Inside TV+Movies with Daniel Fienberg
Gervase's niece talks about being an early target
Marissa of "Survivor: Blood vs. Water"
Well, she had a chance, but the chance got messed up pretty quickly. She responded negatively to future tribal ringleader Brad at the very first grouping of the castaways, putting a target on her back. Then, when the Returning players defeated the Newbies in the first Immunity of the season, Marissa's uncle Gervase, a veteran of the very first American "Survivor" season, made a display of enthusiasm that rubbed Brad the wrong way and made the target even bigger.
Marissa was the first member of her Tadhana tribe voted out and weathered two Redemption Island Duels before going out on this Wednesday's episode.
Perhaps if Brad hadn't been so giddy to vote out the strong, feisty Marissa, followed by the strong, feisty Rachel -- keeping the much less strong and much less feisty Katie and Ciera -- Tadhana wouldn't be searching for its first challenge win of the season. We'll never know.
Marissa certainly thinks Tadhana would be doing better if she'd stuck around. She's also the first contestant I've talked to this season with a pragmatic understanding that this is a game and it may have been necessary to writer Gervase's name down at some point.
Click through for the full exit interview, which may make you wish we'd gotten a bit more Marissa...
NBC gets low numbers across the board
Thursday's "Big Bang Theory"
It was a very mixed Thursday, as several networks found things to be enthusiastic about and several shows sunk into the danger zone.
CBS was, as always, led by "The Big Bang Theory
," which was Thursday's top show in must measures and led the network to overall wins for the night, though "The Millers," "The Crazy Ones
" and "Two and a Half Men
" all continued to fall, despite that powerful lead-in.
Some of the declines for several shows in the 9 p.m. hour are probably due to a well-above-average audience for FOX's "Glee
," which paid tribute to the late Cory Monteith and drew its biggest audience since last September.
The night's lone premiere was ABC's "Once Upon a Time in Wonderland
," which came in below the fall Thursday 8 p.m. launches for "FlashForward," "Charlie's Angels" and "Last Resort" from recent years. And while it still led the 10 p.m. hour, ABC's "Scandal" was down from last week's premiere.
Meanwhile, NBC's former Must See Thursday was five shows averaging under 4 million viewers and between an 0.8 and 1.2 in the key demo, with rather dire numbers across the board.
Note that The CW's lineup was preempted in the New York market for football and will probably change, perhaps dramatically in the case of the 9 p.m. encore of "The Originals."
On to the numbers...
Lea Michele and Naya Rivera were the emotional standouts
Lea Michele and Chris Colfer of "Glee"
Credit: Eddie Chen/FOX
After two weeks in a Beatles-induced haze, "Glee
" simultaneously paid tribute to the all-too-real Cory Monteith and the fictional Finn Hudson on Thursday (October 10) night with an episode titled "The Quarterback."
It's an episode that fans have been dreading, but also anticipating, since Monteith was found dead in a Vancouver hotel room in July at the age of 31. When somebody so young dies, it's impossible to "get closure," but it was important that "Glee" offer fans the opportunity for shared grief with all of the show's stars.
And... Oy. If it's hard to comprehend how a young fanbase deals with the death of a young star, it's even harder to figure out how a cast like the "Glee" cast deals. While there have been periodic rumors of bickering and disfunction involving one actor or another, few workplaces are entirely harmonic at all times and why should "Glee" be any different? But no matter how estranged or how close anybody in that cast is, most of them share a common experience, wherein they went from virtual unknowns to global sensations in just a few months. It's an experience that only the people within that bubble fully comprehend and, this summer, they lost somebody who was there with them from that first moment. Even if Cory Monteith wasn't humble, kind and grounded, it would be a shock and a nearly unhealable wound, but by all accounts [and in my limited, but pleasant, experiences with him] he was.
Watching "The Quarterback" was witnessing an uncomfortable piece of communal grieving. For obvious reasons, we put a premium on Lea Michele's mourning and we wonder how she was able to do what she did in this episode. Michele is a pro and she's said all of the right things about this episode, as have all of the stars and writers, but the public face that anybody puts on a situation like this doesn't really tell us anything. I watched and listened to Michele's "Make You Feel My Love" and it hurt, because she wasn't acting. Nobody in "The Quarterback" was acting. We've seen the "Glee" cast act and many of them are very good, but we've seen all of them do heightened emotion before and this looked different. Or maybe I'm just projecting. Maybe we're all just projecting. Maybe the "Glee" cast grieved in their own way in July and for this episode, they were professionals, keeping their emotions in check and committing only to their finest acting on behalf of their fallen comrade. I don't know. You don't know either. None of us know. I watched the episode and in moments I felt it was a cruel thing to do to the cast. And then in moments I felt like it had to be cathartic. But I don't know. And you don't know either.
[More after the break…]
Simon listens to his last four Groups and makes tough choices.
Simon Cowell of "X Factor"
When we left "The X Factor" on Wednesday night, Simon Cowell had listened to four of his Groups and given chairs to all four.
Six groups remain, including a slew of early favorites and the last two FrankenGroups, so which big Switches does Simon have in store?
Dan and Alan discuss 'Once Upon a Time in Wonderland,' 'Walking Dead' and more
Happy Thursday, Boys & Girls!
It seems like forever, but we're back with our first new Firewall & Iceberg Podcast in 10-ish days. Apologies for the delays and apologies for not having the opportunity to tell you to avoid basically every new network show premiering last week and maybe this week.
Actually, we got in under the wire on ABC's "Once Upon a Time in Wonderland
," which premieres tonight. We also reviewed the new season of AMC's "The Walking Dead
." We talked about the early season successes and failures -- this podcast was completed mere minutes *before* ABC picked up a back-nine for "Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D." -- and we answered a couple pieces of mail.
No podcast next Monday in honor of Columbus Day, but hopefully we'll be back sometime next week!
"Once Upon a Time in Wonderland" (00:01:40 - 00:16:20)
Season 4 of "The Walking Dead" (00:16:25 - 00:26:25)
Early Season Successes and Failures (00:26:30 - 00:49:30)
Listener Mail - Spinoffs (00:50:05 - 00:56:15)
Listener Mail - Showtime meddling (00:56:20 - 01:04:55)
As always, you can subscribe to The Firewall & Iceberg Podcast over at the iTunes Store, where you can also rate us and comment on us. [Or you can always follow our RSS Feed.]
And as always, feel free to e-mail us questions for the podcast.
Joss Whedon co-created show has been winning its Tuesday 8 p.m. slot
Clark Gregg and Ming-Na Wen of "Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D."
Co-created by Joss Whedon, Jed Whedon and Maurissa Tancharoen, "Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D." is a spinoff-of-sorts from the recent string of successful Marvel features, specifically using "The Avengers" as its starting point.
'Arrow' and 'Tomorrow People' have solid launches for The CW
Wednesday's "Modern Family"
With "Modern Family
" delivering Wednesday's best numbers among young viewers and "Criminal Minds
" drawing the biggest audience, it was no surprise to see ABC and CBS battling for Wednesday's ratings crowns.
It also wasn't surprising to see NBC's "Ironside
" dip ever-closer to cancellation in its second week, nor to see ABC's "Super Fun Night
" take a rather large dip in its second airing.
Most of Wednesday's TV offerings posted small declines, with "Law & Order: Special Victims Unit" having one of the bigger drops and ABC's "The Middle
" serving as one of the exceptions with a small audience gain.
Meanwhile, the second season premiere of "Arrow
" basically equalled its May finale in both viewers and in the key demo, giving a solid lead-in for "The Tomorrow People
," which retained well in its debut.
On to the numbers...
Simon and Paulina face tough decisions
Tim Olstad of "The X Factor"
Last week, we were introduced to the 4-Chair Challenge on "The X Factor" and unless you're Ashly Williams or an Ashly Williams fan, the format worked out reasonably well for you.
With the Girls and the Geriatrics out of the way, let's see which acts we're putting on the spot tonight...
A Redemption Island Duel stirs more tension for Brad
John arrives on Redemption Island and greets his wife. "Candice. It's me," he introduces himself. He's such a courteous man! "What are you doing here?" she asks, either confused or annoyed. John is shell-shocked that Brad lied to him, but Candice isn't shocked that Brad was lied to. "I knew you were going to be too trusting with people," Candice tells him. She loves how gullible her husband is, but she knows this bodes ill for his "Survivor
Us & Them, premiering on FOX at midseason. Back at camp, the Returnees agree that John wasn't a good liar and Brad gloats about his achievement. He thinks that in past seasons, the five guys would have stayed together, but in a Loved Ones season, "This isn't Us versus Them, this is Some against Others." That's confusing. Caleb thinks he may be in trouble, because he no longer has a Loved One on the other side.
A third pre-credit sequence? Don't they know I need time to write? At Redemption Island, Candice arrives flipping Brad off. "I was really upset," Candice tells Jeff Probst about seeing her husband again. She wanted somebody she hated to be sent to Redemption Island. "Somebody like Brad Culpepper," she adds. Interestingly, Brad greets this without a smirk. Does the bully dislike being bulled? CREDITS!
It's off to 8:30 p.m. for '2 Broke Girls' as CBS tries to rescue it
America did not find this to be hilarious
If you had "We Are Men
" in the pool as the season's second cancelled show (and first cancelled comedy), give yourself a pat on the back.
Late Wednesday (October 9) afternoon, CBS
announced that effective immediately, "We Are Men" has been pulled from its Monday schedule as part of a wholesale overhaul of a night that used to be a network strength, but has become a major weakness early in the new season.