While "supernatural comedy" sounds like a mash-up of things that don't naturally go together, like fish and peanut butter (please don't inform me of any exceptions to the rule because ick), some of our favorite shows ever have a little bit of one and a lot of the other and we wouldn't have it any other way. After all, a humorless "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" would just make us sad. This girl has to kill vampires constantly and has post-traumatic stress and no sense of humor or a penchant for witty banter? How can the world be so cruel? See? 

Here is a list compiled by HitFix staffers of the comedies that fell in a jar of supernatural sauce and vice versa. Of course, we expect you'll had additions (or just a really good case as to why you don't believe in supernatural comedies, sort of like Santa or the Easter Bunny) to add in the comments below. 

Are these your favorite supernatural comedies?