, 2012 at 3:01AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Darkdoug

    Chiming in on the "deal with Serrat for good" front. I also have to say, are we supposed to give the tiniest little damn about his miserable childhood in Africa? So he has reasons for being a dirtbag. Why are we supposed to care? Of more interest in that scene was the revelation that the CoB comes down so hard on the drugs because he has dealt with his own addiction to painkillers in the past.

    The only thing I will say in defense of Serrat's continued survival is the presence of the Frenchwoman at the little concert does seem to support the premise that he is really the only game in town when it comes to the island's society. Additionally, while it might seem improbable that he can snatch Navy personnel on three different occasions, that demonstrated ability might just be proof of how plugged in he is, and why starting a war with him would be bad news.

    One more consideration is their hope to go home someday. Kill Serrat, and the story that the media will print after the whole crisis is over is how the big bully psycho Chaplin murdered a local villager who stood up to him. That's exactly the kind of charges his adversaries in the government would use for petty spite once their game is brought to a halt.

    That said, Serrat has definitely gotten to the point where his threat outweighs most of those considerations. If they can't kill him, maybe they have to start making examples of his men, the way he is picking on Chaplin's men. Snatch one of his henchmen and string him up in the center of the village, while publically blaming Serrat for driving them to this extreme. Let everyone know that while the Navy can't touch the big guy, they will punish those who follow him against them. See how long his support lasts after that. Or assassinate him and arrest, try and hang one of his henchmen for the "crime." Blame it on competitors or something.

    The only remaining thing I can say about Serrat is that they have plans to bring him around in the long term, and so the writers are thinking of him as merely another protagonist who initially presents as hostile, like Autumn Reeser, the French chick, or Jay Hernandez (whose character seems to have become instantly rehabilitated and the adultery-temptation plotline restored with the mention of his son). I think that's why they keep bothering to give him lines like the stuff about his childhood, or his continued indignation at Chaplin for barging in and interfering with his world, that might not actually be a pose, but sincere resentment.

    November 16, 2012 at 3:35AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    rwmcgee

    It's just jumping on the band-wagon at this point I guess...but yes, Serrat is absolutely the show killer at this point. Having some kind of island warlord to resist the submarine crew is fine...but the crew's reaction is unbelievably stupid.

    A) KILL HIM.
    or
    B) Have all the Navy personnel sleep either on the submarine or in some kind of fortified compound on the island (The Romans figured this one out, so building a base isn't exactly a new concept)
    or
    C) Work WITH the guy (too late now, I know)

    but yeah, he's driving massive plot holes through every good part of the show, he needs to go immediately.

    November 16, 2012 at 5:22AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Rachel

    The sex triangles on this show are eyerollable. I guess that since they're on ABC they feel like they have to include this stuff. Newsflash ABC: I'm a GIRL and even I think there's too much kissing can you do less kissing here please thanks bye.

    November 16, 2012 at 5:43AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Joh

    Agreed on the love triangle. I think James and Grace are perfectly fine as a potential romance. But Tani is just...there. And she basically has been since the beginning. She's not the biggest problem on this show (Julian, I'm looking at you), but she's not really bringing anything to the table.

    November 16, 2012 at 6:08AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Img_1603_talkback_profile

    Peter_the_Gr8

    I'm still watching mostly because it is Shawn Ryan. There are just a lot of people I do not care about on this show - Tani being front and center (I didn't even know her name.) I find the DC stuff pretty non-compelling mostly because I find the two women uninteresting. But The Shield and Terriers buys a lot of clout in my heart so I'm sticking with it.

    November 16, 2012 at 12:31PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Ellen M.

    There was way too much going on in this episode. I felt like I was trying to watch tennis "triples". At some point you couldn't keep track of the tennis balls on the court. Considering what happened last week with Serrat, that guy could have been excluded from the action this week. Let his character rest already. The love triangles are also getting silly. I thought last week's inclusion of Speedman, hallucinating, kissing the French woman felt very forced.

    The reveal of Cortez was over the top and I would have enjoyed having that play out a bit longer than just one week after the theft of the key.

    I also thought the morale boosting scene with Speedman was great. It felt like something that could actually happen from time to time.

    I really hope they can sort all this stuff out and simplify things. I would like to see this show come back next season with a much more focussed storyline. It's a great premise and the actors consistently rise above the material.

    November 16, 2012 at 12:33PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Lbsammills51

    I'm on board with killing Serrat too. If they'd bothered to portray him as either someone playing all the angles without being stupid enough to continue challenging a man with nuclear weapons, or as the leader of an insurgency of sorts on the island, having no care for Marcus' beef with the U.S. but simply not wanting the island and its people to be caught in the middle of this maelstrom, that would've been fine and interesting. This is not. He's the moron constantly challenging the man with nuclear weapons because he's throwing a fit that he's not king of the island anymore. I can't take the character seriously, have no interest in the character and tend to roll my eyes whenever he's on-screen. Shoot him and be done with it.

    November 16, 2012 at 12:48PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    kneejerk

    Well, if tonight was the episode that was make or break, I guess the 1.3 tells the story that we won't be seeing the back nine...

    November 16, 2012 at 1:42PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Avatar_talkback_profile

    mcm99

    Do they not have a brig on that submarine? If they do, why the hell is Julian not in it? He killed - outright murdered - one of the navy men!

    I can take a lot of non-realism for the sake of drama but this is ridiculous that he is running around free on that island.

    November 16, 2012 at 3:36PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Ronnie_james_dio_f_talkback_profile

    UnHoly Diver

    Just an FYI for anyone that night be interested; Ryan's gonna be on Kevin Pollak's little internet chat show this Sunday at 6PM ET. If anyone has ever tuned into an episode, you know it's a one on one, no holds barred kinda thing, and KP usually gets his guests to open up. I'm sure a lot of time will be spent on The Shield, but hopefully, he'll talk about Last Resort, as well. If you can't watch it live, it's available on Hulu, iTunes, and YouTube by Monday or Tuesday.

    November 16, 2012 at 3:44PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Jacob

    I definitely want the show to continue, but man, I really spend most of this episode wondering why Serrat was still alive. Because I'm just kind of baffled.

    November 16, 2012 at 5:24PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    KansasGuest

    As a female fan of LAST RESORT, I just want to say that it doesn't feel to me like James & Grace have any sort of "love" connection going on. I'm fine with that. This is the 21st century. For there to be a "love triangle," you need at least 2 of the corners competing for the 3rd. Grace is just using James for his very pretty physique at a highly stressful time. You go, girl! She doesn't want an emotional commitment at this time. Hence the "one time thing" comment. Stop trying to bake a 3-layer-cake out of what was clearly a two-cookie snack. ;-)

    November 16, 2012 at 6:09PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    wallywalters

    Well, Last Resort just got canceled. I'm guessing this is one of those shows where there's no hope of ever seeing the story resolved.

    November 16, 2012 at 7:10PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Kianna

    I was all set to be thrilled that this many people were commenting here - since the show needs all the eyeballs it can get - and then I read the comment saying it's been canceled. For fuck's sake, ABC.

    So done with American television.

    November 16, 2012 at 7:17PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    George

    Another mediocre episode.

    Can't wait to see how huge the loose ends are going to be after the cancellation that was in the making for weeks already. Thankfully the show was never good enough to warrant much investment from me, so it's not too bad.

    November 16, 2012 at 11:07PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Beekayz

    I understand that a need for realism isn't particularly high on the totem pole of 'Last Resort', but how can the scene with COB falling off the wagon be justified as a logical course of action by Julian?

    COB was kidnapped, tortured and injected against his will and there would be no ramifications (for him) if he reports it immediately to Marcus. Due to the severity of his injury he won't be able to hide it from the crew, and one injection would not be enough to turn him into a full blown drug addict (at least not physically and realistically not mentally/emotionally either especially with the ramifications of what continued use would lead to and the pact with the devil that would eventuate between him and Julian).

    November 16, 2012 at 11:15PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    birkoff1

    CANCELLED.

    November 16, 2012 at 11:27PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Anonymous Indeed.

      A shame. I've criticized the show before, but it doesn't deserve to die - not when it's better than 90% of the swill that's on primetime.

      Maybe Homeland can snag Braugher - how great would that be?

      November 17, 2012 at 9:17AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Ted Well deserved cancellation. Great pilot, unwatchable idiocy after the pilot.

      November 17, 2012 at 3:51PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Charlie Chan Thats because it's to close to home, and all the cover-ups and lies that the government are really involved in, VietNam Bay Of Pigs, Water gate, All the scandles and BS that are fed to the sheeple !!!

      December 10, 2012 at 7:00PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Omar

    I think most people are assessing the show from a point of view of screenwriting/wannabee screenwriting (no insult intended). This is fair. But it's also fair to assess this show based on the intangibles that separate a thing being excellent because it competently executes certain mechanics and a thing being great because it transcends the mechanics on the strength of "it" qualities.
    The Last resort has "it".
    Look I get everyones criticisms about the absurdities but this show is so bad ass I could care less lol. It's like wactching Arnold Shwarzenegger in a cop flick. Yes it makes no sense whatsoever that he's an austrian bodybuilder with a crazy accent yet everyone interacts with him like he's a native from Chicago lol...But he's Arnold so who cares haha. The larger than life factor of Arnold negates all the absurdity. It's why we watch this stuff. Not for competent mechanics but to get covered in awesome juice.
    Serrat is awesome juice. The actor who plays him has created a cross between Papa Doc Duvalier/kony slash that slick bastard you cannot get enough of hating lol.
    Chaplin is awesome juice. I mean Homeboy is like a cross between Picard Shatner and Malcolm X lol. Braugher is basically an A-list star with all types of heat who happens to be on a tv show. Every shot he's in is pure epic gravitas. Dude just got it likedat. Then they surround him with Hybrid from Underworld and the liquid metal guy from the second Terminator flick lol. Cmo'n this show is crack!
    Every week things happen in overdrive. I mean good lord it never let up from the first ep. I mean one week they are nuking DC, next they are Killing a Condaleeza Rice clone (brilliant) and this week was the nuttiest.
    I mean they got the captain killing executing henchmen in cold blood, that Navy seal surfer looking dude cheating on his mega-hot honey with the almost as hot lieutenant chick, and the latina girl being revealed as a traitor! Wow. Goodstuff.
    None of that taking forever for things to happen nonsense. Blink and you miss it with this show.
    Look I knew this show would be cancelled as soon as they firmly wrote the US government as being this terminally lethally corrupted anti-democratic entity opposed primarily by a heroic angry black man with a buncha nukes (and uses them to!) I have no idea how his show got made lol. At the pace it's going I fully expect it to resolve all plot lines by episode 13 before it is yanked off the air.
    One season of genius is enough for me. I'll be the first in line for the box set!

    November 17, 2012 at 5:04PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Omar Not to reply to my own comment but I left out in my list of madness cool stuff that happened in this ep...The COB gettin' tortured turned out and junkified on painkillers! Holy hell who the heck saw that one coming? That was like watching John Wayne getting raped by native american drug dealers lol. Plus the revelation that he was once a junkie of his own volition. Wow. This show should charge admission. I'd pay.

      November 17, 2012 at 5:18PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Brad

    Show spends too much time on local (Island, crew) issues and not enough on the big political issues. The U.S. pre-emptively nuked Islamabad and Lahore. The Colorado sent a warning nuke over Washington DC. Big-time war stuff, particularly with Pakistan. The world would be in turmoil, and with the communications capabilities of the NATO station, the Captain should be focused on playing a role in how events and reactions evolve. In real life, the first thing that would have been taken care of would have been securing the island, especially imprisoning or killing Serrat and his men. Or they would have kept everyone on the boat.
    More time should have been spent on the Washington DC part of the show. The political crisis atmosphere there would be worthy of its own show.
    Can you imagine if a bunch of generals resign, the Sec Def gets canned and then Pakistan gets nuked? The country would be up in arms (I would hope). Certainly other countries would be freaked. I would see NATO stepping in to keep the U.S. Navy from attacking the Colorado at a NATO island base.
    It is a shame the show got canceled because I think it had a lot of potential, but the writers simply did not approach the story appropriately. Maybe they should have looked at it as a one-season arc with a resolution of the Colorado's status by the end of the season. If continued they could have set up a new arc for the next season, such as being an element of an opposition force of U.S. and international opponents of a rogue U.S. president.

    November 17, 2012 at 9:13PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    jason

    I want to like this show. I love the concept. I like most the cast. But each week, more than one scene leaves me disliking (people freak out over the word hate) the show to the point all the good gets trampled down (anyone say Chuck season 3?). Arrow on the other hand, so far, the same bad vibes ring just a little less hard and long, such that the good comes through and I'm hooked (chuck s1, s2, s3.5, s4, s5 till the mean spirited ending)

    November 18, 2012 at 12:49PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Alvina

    The only aspects of the show that are keeping me watching are the DC/political scenes, and the island tension. I couldn't care less about the Seal, the bartender, the french lady, or Serrat.

    This show would have reminded me of an old-school spy novel (longing to go back home to a wife, and all) if it werent for the meaningless love triangles.

    November 20, 2012 at 11:15PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    BigDave

    if Serrat is alive at end of next episode I'm not watching anymore.
    Someone posted that. I am totally onboard with this idea. The absurdity of the whole premise of the plot is made WAY WAY over the top by the continuing existence of Serrat in a living condition. Simply killing him is not good enough anymore. He must be flayed while still living then forced to eat some of his body parts before death takes him.
    I am DONE with this show if he lives past the next episode.

    November 21, 2012 at 9:55PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Joe Fubar

    What happened to the dude that got his feet burned and given a pain killer that he was once addicted to ? Two episodes went by and no one speaks of him ??

    December 10, 2012 at 6:54PM EST Reply to Comment

Get Instant Alerts on What's Alan Watching

Latest Posts
More Posts
Recent Activity on Facebook
Most Popular on Facebook
Top Stories From Around the Web