The nominees are...

Eminem: "We Made You"
Kanye West: "Love Lockdown"
Jay-Z: "D.O.A (Death of Auto-Tune)"
T.I. featuring Rihanna: "Live Your Life"
Ne-Yo: "Miss Independent"

We predict...

Melinda: Eminem, "We Made You"  Slim Shady's parody will reign supreme over more high-concept clips, such as T.I.'s "Momento"-inspired "Live Your Life."

Katie: Eminem, "We Made You." I have a feeling that "Jessica's fat" jokes are still going over really well.

Greg: T.I. ft. Rihanna "Live Your Life." Yeah, he's in jail, but  Eminem is old school a shadow of his former self.  T.I.'s track was a bigger hit and of the time.  Slim Shady loses this one.