Brandon and Janette brought the judges to their feet, while Randi and Evan faced tough critiques
Jason Glover and Caitlin Kinney of 'So You Think You Can Dance'
Caitlin and Jason - Performance #1
Choreographers: Tony Meredith and Melanie LaPatin, foxtrot
Monkeys As Critics' Verdict: Like buttah
Caitlin is excited to be elegant and pretty, and right from the get-go you can tell she just feels a whole hell of a lot more comfortable in her spangly dress than she did as a rubber condom alien. The routine looked effortless and elegant and probably will bore the crap out of voters who have gotten used to dancers defying gravity and flopping around the stage like freshly executed convicts. I mean, come on, I get tired just looking at some of these routines. Graceful and elegant doesn't exactly wow, you know?
Nigel said Caitlin made everything look easy "like Grace Kelly" and added that Jason's footwork was very good indeed. Mary said it was tremendous and thought the foxtrot suited them. Then she stole Toasty Oreo's snaps, and there was a brief snap off at the judges' table, which was admittedly odd and I'm sure Caitlin and Jason wanted to break Mary and Toasty Oreo's fingers for wasting their time. Toasty Oreo said they looked fantastic, but felt Caitlin could have glided more and shown more in her eyes, whatever that means.