Film Festival

Review: 'Dance Moms: Miami' puts the guilt in guilty pleasure

Lifetime's spinoff offers more moms behaving badly

  • Critic's Rating D+
  • Readers' Rating D
Dance Moms: Miami

Susan and Brigette have big dreams for their poor kids on 'Dance Moms: Miami'

Credit: Scott Gries/Lifetime

Last night's premiere of "Dance Moms: Miami" was good news for "Dance Moms" fans broken up about the flagship show airing its season finale. Now there's a whole new set of ambitious kids, crazy moms and flamboyant instructors to follow.

It's less good news for anyone who doesn't enjoy seeing kids put under unreasonable amounts of pressure, grown women embarrass themselves and arguments inflated for entertainment purposes.

I'll admit I'm in the second camp, and I've never bothered to check into the "Dance Moms" phenomenon before this. I've seen clips and interviews, but it always seemed like something worth ignoring.

5 reasons why someone might watch 'Giuliana & Bill'

Scenes from a marriage, now in season five

Giuliana & Bill
They love it when you watch: Bill & Giuliana Rancic
Credit: Andrew Eccles/The Style Network

Until today I had never seen an episode of Style Network's "Giuliana & Bill." And now that I have, I'm wondering why anyone would watch this show on a regular basis.

Obviously someone out there likes it. Tonight was the fifth (!) season premiere, which apparently was much more serious than usual as it tackled Giuliana's diagnosis and treatment for breast cancer.

I wouldn't say "E! News" host Giuliana Rancic and her "Apprentice"-winning husband Bill are bad, or even boring, people. I'm just curious where the appeal in an entire show chronicling their relationship lies.

This is all pure speculation, but here are five possible explanations for why people watch:

'The Voice' results recap: First four eliminations

Some expected and some not-so-expected contenders say goodbye

The Voice results

Jordis nearly hit the road on 'The Voice'

Credit: Lewis Jacobs/NBC

It's the first ever live results show on "The Voice"! A product of the show's success, NBC is giving it some extra hours on the schedule and making the eliminations more dramatic. Will it be as mind-numbingly inane and unnecessarily padded as the average "American Idol" results show?

Don't count on it, because four people will be going home. And before that happens, the bottom three from each time take the stage for a last chance performance in the hopes of winning a coach's save.

Plus, Gym Class Heroes will perform with Team Adam. That's a lot to pack into a single hour, so let's get to it.

'The Voice' recap: First live show

Team Christina takes an early lead with an inspirational favorite and a few relevant pop contenders

Ashley de la Rosa

Ashley de la Rosa is a top contender on Team Christina

Credit: NBC

Finally, the competition truly begins as Team Christina and her "singers from every genre" face off against Team Blake's "unique sounding vocalists." (We'll see Team Adam and Team Cee-Lo next week.)

It's been weeks since they filmed those battles and a few things have changed: Adam has less hair, Cee-Lo has more (thanks to a wig), Christina dropped the ridiculous hat and covered up her cleavage and Blake...looks like Blake.

Christina "could not be more thrilled about what's going to happen tonight," while Blake thinks "it's gonna be tough. America is gonna know what it was like for us going through those battle rounds, it's hard to make a decision."

Recap: 'The Real Housewives of Atlanta' - 'All Pomp But No Circumstance'

It's all business (and bling) before the season finale

Kim and Kroy

Spin-off here we come! Kim and Kroy set the scene for 'Don't Be Tardy For the Wedding'

Credit: Wilford Harewood/Bravo

The season's penultimate episode isn't very eventful, but nearly all the ladies are working it. Phaedra's getting closer to her dreams of big time funeral business. Cynthia's almost ready to launch her modeling school. Kandi's still prepping her sex toy line. Nene contemplates moving to LA and looking for someone crazy enough to cast her alongside professional actors. (Hello, Ryan Murphy!) And Kim gets engaged (and a spin-off!)...

Is Bethenny Frankel a 'Real' housewife worth watching?

'Bethenny Ever After' veers from crass consumerism to shockingly raw moments

Is Bethenny Frankel a 'Real' housewife worth watching?

"Bethenny Ever After"

Credit: Bravo

Last year I found myself hooked into "Bethenny Ever After" (Mon. 10 p.m. on Bravo) despite myself. Yes, former "Real Housewives of New York" star Bethenny Frankel can be crass, loud and annoying, but mostly she had a self-deprecating sense of humor that made scripted scenes almost tolerable and displays of conspicuous consumption a little less irritating. In some ways, she was the neurotic Manhattan version of Mary Tyler Moore 2.0 -- married with a kid in the big city, she was going to make it after all. 

But I was prepared to sit out this season. Last year Frankel sold her Skinnygirl cocktail brand for a reported $120 million, ended up on the cover of Forbes, and jumped from simply well-to-do to filthy rich. While kudos to her, part of Frankel's appeal had been her status as a scrapper -- an ambitious woman who, unlike most other "real" housewives, had to fight for whatever shred of the D-list pie fell into her lap. 

Recap: 'The Voice' - 'The Final Battles'

It time to turn things over to America and for Christina to stop wearing that hat

Recap: 'The Voice' - 'The Final Battles'

One of the Battles on Monday's "The Voice"

Credit: NBC
Hallelujah! We've made it to the final week of battle rounds, and after a torturous month of obvious choices and lackluster match-ups it couldn't come a moment too soon.
 
Carson promises we're in store for an evening of "big changes, unexpected challenges and the most shocking battle yet when country meets hip hop!" Plus Cee-Lo will cry! So let's get to it.
 

Recap: 'Project Runway All Stars' - Season Finale, pt. 2

Will Mondo finally win it all?

Recap: 'Project Runway All Stars' - Season Finale, pt. 2

Michael Costello, Austin Scarlett and Mondo Guerra battle it out for to finally win "Project Runway." 

Credit: Lifetime

With regular "Project Runway" queen Liane Bonin Starr going on hiatus, I'm lucky enough to step in for the show's big finish (although look for a surprise below).  And after a season that was more entertaining than many might have expected (especially considering that host Angela Lindval turned out to be a cold meanie), the final three designers could provide a runway finale for the ages.

Is 'Ringer' improving with age?

After a dismal start, is the Sarah Michelle Gellar show finding its footing?

"Ringer"

 "Ringer" 

Credit: CW
To say "Ringer" got off to a shaky start may be the understatement of the year. After a cornball pilot that was loaded down with a "Parent Trap" premise, a horribly cliched criminal subplot and some of the worst green screen scenes short of a student film, the show seemed stuck in ripping off film noir plotlines and even costumes. Still, I noticed glimmers of hope. As Bridget-as-Siobhan struggled to keep her identity hidden from Siobhan's closest friends, characters such as best friend Gemma and her deadbeat husband Henry (with whom Siobhan was having an affair) emerged to take focus off the dreary police procedural subplot and we discovered Siobhan's perfect life was anything but. 
 
So, eighteen episodes in, how are we doing?
 
Well, "Ringer" has most certainly delivered on twists and turns. Keeping track of who is evil this week and who is lying about what may actually require a flow chart and flash cards as the twin sisters Bridget and Siobhan (both played by Gellar) navigate dangerous, labyrinthine plots that may or may not get one or both of them killed. Is Siobhan's husband Andrew (Ioan Gruffudd) in love with Siobhan (actually Bridget) or is he willing to kill her to protect the Ponzi scheme he's running (this week, it seems to be love -- if he survives being shot by an unknown gunman)? Is someone really trying to kill Bridget because she's Bridget or because she's pretending to be Siobhan? Is Bridget's long-suffering NA sponsor Malcolm (Mike Colter) just a sucker for punishment or… well, we actually know the answer to that one (yes). 
 
Plot twists are thrown at us with the speed of dodge balls in the hands of fourth grade bullies. Even plotlines that initially seem straightforward, such as when Andrew's teen daughter Juliet (Zoey Deutch) accuses a teacher of raping her, are tangled into knots. See, it was actually a plot Juliet, the teacher and a classmate orchestrated to squeeze $10 million dollars out of Andrew. And the plot was actually the idea of Andrew's ex-wife. And she was sleeping with the teacher, not that Juliet knew anything about it. And she hired someone to beat up the classmate and… remember, this was a minor subplot. The rest of the show? Even more convoluted.
 
On the one hand, kudos to "Ringer" for trying hard to keep us guessing. The problem is, in creating endless twists and reversals, what's been lost is key to holding our attention -- character development. While Bridget is clearly the mushy soft center holding our interest (and Malcolm her loyal supporter) and Nestor Carbonell is another sympathetic but mostly wasted character as the stock detective, everyone else seems to flip flop from likable to possible psycho killer week after week.
 
As sweet-natured Bridget worked her charms on Andrew, it seemed the beleaguered husband was finally getting a second shot at love (albeit with someone who isn't really his wife). But when he finally confesses his instigating a Ponzi scheme at work to Siobhan/Bridget, Bridget suspects he's trying to kill her or Malcolm. But then he saves her life, so he was just the victim of bad lighting earlier in the episode. If it's confusing for Bridget, it's possibly more so for viewers, who have to move characters into and out of the good guy and bad guy columns repeatedly not just in a season, but in a single episode. 
 
The other drawback of "Ringer"'s convoluted plotlines is that, in trying to tie up loose ends it's inevitable that logic occasionally gets tossed to the wind. Andrew has no clue that his wife isn't really his wife, but Siobhan's best friend quickly spots a missing tell-tale burn while Siobhan's driver sorts out he's escorting the other sister around town because she's not car sick. Yes, we can assume Andrew wanted to connect with Siobhan so badly he was willing to overlook some disparities, but given that Gellar's voice, stature and attitude are so different when playing the sisters, it's hard to believe anyone who knows about the identical twin angle doesn't figure it out. Most disappointing is Agent Machado (Carbonell)'s continued utter cluelessness. As talented as Carbonell is, it's difficult to watch him trudge through the usual determined detective tropes (and when he finally does get a plotline of his own, it's about him falling for one of his informants -- yawn). 
 
Ultimately, the level on which "Ringer" probably works best is one Gellar is familiar with -- straight forward soap. There's a little more violence and better clothing, but mostly this show is just a twisty, fast-moving take on outrageous soap opera plotlines. Does it always work? No, but sometimes it's fun and, if you allow yourself to get caught up in the action, there's always another nailbiter around the corner. But if you haven't been watching, be forewarned -- jumping in now won't be easy. 
 
Are you watching "Ringer"? 
 

Reality TV Roundup: 'Idol,' 'Teen Mom' make cuts and 'Runway' finale starts slow

It's been a busy week, so get all your reality news here, now

"Project Runway All Stars"

"Project Runway All Stars" 

Credit: Lifetime

Welcome to Reality TV Roundup -- a quick look at some of the reality TV-centric stories that have recently popped up across the fine, old Interwebs. Click away, my couch potato friends. But before you do...?

SPOILER ALERT! SPOILER ALERT! SPOILER ALERT! One more time: SPOILER ALERT. If you watch "Survivor," "The Voice," "Project Runway," "Celebrity Apprentice" or any other competition shows, the latest elimination for each show is probably revealed in the text below. The hope is that, if you missed this week's program and would rather clear out your DVR than watch the episode, you can get a quick hit here. But don't come crying to me if you find out something you didn't want to know. You've been warned. Also note: lots of non-competition reality info lurks below, too.

Liane Bonin Starr

About This Blog

Liane Bonin Starr is an author, screenwriter, radio producer, former senior writer for EW.com and unrepentant shoe collector who spent four years covering the fashion industry to rationalize her problem. Her byline has appeared in The Los Angeles Times, Entertainment Weekly, Daily Variety, The Hollywood Reporter, Flaunt and a lot of other publications that went out of business before she got paid. Her last book was called "a scandalously catty, guilty pleasure" by the late, great Jane magazine, which sounds about right to her. Expect more of the same from Starr Raving.

Get Instant Alerts on Starr Raving

Recent Activity on Facebook
Most Popular on Facebook