"Lucy" dominated the box office this past weekend, but is it a good watch?

HitFix staffers weighed the bests and worsts to the many elements of this genre-mashing movie, with that car chase, Scarlett Johansson, Scarlett Johansson's jeans, Scarlett Johansson's genes, Luc Besson's knack for cheap footage, bad guys, Amr Waked and more.

Click through the gallery below, and see where we agree: what did you think about the third act? And the gunplay? And the romance, if we can call it that?

"Lucy" hit theaters on Friday (July 25).

After five years as a columnist and editor at Billboard, Katie Hasty joined HitFix in 2009 for music and film reporting out of New York. The Midwest native has worked as a writer, music promoter and in A&R since 1999 and performs with her band Numbers And Letters.