Caitlin & Jason left the judges confused, but Melissa & Ade and Brandon & Janette got top marks
Next gallery »Emmy Nomination Preview 2009 - Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy
« Previous galleryMeet the 'Big Brother 11' cast
Jason Glover and Caitlin Kinney of 'So You Think You Can Dance'
Caitlin and Jason
Choreographer: Brian Friedman, jazz
Monkeys As Critics' Verdict: Eaten by aliens
God, I was hoping they could bring it. But she’s an alien who has to procreate with the last human? Really? That sounds... friggin’ awful. Really friggin’ awful. What the hell is wrong with you, Brian? You have one of the prettier girls in the contest this week and you make her look like a damn latex lizard. They were in the bottom three two weeks in a row and you couldn’t throw ‘em a bone? I mean, seriously, they’re so screwed.
The judges tried to find something nice to say, like loving parents at a nightmare school play. Nigel said it was very weird, but praised them for committed themselves 100 percent and noted that Caitlin looked like a dancing condom. Mary didn’t think it played to their strengths and it didn’t sit right with her. Mia said the only thing she didn’t like was the tin foil but thought it was fun.