Emmys 2012 Predictions: Outstanding Comedy Series
Is 'Modern Family' a lock to threepeat?
Can any comedy beat "Modern Family" at the Emmys?
Are you a fan of 30 Rock?
Sign up to get the latest updates instantly.
Dan and I are almost done with our picks for who should and will win the major Emmy categories on Sunday night. In our next-to-last post, it's time to look at the contenders for Outstanding Comedy Series.
Your nominees:
"The Big Bang Theory"
"Curb Your Enthusiasm"
"Girls"
"Modern Family"
"30 Rock"
"Veep"
Should win
Alan's pick: "Parks and Recreation," the best pure comedy on television, isn't here. Nor is "Louie," which isn't exactly a comedy all the time, but is great and was eligible here (as evidenced by its nominations in other comedy categories). Of the ones that are left, I'm choosing between "Girls," which had very promising debut season and didn't feel like anything else on television; "Curb Your Enthusiasm," which had three all-time classic episodes and a bunch of others that weren't all that special; and "30 Rock," which had one of its strongest seasons to date late in the run. I like "Girls" a lot, but I'm gonna go with Liz Lemon and friends, who made me laugh loudly and often throughout those 22 episodes, and forever changed the way I think of banjos.
Dan's pick: "Louie"! No? "Parks and Recreation"! No? Hmmm... Well, it was a very good season for "30 Rock," a somewhat under-the-radar comeback given how acclaimed many of NBC's other comedies are. But does "30 Rock" really need my support? Nah. Probably not. So my imaginary vote goes to "Girls" for successfully navigating a tightrope that saw the show tiptoe right up to the edge of "obnoxious" without ever toppling in the wrong direction. I've been raving about that balancing act since spring and I'd like to support it one last time.
Will win
Alan's pick: Emmy voters love "Modern Family." This is well-established. Its mix of single-camera mockumentary style and more traditional multi-camera jokes gives it broad appeal among many constituencies in the TV Academy. And while I didn't think this season overall was the show's best, there were enough good episodes to make a successful Emmy sampler. "30 Rock" (which did well in the past) or "Curb" could sneak in, but a "Modern Family" threepeat seems like one of the night's more inevitable results.
Dan's pick: Until proven otherwise, it's my assumption that "Modern Family" is unbeatable.
PREVIOUSLY: Outstanding Miniseries or Movie | Outstanding Directing | Outstanding Writing | Outstanding Supporting Actress | Outstanding Supporting Actor | Outstanding Lead Actress | Outstanding Lead Actor
Get Instant Alerts on What's Alan Watching
Around the Web
News From Our Partners
-
Mike Hogan: Why We're Hating Don Draper
Colorado Woman Dies During Production Of Reality TV Show
It Pays To Play Gay On Daytime Soaps
-
What to Watch Tonight: SYTYCD, Pretty Little Liars, and the Season 4 Finale of The Voice
Dan Harmon Has Apologized for His Comments About Community Season 4, But Should He Be Forgiven? (POLL)
Teen Wolf "Fireflies" Review: The Virgin Homicides (PHOTO RECAP)
-
Avicii Drops New Single 'Wake Me Up'
New Music Releases – July 2013
Robert Pattinson Wants to Introduce Katy Perry to His Parents
-
Video Interviews with Cast & Crew of Monsters University
Digital Multiplex: 21 & Over, Quartet, and More
RT on DVD & Blu-Ray: Jack the Giant Slayer and Quartet
-
'Veronica Mars' Begins Filming: See Set Photos Here!
'Kick-Ass 2' Exclusive: Meet Your Heroes And Villains
Brad Pitt Promises 'World War Z' Will Be 'Most Intense' Movie You'll See All Year
-
Hear This: My dad toured with Phil Collins
Watch This: White Zombie is the granddaddy of all zombie flicks
Comics Panel: New comics releases include a high-profile Superman title and a musician’s return to comics
-
'Star Wars: Episode VII': Is George Lucas Involved in the J.J. Abrams Reboot?
'Anchorman 2' Teaser Poster Revealed, and It's Kind of a Big Deal
New 'Kick-Ass 2' Trailer: Hit-Girl Gets Her Hits In, Kick-Ass Goes Shirtless
-
The Telefile - TV on DVD: Tuesday, June 18, 2013
The Telefile - Veep: The Episode's Best Insults
The Telefile - The Most Heinous Person on Reality TV This Week
Comments
Option 1
Comment instantly as a guest GuestOption 2
Option 3
Login or create a HitFix account Login Signuprdave
September 21, 2012 at 1:45PM EST Reply to CommentHow did Parks and Rec not even get nominated. Blasphemy!
rdave And/or Community?
September 21, 2012 at 1:46PM ESTThat Werewolf Guy Well, in case of COMMUNITY it might have been something to do with season 3 being most of the time awfully bad, thanks to a stronger focus on gimmick episodes and the betrayal of every character in the show. (Pierce becoming a senility punchline, Abed a borderline psychopath, Chang a braindead cartoon villain...) I still hope that it win the comedy script Emmy, because the multiple timeline episode was the one great standout episode of that season.
September 22, 2012 at 11:28AM ESTronozer
September 21, 2012 at 2:27PM EST Reply to CommentModern Family is hugely over-rated, and much of 30 Rock was not good this year. In a fair world Louie or Girls would win. Parks and Rec would be next.
ronozer
September 21, 2012 at 2:27PM EST Reply to CommentModern Family is hugely over-rated, and much of 30 Rock was not good this year. In a fair world Louie or Girls would win. Parks and Rec would be next.
nath
September 21, 2012 at 5:16PM EST Reply to CommentIt makes me groan seeing how Modern Family consistently dominates the nomination lists. I mean, just for example, there's no way two-thirds of the best male comic performances on TV are all in the same show.
It's like the voters don't even try to give anything interesting or challenging a shot, but I guess I can't be too surprised when the awards for best performances are given out based on one episode and best shows are given out for what, three?
dan Nath - Why is there no way two-thirds of the best male comic performances on TV are all on the same show? I'm not saying they *are* but if Aaron Paul, Dean Norris, Jonathan Banks and Giancarlo Esposito had all been nominated for supporting actor in a drama, would that have seemed implausible or unfair?
September 21, 2012 at 5:21PM EST-Daniel
nath Okay, I should clarify-- hypothetically, it's certainly possible, and a show like Breaking Bad that receives universal critical acclaim, especially for the performances, could plausibly have that happen. But even saying that, I think the Emmys should better reflect what is actually quality television, and it *would* seem a little unfair given the number of terrific dramas that deserve at least one nomination-- Mad Men, Boardwalk Empire, Justified, and Game of Thrones just off the top of my head.
September 21, 2012 at 5:26PM ESTGiving all these nominations to Modern Family seems like they're saying it's basically the only worthwhile comedy on television. And considering the show gave up trying to be interesting about 2/3 of the way through season 1 and has settled into comfortable mediocrity, doing so seems like a case of lazy, status-quo voting.
nath "I think the Emmys should better reflect what is actually quality television"
September 21, 2012 at 5:30PM ESTTo clarify, I mean "The Emmys should attempt to represent and recognize the whole range of quality television, and not just fixate on one show unless it is truly head-and-shoulders above the rest."
Isaac
September 22, 2012 at 2:34AM EST Reply to CommentWhatever guys, I still love Modern Family. It still makes me laugh every time I see it, I still love the characters and yes, it's not as fresh as it once was, but the cast gives it their all.
If Community, Louie or Parks and Recreation had been here, it would be a different story, but without them, my vote goes to Modern Family (even though Veep would be another worthy winner, and I really enjoyed this season of Curb Your Enthusiasm). I also thought that The Big Bang Theory, while it had a bumpy go at first, ended the season very strongly with a season finalé that was the best use of the ensemble in years.
Jared K
September 23, 2012 at 11:09AM EST Reply to CommentShould Win: Girls
Also Worthy: 30 Rock
Will Win: Modern Family
Dark Horses: Girls, The Big Bang Theory
Leaving aside my annoyance at the ludicrous absence of Parks and Recreation and the somewhat-less-ludicrous absence of Community and Louie from this category, I would be inclined to reward the most innovative (if not strictly the funniest) show in the category. Girls may be polarizing, but it’s bold, and I’m betting that those voters who like it ‘really’ like it, giving it a solid base of support with which to challenge the frontrunner. Not that I think the frontrunner will be challenged. Not by this field. Modern Family probably has another two or three years left before voters get tired of it. And while this season was a step down, it was still better than The Big Bang Theory.
forg
September 23, 2012 at 1:20PM EST Reply to CommentGo Modern Family!