Are Casey James and Andrew Garcia the clear favorites? Might another Lambert reign?
Next gallery »'American Idol' Top 24 - Top 12 Men performance gallery
« Previous gallery'American Idol' Top 24 - Top 12 Women performance gallery
Tim Urban of 'American Idol'
Think: A weird cross of Zac Efron and John Peter Lewis
Our Unscientific Hunch Before the Top 24: We didn't see Tim during the auditions and he popped up in Hollywood for a mediocre first solo and a dreadful performance on Group Day. Then he only made it into the Top 24 because of the silliness with that Golightly kid (whose audition was far better). Under normal circumstances, I'd guess that Urban would be the one of the first men out, but this year's male crop is so weak he'll probably get several weeks to prove himself. I still reckon he's gone before the Top 12, but he's boy-band-friendly enough that young women may vote for him for a couple weeks.
Photo Credit: FOX