Could Cheryl Cole return?
Rate This Image
Music cred: 6 Grammy Awards. 60 million records sold worldwide. Three #1 hits including a little diddy you might have heard of called "Un-Break My Heart."
Why she would be good: She knows music and she's shown a personality on her reality TV show "Braxton Family Values."
Why she could suck: She might be too nice for the show. You need judges who are going to get into it with Simon and Toni might be a bit too intimidated.
Chances: 30%. Well, WE tv would love it to he help promote her "Values" and Braxton could use the national exposure. With her biggest years behind her, she wouldn't be on the top of Cowell's list. - Gregory Ellwood