Relive the best (Siobhan, Crystal) and worst (Tim, Andrew) of Tuesday's Rolling Stones Night performances
Next gallery »'American Idol' Top 11 performances - Billboard Hot 100 Night Gallery
« Previous gallery'American Idol' Top 12 Interviews
Casey James of 'American Idol' performs on Rolling Stones Night
Singer: Casey James
Song: "It's All Over Now"
Monkeys As Critics' Take: Yikes. That's, um, quite a story Casey has. And his mother appears to be Katey Sagal. Casey's got his guitar and a certain honky-tonk swagger. There's a version of the Rolling Stones whether they're the best bar band in history and Casey's playing a pleasant and low-key version of that Rolling Stones. He's not hugely impressive and he's a little bit lost in the middle of the stage, but he's still solid and he looks like he's enjoying the audience approval. This is a performance, like so many of Casey's performances, that would be better in a small, dark bar. His personality just isn't big enough yet. But the vocals are on-key and the guitar playing contributes to the performance without being obtrusive.
Randy, Ellen, Kara and Simon Say: Randy says that Casey James can make a career like this, hailing that Casey is back. Ellen says that for most women, their hearts will race looking at him. "But for people like me... blondes... I thought it was fantastic," Ellen says. That was probably her best moment in a few weeks. Kara says that tonight Casey wasn't trying to be a rock star, he actually was a rock star. Simon disagrees. "For me, that was like an audition performance," Simon warns Casey, saying that he didn't use the stage or the audience well enough.