Normally I do separate "Best" and "Worst" galleries for the various new fall TV shows, but this year I just squished 15 notable shows together into a single gallery.
"Why?" you might ask.
First off, I do it for you, dear readers. This way, you're only clicking through 15 pictures, rather than 20. Aren't I conscientious?
But more to the point, I think that combining my Best & Worst galleries is reflective of the degree of ambivalence I feel towards most of this year's new shows. I doubt that I'm going to have the time to write many full reviews this season. I don't have the time and I feel pretty awful about that fact. As you know, there's nothing I enjoy so much as writing 2000 words to say, "Meh." If, however, I were to be reviewing these new shows, there isn't a single one that would get an "A" or "A-" or even a "B+" grade from me. I like "Vegas" and "Nashville" and "Last Resort" and "Ben and Kate," I have reservations on each. Last year, there were four or five "A-" or "B+" pilots.
I have less reticence to call out the bad pilots, but other than "Beauty and the Beast," I'm not sure I could rank them. There's a lot of bad.
And then there's a pile of so-so that this gallery is ignoring. So don't ask me where "Revolution," "Animal Practice," "Made in Jersey" and a couple other shows are. I might regret not coming down definitively on the "Good" or "Bad" side after a week or two, but for now, I'll just shrug.
A long-time member of the TCA Board and a longer-time blogger of "American Idol," Dan Fienberg writes about TV, except for when he writes about movies or sometimes writes about the Red Sox. But never music. He would sound stupid talking about music.