Now that we know who Jon Snow’s parents are, perhaps the biggest mystery in geek culture is “Who spawned Rey from Star Wars?”

Conspiracy theories abound, and each is plausible in its own way. Some believe that she’s the daughter of Luke Skywalker and Jyn Erso. Others are convinced she’s somehow related to Ben Kenobi. But there’s one theory that’s much darker than fans might want to believe.  

Check out the video above or below to see exactly who she might be related to.

David Eckstein is a writer living in Los Angeles.