We're glad we weren't the ones on the spot
Next gallery »10 Singers You Forgot Were Oscar Nominees
« Previous galleryDeath of the Rom-Com: 11 Worst Cliches of the Moribund Genre
Rod Steiger vs. Warren Beatty, Dustin Hoffman, Paul Newman and Spencer Tracy (1967)
Now here's a throwdown we couldn't even begin to address. Rod Steiger won for "In the Heat of the Night," the year's Best Picture winner and a truly deserving choice. But Warren Beatty in "Bonnie and Clyde?" Dustin Hoffman in "The Graduate?" Paul Newman in "Cool Hand Luke?" Spencer Tracy's final performance in "Guess Who's Coming to Dinner" (he died shortly after shooting)? You try to pick just one and feel 100% satisfied.