The highly anticipated horror movie The Witch opened last weekend, and has received a mixed reception from viewers despite being a critically lauded Sundance darling.

One of the questions that entertainment pundits are asking is: What defines a horror movie?

In the video above and below Chris Eggertsen and Roth Cornet dive into that question and why they think there’s been such a polarized response to this film.

You can read Chris’ piece about the split reaction from critics and fans here. 

Take a look and chat with us here or on Twitter.

Roth: @RothCornet

Chris: @HitfixChirs