Cannes Film Festival 2013

'Sons of Anarchy' Season 5 finale recap: Jax's revenge in 'J'ai Obtenu Cette'

Jax may be victorious, but is it worth it?

Charlie Hunnam and Rockmond Dunbar on 'Sons of Anarchy'

Jax (Charlie Hunnam) helps Roosevelt (Rockmond Dunbar) work toward a "common goal" on the season finale of "Sons of Anarchy."

Credit: FX

Are you a fan of Sons of Anarchy?

Sign up to get the latest updates instantly.

Kurt Sutter really wrecked the curve for "Sons of Anarchy" season finales with last season's disastrous "To Be, Act 2." So anything would probably have been an improvement over that. But there was still a chance that "J'ai Obtenu Cette" (French for Opie's final words, "I got this") would go completely off the rails after what's been a solid enough (not great, not awful) season.

It didn't go off the rails. But it also didn't do much to really change the repetitive game we've been watching for five seasons now.

If I told you Gemma and Tara are feuding, Jax and Tara's relationship has turned rocky, and Jax wants Clay dead, would any of that even be considered spoilers? Or simply more business as usual.

The major storyline the season finale finished off was Jax's mission to get revenge on Damon Pope for essentially ordering Opie's death. While Jax has been treating Pope as a revered mentor all season long (and probably learned a few things in the process), it turns out that he never lost sight of his true goal. He just wanted to orchestrate one of those elaborate plans that would neatly tie his season-long goal of killing Pope into his series-long goal of killing Clay.

After serving Tig up to Pope just as the crime boss demanded, Jax busted in on the execution and turned the tables. He didn't even have to pull the trigger. He simply handed Clay's gun to Tig, gave his shocked friend some motivational words ("You kill the man that burned your kid alive"), and let Tig do his thing.

Pope's last words: "You stupid cracker bitch, you know what happens to whoever kills me, right?"

Jax's answer: "I'm countin' on it."

As many of you predicted in the comments, Jax wants to use Pope's "life insurance" plan to his own advantage. He'll frame Clay for Pope's murder and let the men sworn (and paid) to avenge Pope's death take out Clay for him.

This is Jax as puppet master, so above it all he doesn't even get his hands dirty in the murders of Clay or Pope. He just pulls the strings. He had Juice provide the weapon, Gemma ensure that Clay wouldn't have an alibi (he was with her when Pope was killed, but she'll swear he wasn't), Roosevelt make the arrest (happily, even if he knew it was a set-up) and Clay himself supply the motive with his open dislike of Pope and stupid actions that got him kicked out of SAMCRO. The only things Jax has to do are sit back and feel proud of himself. And maybe make smug comments like, "I'm just a mechanic looking out for my family" to Pope's right-hand man August Marks (Billy Brown, who gets a little more time in the spotlight this week and rolls with it nicely).

Want More...

Sons of Anarchy?
  • Check out everything there is including photos, reviews, videos.
I'm not sure if we're supposed to respect Jax for this or be horrified by his cold-bloodedness, but there are at least two strong reasons to believe the latter. The most obvious is his conversation with Bobby after Bobby finds out Clay's been picked up for Pope's murder. "It wasn't about being smart enough to hurt him," Bobby tells Jax. "It was about being smart enough not to hurt him. You had a chance to be different."

Jax's disappointing reply: "Maybe I'm not so different."

And for the other obvious clue we have to go back to last week's episode and Jax's loathsome and indefensible attack on Wendy. That reverberates this week as Wendy visits Tara's office to explain everything that Jax did to her. Tara, of course, is horrified and finally seems resolved to actually get the hell out of Charming. "Trying is never gonna get you out! Go to Oregon now, before something awful happens to you and your sons!" Wendy screams in case Tara doesn't get the message. But Tara does. And of course it's too late.

Over five seasons, we've seen how Jax's inability to get over his hatred and anger has wreaked havoc in his life. He can't let go of the club in the exact same way he can't let go of his hatred for Clay or anger at Wendy. He may dress it up in noble talk about protecting his friends and protecting his family, but Jax is driven by wrath. He probably wouldn't even recognize himself without it.

And this is the Jax we're left with at the close of Season 5, with only his scheming mother there to back him up. Tara is going to jail and will be charged with conspiracy to commit murder (because of Gemma?). Clay is on his way to jail too, where it won't be easy to survive with Pope's henchmen after him. Bobby has turned in his VP patch, Juice feels like a broken man after betraying Clay, Tig remains both a good soldier and an irreparably damaged human being.

That's a lot of collateral damage to help Jax get to the top. Think he's feeling lonely there?

Odds and ends:

- For those of you wondering exactly when we'd get it, the season finale delivered the annual Katey Sagal song. This year it was a cover of "To Sir with Love" playing over the opening montage, and the song also happens to be available on the new "Sons" soundtrack.

- How much is too much? It's a question worth asking after watching Otto bite off his own tongue (WTF!?) instead of giving his statement ("Way to commit, Otto," Donal Logue's Toric notes) and seeing the garbage cans full of dog corpses that disgust even Tig. We don't watch "Sons of Anarchy" for flowers and rainbows, but there's a way to be dark and edgy without getting stupid and repulsive.

- Speaking of unnecessary nastiness, Gemma wishing Tara gets "fist-raped" in prison was pretty vile, even for her. (Add the fact that Gemma herself is a rape victim, and it may be the lowest low of the whole episode.)

- I'm glad Jimmy Smits' Nero survived the finale, and even though I wish he'd actually listen to Jax and buy that farm (that sets up an awful joke if he eventually gets killed, doesn't it?), I'm glad it seems like he'll be around next season. Seeing where the writers take Nero and seeing what Smits does with it, is easily the part of Season 6 I'll be looking forward to the most.

- Runner-up for what to look forward to in Season 6: more of Logue's Toric. Poor, underused Unser gave us a little more info on Toric's background tonight. He has a Harvard education. He's ex-special forces. He made a lot of high profile arrests as a Marshal but also has a long list of misconduct allegations: excessive force, intimidation, racial profiling. He was forced into early retirement and Nurse Pam was his only family. Sounds like a dangerous man to have as an enemy.

Geoff-berkshire-sm
Geoff Berkshire
Contributor
Geoff Berkshire lives in Los Angeles and writes about film and television. His work has appeared in Variety, the L.A. Times, and Premiere, among other publications. He is the former national entertainment editor and film critic for Metromix.com.
Trending Now on HitFix Boards

Comments

  • Option 1

    Comment instantly as a guest Guest
  • Option 2

    Connect
  • Option 3

    Login or create a HitFix account Login Signup
  • Default-avatar

    Agnès

    Worst title ever anyway: I'm French and it doesn't mean much to me. It's even grammatically incorrect. I wonder how they could let it happen, Google translation isn't always the answer.

    December 5, 2012 at 1:30AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Facebook_talkback_profile

      GeoffBerkshire I have no idea what's been happening with episode titles this season but the other foreign language title -- "Andare Pescare" -- was also apparently grammatically incorrect. Intentional or not? You'll probably need to ask Kurt Sutter.

      December 5, 2012 at 2:00AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Tausif Khan On Twitter Sutter said it was bastardized french for the finale:

      kurt sutter ?@sutterink

      "J'ai Obtenu Cette". why a bastardized french title for the season 5 finale? chucky knows. i hope you enjoy it. thanks for all the love.

      December 5, 2012 at 2:35AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      elise "I got this" means "Je m'en occupe" and "J'ai obtenu cette" means "I obtained this". (This what?) Chucky needs a hand learning French.

      February 20, 2013 at 7:50PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Becky

    Jeez, hate it much?

    December 5, 2012 at 1:40AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Panther_talkback_profile

    kro_lin

    Three thoughts: First, I am sooooo tired of Gemma's character.
    Second, there was a scene of Jax drinking milk from the refrigerator! I finally got my "WHEN DO THEY EAT?!" moment. I am proud.
    Third, I both hate and love this show. Can't wait for season 6!

    December 5, 2012 at 1:42AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Prunella Second, there was a scene of Jax drinking milk from the refrigerator! I finally got my "WHEN DO THEY EAT?!" moment.

      And my thought was, Doesn't anyone use a freakin' glass anymore???

      December 5, 2012 at 3:46AM EST
    • Haha! Your sarcastic wit is simply amazing.

      December 5, 2012 at 10:00AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Weez Phil likes cereal.

      December 5, 2012 at 10:27AM EST
    • With all that running around and scheming they do I would think they would need to eat a balanced breakfast.

      December 5, 2012 at 1:38PM EST
    • Ron-swanson-manly_pic_talkback_profile

      Timm S Phil DOES like cereal! He's also the most useless redshirt around. When the Sons are casing the dogfights, the camera pans around to all of them individually, and when it rested on Phil all I could think was "Try to look mean. Try to look mean. LOOK MEAN, GUY PLAYING PHIL!!!!" Putting words to his internal monologue keeps me invested in his character. Most of the time it's just the sound of "test pattern". He also likes cereal.

      December 5, 2012 at 2:06PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      madmeme Ha! During the dogfight scene, when they panned to Phil, I was thinking, "He'd look more in place behind the counter at a RadioShack than he does in a biker gang at a dogfight."

      December 5, 2012 at 3:00PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Gob's Frozen Dove I"m late to the party as usual, but they just showed Guy Who Plays Phil on "Raising Hope." He answered the door when Jimmy and his boss knocked, thinking there was some domestic abuse going on. Turned out his daughter had a splinter in her finger. He was wearing a Sons leaher vest too.

      December 6, 2012 at 1:40PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    PatJ

    Pretty sure the lady digging in the dumpsters outside the dog-fighting complex was the same homeless girl that Jax saw in the cemetery during Season 1, and has popped up from time to time since (panhandling Gemma for money, in the park before Tara got grabbed).

    Any ideas on who/what she is, or who she represents? Is there a Hamlet parallel I'm missing?

    December 5, 2012 at 2:54AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      (forgot my password) Leo I think she's supposed to represent Fate, or something like that. She seems to appear at important moments in Jax's life.

      Just my prediction but I definitely think she's going to be in the very last episode of Season 7. I don't think this is going to end well for Jax and I can see her appear to him right before the end of the show - whether he dies or not.

      December 5, 2012 at 3:36AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Anthony Her comments made no sense though. Not anything that could be linked to the story. I'm wondering what was up with that?

      December 5, 2012 at 9:13AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      shipwreckedcrew It's code.

      She's Russian intelligence, who works as a double agent for the CIA as an intermdiary between the IRA and Mexican drug cartel.

      Jax is actually the Manchurian Candidate, and Sutter has him running for President in Season 9.

      She's there to keep an eye on him.

      December 5, 2012 at 6:23PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Daniel I'd guess she represents the dark underbelly of humanity, without all the pretensions (honour, family, the tribe) the gangs, bikers and Aryans use to excuse their abuse of human ethics.

      December 7, 2012 at 8:58AM EST
    • Flat_eric_talkback_profile

      HISLOCAL I literally LOL'd at "Jax is actually the Manchurian Candidate".

      December 7, 2012 at 3:09PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    (forgot my password) Leo

    I thought it was a good episode with a few minor hiccups. One being Otto's biting his own tongue off. Sutter obviously wanted a dramatic and shocking scene like that but really, it wouldn't make any difference whether or not Otto could speak in terms of his "making a statement" against Tara - he could sign a statement as well.

    I really think Sutter had gotten so much positive feedback on the finale to Season 3, with Jax's planning and Stahl's death and he copied that a bit here. But I liked it and he really played fair by giving us clues all along and it turned out just as a lot of us predicted, with Jax planning to kill Pope all along. Not sure why he couldn't let Tig in on it, I mean Tig could've pretended the same way Jax did but that's not that big a deal.

    I was so glad that it didn't turn out to be a big reveal that Clay is Jax's dad as some predicted because I think that would've been such a cheat. All along the story has been predicated on JT being Jax's father and the importance of the letters to his son. This show is obviously Jax's journey and Hamlet references aside, it's important that JT was his dad.

    So I'm left with a few questions about the end, and I'm pretty sure we're supposed to have them. Did Gemma tell Roosevelt about Tara asking for the cross for Otto, as she threatened she would do? Makes sense. But then it could have been Toric behind it somehow as well. Not sure just how, but he certainly wanted Tara put away.

    My biggest question is about Jax's reaction to Tara being arrested. He didn't seem to put up much of a protest and didn't even follow her out to the police car. But more than that, he just didn't seem all that upset about it - as if he was balancing in his head as to the plus side the fact that now she couldn't take the boys away.

    Anyway, liked this season a lot, and liked the transformation of Jax which seemed fairly realistic in a show that doesn't fare well under close scrutiny.

    December 5, 2012 at 3:49AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Darkdoug As Toric & the lawyer pointed out, it was not so much a preventive measure as a demonstration of his absolute refusal to speak. Like breaking Stahl's nose back in Season 1. He could have just torn up the deal or spat at her or something else. He could have settled for assault or some lesser crime to invalidate his testimony. That's just not how Otto rolls.

      As for Tig, given how much trouble he causes by going off on his own, do you really want to trust his acting ability in such a tight scenario?

      I think Jax's non-reaction is in keeping with his transformation to puppet-master. Now he's sitting back and thinking of the angles, rather than hot-headedly punching the cops.

      December 5, 2012 at 10:50AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      (forgot my password) Leo DDoug, you're right, Thanks for that. And Toric's "way to commit" line was pretty great.

      As to Tig, the Jax of seasons past would've told Tig and/or been more careful about eliminating the possibility of Tig getting shot before he could help him. I think we're supposed to see this as part of the evolution of Jax's mindset to Clay's, in that they both were willing to sacrifice club members for their perceived benefit of themselves or the club. When Tig confronted Jax and pointed out that Pope could've just shot him well it probably wasn't very comforting to hear the reply, "Well he didn't." (or something like that.) That's what Clay would've said.

      Tim, the "long term strategist" thing is what makes the season fun and similar to season 3, but at the same time so many ridiculous things have to fall into place to make it work. I guess that's the soap aspect. Just an example, there's no way no how Pope would've taken Jax under his wing and trusted him like that. Pope is supposed to be so street smart and savvy, yet he doesn't have his guard up against the man who's best friend was killed per his own orders?

      My biggest complaint about the series and in my humble opinion what keeps it from being "great", is that the characters have always been manipulated for the purposes of the plot instead of being true to themselves. It makes for fun soapy entertainment but it also prevents the show from having the credibility it needs to be one of the great ones. (Again obviously my opinion.)

      December 5, 2012 at 12:25PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Daniel Gemma is too obvious plot-wise to have informed on Tara. She would have had to give and then sign a statement to the police (and then know she would be called as a witness, guaranteeing Jax would exact some form of revenge in due course).

      Gemma is ruthless, but not that stupid. And first visit Jax makes to Tara in prison, he will hear of Gemma's threat anyway, so she needs to say she got emotional and know the evidence will point elsewhere.

      However, with Gemma listening in on Nero and Jax's conversation, she does need to keep them both in charming . . . how she continues to do this will depend on the creativity of the scriptwriters here on in.

      As for Otto biting off his tongue. The symbolism might have been that he wouldn't talk, but I think the legal angle is that he is criminally insane, and any testimony is worthless.

      As for Jax playing the silent Delphic (or Machiavellian) type with Bobbie, it does cause one to wonder how much he wants to not end up like Clay. Telling his VP that this was the only play to (a) save Tig's life, (b) guarantee the club's existence and (c) avenge Opie's death would have been more, um, 'presidential'. It certainly would rendered Bobby speechless if asked: "So how would YOU have achieved these outcomes, bro?"

      December 7, 2012 at 9:19AM EST
  • Default-avatar

    (forgot my password) Leo

    Meant to add, I agree with you Geoff about Nero surviving. I thought Jimmy Smits sold every scene he was in this season and he can only improve this show by his presence.

    December 5, 2012 at 4:11AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Jimmy D

    We get it, Hitfix. You guys didn't like Sutter criticizing your reviews the last two years. Nevermind that everyone else at EW, AV Club, IGN, etc. has loved this season and loved the finale.

    Keep on grudging...

    December 5, 2012 at 4:12AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Matt Agreed. Hitfix hates Sutter, it's the reason Sepinwall stopped doing recaps for SOA. He tried to put it off on his "excessive fall/winter workload of shows" but we know the truth. I love Sepinwall, he's my favorite reviewer of all time, but it was pretty transparent as to why he quit recapping this show. My question is why they would get this Geoff dude to do it, when he obviously doesn't even like the show anymore. It shows man, it really does. And it makes your recaps sound rather petty and snippy. Either find someone to do it justice or just f'ing quit doing them.

      December 5, 2012 at 5:38AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Jimmy D Agreed, I enjoy the site and most other reviews but it was blatantly obvious why Sepinwall stopped reviewing the show. And now looking back it's more obvious why they chose someone who doesn't really like the show to fill in for the recaps.

      The show isn't perfect, and neither is Sutter. But man, all these HitFix SoA reviews just reek of a need to point out flaws rather than actually recap the episodes. It's the same criticism every week - "repetitive". They have nothing else to say, really.

      December 5, 2012 at 7:07AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Steve Sons is a male soap opera. A little more violent,but its the A-Team on bikes. The first 30 minutes were a waste of time. Why show the SOA joining with Nero's supposed crew take on almost 30 rivals and see the pits fighting? What happened during those scenes that advanced the story?

      December 5, 2012 at 8:38AM EST
    • I think Geoff's reviews are pretty good, actually. I don't know if hitfix had any ulterior motives (which sounds way too conspiracy theorist), and I don't really care.
      I like to make fun of this show and I'm glad someone reviews it so that I have the chance. You guys need to join a SOA support group.

      December 5, 2012 at 10:03AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      (forgot my password) Leo "Nevermind that everyone else at EW, AV Club, IGN, etc. has loved this season and loved the finale."

      I'm not sure it's ever persuasive an argument to say someone's opinion is wrong by naming those that share your own opinion. You need to back up what you say with convincing argument. You know, why do you disagree with Geoff and why did you like it.

      Steve, I thought the scenes with Nero's gang and especially the dog-fighting scenes were really important. The fight scenes showed both Jax and Nero getting deeper and deeper into the gang/club life and the dog scenes humanized the Sons. Especially Tig, who from the past we knew his great love was a dog. Loved the scenes with Tig at the end with the dog which showed Tig being able to love and feel again, as corny as that sounds.

      December 5, 2012 at 12:39PM EST
    • Tattoo_talkback_profile

      Hatfield Just to offer the less civilized and eloquent version of what Leo said, there's a whole lot of stupid in the top of this thread

      December 5, 2012 at 6:18PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    DutchViewer

    Anyone else notice the subtle handshake between Jax and August?

    December 5, 2012 at 5:04AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Matt Yes. I think he is not too upset about Pope's death. Now he's Top Dog and will be making the crazy money. If Pope can afford to just shell out 5 million for his death, that means 5 million ain't shit to him. August is gonna be sitting pretty, on top and in charge. It doesn't behoove him to go postal over Popes death.

      December 5, 2012 at 5:41AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Prettok It didnt behoove Jax financially to go postal over Opies death. Is SAMCRO the only crew in town to act purely out of brotherhood loyalty?

      December 5, 2012 at 9:22AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Mike Why wasn't August w Pope at the meeting w Jax and Tig? He's Popes right hand man...kinda convient he was absent at such an important meeting. Me thinks Jax had a deal w him....

      December 5, 2012 at 9:41AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Darkdoug He told Pope that he'd be busy with the work there, and Pope bought it, so I'm thinking that's simply fortuitous on his part. If he had been there too, he'd have gone down and Jax would be shaking hands with whoever ranked behind him on the org chart.

      December 5, 2012 at 10:53AM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Sam

    We've left Hamlet for Oedipus. We get it Kurt, Gemma is always going to win. The rape comment was beyond disgusting.

    Pretty predictable season finale, lackluster season, lots of pointless stuff, HELLO! C-List guest stars!

    And yeah as someone who is fluent in french, J'ai Obtenu Cette has been driving me nuts, it's not I Got This.

    December 5, 2012 at 9:33AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Andyw SAM - If you don't like SOA, then don't watch it! I am a huge fan and admire Kurt Sutters ability to add (believable) twists to not only finale but each episode.
      Only criticism I agree with is Gemma's rape remark... Prob unnecessary ...

      December 5, 2012 at 10:13AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Darkdoug But not out of character or anything. It's SUPPOSED to make Gemma look bad - she and Tara have repeatedly expressed their love for each other, and this just shows exactly how Gemma's selfishness takes precedence over any other concerns or humanity.

      Abuse victims are not saints, nor are they automatically soldiers in the anti-abuse fight. It is well-known how such things occur in cycles, with abusers turning around and visiting their own traumas on others. If she were the one in prison, I could easily see Gemma inflicting such on women who crossed her. Nor is it outside the realm of possibility that Gemma is harboring some irrational resentment at Tara from her own rape. Tara was her closest confidant and main source of support in those days, and here she is, threatening her with jail in order to appease her own selfish interest in her grandsons. Guilt and/or shame makes her say the worst possible thing she can to Tara, in an "I wish it would happen to you" sort of way - the corollary of survivor's guilt.

      Is it completely unjustified? Absolutely. Is it realistic? Also absolutely. There are horrible people in the world, and Gemma is one of their fictional counterparts. The low point for Jax, the reviewers seem to think, is his drugging Wendy, but who was the first person to do that? Gemma herself, only in an attempt to murder her! We've gotten too used to the good side of the Mama Bear, with all the danger her descendants have found themselves in over the last 5 seasons, and the alliance with the other woman in their lives, that we have forgotten that "Mama Bear" in reality is a fearsome threat no sane person wants anything to do with. Her victimization at the hands of Zobelle & Clay in Seasons 2 & 4 also artificially inflated her sympathetic role.

      The Gemma we saw, heard and suspect of the S5 finale would come as no surprise to anyone who had only watched the pilot episode.

      December 5, 2012 at 11:16AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Daniel I think we have confused the Gemma issue.

      Gemma has always been a damn tough biker's bitch/old lady. She may as well be Medea, only in reverse: she won't kill her boys but would do anything to anyone else who got in her access to them. Hell, she killed (more or less) Jax's father. Her unethical side isn't the problem.

      Now, we don't expect her to do volunteer work in a rape crisis centre after being bashed and raped. But it would be nice to see a touch of humanity there somewhere. That's just what's called fleshing out a character. Even if she still ends up choosing the least ethical behaviour, it would be nice to see her wrestle with her inner demons. Hell, everyone else does, even Tig. . . . even Clay (or at least he pretends to do so).

      As for the bad French. Frigging hell, Chucky is mangling French now for the first time in this episode, and the title of this same episode is also in French. And you are complaining about correct grammar? Please!

      December 7, 2012 at 9:38AM EST
  • Photo_15_talkback_profile

    Jordo

    This series desperately needs an end game, because this season was a chore to get through.

    December 5, 2012 at 10:54AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Steve Wow there is something wrong with you. This has been the best season of SONS yet.

      December 5, 2012 at 11:23AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      John So because he didn't care for this season, there's something wrong with him? Great argument. And this has not been the best season, not even close (it's Season 2 by a landslide), but I wouldn't suggest that there was something wrong with you for thinking so.

      December 5, 2012 at 4:08PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Steve

    The guy who wrote this is lame..You will never be successful in life. This season of SOA has been terrific. SOA is one of the greatest shows of all time already but this season is the greatest season in TV history. The guy who wrote this article should stop watching this show if he does not like violence or if things get too graphic for him. Go watch gossip girl SOA is not for you. SOA has surpassed Breaking Bad as the best show in the last 5 years. The way it's going it may eventually take over The Shield as the greatest TV show of all time. I could understand if the writer said The Dublin season was not great but this season had it all. Kurt Sutter is amazing as what he does.

    December 5, 2012 at 11:21AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      madmeme It's alright, Kurt. Calm down, now. The show was fine - you did a decent enough job; a few holes in the plot, but nothing major this time.

      December 5, 2012 at 11:32AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      John It's better than Breaking Bad? It's going to end up as the greatest show ever (actually, that's what Breaking Bad is going to do)? I mean...wow. I can't take anything else you say seriously after that. And no, this season was not great or even that good. It was fine. The third season was worse, but this was probably the second weakest of the run. It's just that it's the same old thing over and over again. The club makes a bunch of seemingly formidable enemies and/or create untenable situations in which some characters need to die. Then, Kurt Sutter comes up with some BS way to get out of everything when the "formidable" enemies are actually pretty stupid (seriously, why wouldn't Pope just kill Jax *and* Tig, and why would August just buy Jax's unconvincing "explanation"), and something happens to prevent anyone who actually matters from dying. Yes, Opie died this season, but that sort of came out of nowhere and was problematic for different reasons (e.g. that Sutter just felt like killing a major character for the hell of it). Honestly, the only thing this season accomplished for me was wanting Jax dead. I can't believe I'm saying this, but I'm actually rooting for Clay at this point. This is what happens when the writers cop out of killing off a character when his time has come.

      December 5, 2012 at 7:22PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Darkdoug

    Another cheek shot! Just yesterday or so, I was commenting on another show's review about how that seems to be the popular death wound on TV these days.

    December 5, 2012 at 11:22AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    madmeme

    Talk about a deus ex machina: Chuckie goes to Jax's house to drop off some car mats - and he brings back the 'congratulatory' flowers (which happened to be delivered that very day) to a GARAGE - where the woman the flowers are addressed to neither lives nor works. Sheesh....

    December 5, 2012 at 11:29AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Griff Yea you are not using the term "deus ex machina" correctly. I wouldn't say a clearly slightly off guy bringing the flowers sitting outside a house in California that belongs to his boss to his boss' place of business instead of just leaving them outside would act as "god in the machine"

      December 5, 2012 at 12:07PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      madmeme Uh, you know it's not literal, right? I would say that what I described is precisely a 'difficult or unsolvable problem (Gemma finding out Tara took the job when no one else knows) that is suddenly and conviently solved with the contrived intervention of some character.'

      December 5, 2012 at 12:26PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      madmeme Actually, it's two things - the contrived 'new event' (the sending of the flowers) - and the 'intervention of the character' (Chuckie). I think you're not aware of what the term actually means.

      December 5, 2012 at 12:30PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Griff Yes I know it isn't literal but is this really an unsolvable problem a la RICO last year? The explanation alone really was understandable as I had mentioned. This is a loony guy to begin with and see flowers outside his boss' house and brings them to his place of work. This is among the smallest things to complain about and to claim it is "deus ex machina" I find to be reducing the term in value, to how most people over use "jump the shark" to the point that it has remove its actual value

      December 5, 2012 at 12:35PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      madmeme Of course it isn't an unsolvable problem (there is no such thing in fiction) - or something even close to the level of the CIA twist from last season. But all I know is that it struck me while I was watching it as silly and contrived - and that always takes me out of the drama. And all of Gemma's actions towards Tara for the rest of the episode stem from that 'plot point'.

      December 5, 2012 at 12:45PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      (forgot my password) Leo It may not be deus ex machine but it's definitely contrivance, which is the soap aspect of the show. They needed to have Gemma know about this at that point in time so they have Chuckie bring the flowers to her. That kind of thing happens a lot in this show.

      Similar to later on when Gemma just happened to be in a place where she could overhear Jax telling Nero (or inferring to him) that he wasn't going to leave SOA, which was an important thing for her to hear.

      December 5, 2012 at 12:46PM EST
    • Ron-swanson-manly_pic_talkback_profile

      Timm S Yeah, I laughed at the congratulations basket coming to the garage right about the time I was wondering how Gemma is going to find out/put a wrench in Tara's plans to get out. THIS SHOW IS A SOAP OPERA. Sorry for using my outside voice.

      December 5, 2012 at 2:23PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Daniel No, the flowers didn't make sense being delivered there (Tara would have been more careful), but the CIA deal has made no sense this season. At all!

      The CIA wanted the Real IRA, not another contrived weapons deal, which the Agency could handle a hell of a lot better anyway. Remember, they needed Clay for the Real IRA connection. The guns wee never the main issue.

      Maybe someone else can make sense of that, as I simply gave up.

      December 7, 2012 at 10:44AM EST
    • Ron-swanson-manly_pic_talkback_profile

      Timm S @DANIEL: The way I thought it went, the CIA was backing the Galindo cartel in their war against the other cartel(s), leading to them needing the IRA for guns to use in that war. So, it was about the guns to control their war, not a sting on the IRA. That was what the ATF (Stahl & Co) was going for, not the CIA. Regardless, the show dropped it after the big drama the week prior.

      I might not be understanding everything correctly, but I think that's how it played.

      December 7, 2012 at 1:41PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Ed G.

    I really just don't like the montages. They just fill out time for more commercials without doing anything at all to move the story or develop character. But at least Jane's Addiction's arrangement for "Sympathy for the Devil" was superb.

    I had it in the back of my mind that they might pose Gemma as the Old Lady behind the President, like Tara behind Jax and Gemma behind John Teller. It can't be good if even I was able to foretell that one.

    December 5, 2012 at 11:39AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      (forgot my password) Leo I may be in the minority but I HATED the opening montage and that song just sounded so corny and schmaltzy for a show like this. Did care for the rendition of the final montage but at least it fit the mood better. (And I'm a fan of Jane's Addiction.)

      December 5, 2012 at 12:47PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      (forgot my password) Leo Meant "didn't" care for the rendition of the final song.

      December 5, 2012 at 12:58PM EST
    • Ron-swanson-manly_pic_talkback_profile

      Timm S (FMP)L, I think Geoff got it right about the opening montage, that Sutter finally found a place-not a good place, mind you-to shoehorn a Katey Sagal song in one of his famed montages. I got a nice laugh when my wife, who never watches this with me but was this week, jerked her head up and asked (incredulously), "What is this song?!?! It doesn't really fit this show at all!" Only in Sutter's World, Lovely Wife.

      December 5, 2012 at 2:29PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    brian eno

    Soooooooooooo, we are supposed to believe someone as cunning as Clay would leave a murder weapon half way up the hill at the murder scene?

    December 5, 2012 at 12:28PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      jgin Dude: the Chief knows it was a SET-UP. He doesn't care. He simply wants revenge for his wife's murder.

      December 5, 2012 at 1:52PM EST
    • Ron-swanson-manly_pic_talkback_profile

      Timm S I'm not sure you understood how that all shook out.

      December 5, 2012 at 2:29PM EST
  • Ron-swanson-manly_pic_talkback_profile

    Timm S

    Off the top, thanks to Geoff for covering this season. I know it's been an up and down one for you, and you've taken plenty of fire from some reading these reviews, but it's been good work and has given us at least a jumping off point to talk about SoA, and (for me at least) more than not some great perspective and insights upon which to chew. Thank you.

    This show. I'll start from the end and then just wander from there. The Montage, which has now turned from something irritating to soothing in its consistency, had a prominent place tonight, and both of them featured the one thing I hate about Sons: Katey Sagal. Her singing in the first, her winning in the last. And before I get assaulted, YES I know she's married to Kurt Sutter , and YES I know he's going for a dimestore version of HAMLET with his story, and YES I've read Hamlet. So, while it seems silly to watch/invest in a show where one of the two main figures is someone I don't like watching, I do it anyway. Call it irritainment, if you must. Still, as much as her performances bother me, it made narrative sense to have her win the day over Tara. While it didn't make crystal clear it was Gemma who dropped dime on Tara, you know that's how it went down. If for no other reason than Sutter didn't spell out it was Toric (or somebody else) in flashing neon letters, as is his custom. Sons is many things; subtle is not one of them.

    Once again, we get another wonderful gunfight scene from Jax & crew, and in a designed-for-assasination warehouse to boot. I mean, Tig was right, there were no cages or anything peripherally related to dogs there. Jax's master plans and his role as puppet master do make him look other worldly smart, but maybe not really.(?) Everything has to fall the exact way he thinks it will, with ZERO deviation, or else the whole plan is shot to hell. This requires us to believe 1. Jax is gifted with the ability to anticipate the actions of others based upon his extraordinary understanding of human psychology, or 2. he can see the future, or maybe 3. this show is the television equivalent of a Hostess (RIP) SnoBall, with nothing redeeming and you feel dirty after you eat it, but it sure is a lot of fun to eat. Maybe it's the third one? Not sure it was a meta-commentary on the show, but my big laugh out loud moment of the night was after the shootout and Tog kills Pope, Tig asks Jax, "What if he killed me outside?" (or something), and Jax responds with, "That was just a risk I had to take." Perfect. Just perfect. So very soapy and silly, and the exact right thing I wanted to hear.

    Also, did we not get even ONE episode where Jax showed his ass? Can we not dedicate some time to how SoA has moved on from this reliable trope? JaxAss and KateySong have been to me what Penny was to Desmond (my Contant. Anyone?), and I feel a little out of sorts. Says the heterosexual father of four. Somewhere my life has ventured off course...

    All in all, SoA Fandom, a successful season. I was entertained and engaged all year, and Tuesday night was stopdown viewing time for me every week. And I LOVED the last four eps being 1.5 hours. Big score. In my opinion, this is a lowdown, dirty, fun little show that is (generally) well acted (apart from Sagal Sturgeon Face, Phil Who Likes Cereal and Only Cries-a-lot Juice), has some great, fun violence, and a story I like watching. And I look forward to its return. In the meantime, bring on Spartacus! All that SoA aspires to, with consistent character development, generous use of the word "cunt", awkward phrasing and plenty of naked people.

    Again, apologies for the length. It's been a fun season.

    December 5, 2012 at 3:46PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      madmeme Nice summary. I agree with all your points - and particularly your assessment about the acting (Sagal = painful).

      And yes, Hostess SnoBall indeed. Last season was like finding a dead cockroach in the last bite, but this season was just the disgusting goodness all the way through.

      December 5, 2012 at 4:43PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    jan

    I thought someone commented on the fact that one of the newbies in the club was on Raising Hope--and wearing his cut even--but now I don't see the comment. It was pretty funny to see this guy brought down by a little girl--his niece, I think--who had a splinter that he didn't know how to get out.

    December 6, 2012 at 10:51AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Goodkarmarider

    This show has the blood of the kids from Sandy Hook Elementery on it's face and hands!!!! It is violence porn that is traash. Who is watching this evil shit??? Why do you like to see all this violence? It is killing our children? Our Youth? Please stop, how do the people behind this show sleep? Do they have children? Do they care about your children? No all they care about is your money. They have no morals. The show runner Sutter had his own wife gangbanged on his own show what a PIG!!!! The bar has been dropped to a new low here.

    December 17, 2012 at 5:43PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Mahmoud Fayed Your punishment must be more severe

      December 28, 2012 at 11:56PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Velho

    The crazy lady was played by Donal Logue's sister from "Terriers". She was a nut ball in that as well.

    January 9, 2013 at 2:31AM EST Reply to Comment

Get Instant Alerts on Breaking News

Latest Posts
More Posts
Recent Activity on Facebook
Most Popular on Facebook
Top Stories From Around the Web