Beware: Soilers ahead
Next gallery »Best Actor Oscar Contenders 2015
« Previous gallery10 Stories You Might Have Missed: Dwayne Johnson to lead 'Baywatch' remake
Worst: Those slight gaps in logic
Where to begin? Here are just a few: Why didn't the police think it was strange Nick would have all those things he supposedly bought for himself stacked so neatly and unopened in the shed? How could Amy buying a car on Craigslist go so unnoticed? How could Nick really not have a clue that Amy had spent any significant time bonding with their neighbor, Noelle (Casey Wilson)? Why did no one notice a woman covered in blood driving over a hundred miles home in a car without tinted windows? Wouldn't Desi's friends, family or co-workers question that he could have kidnapped Amy since he was nowhere near the city she lived in at the time?
- Gregory Ellwood