Relive the best (Siobhan, Crystal) and worst (Tim, Andrew) of Tuesday's Rolling Stones Night performances
Next gallery »'American Idol' Top 11 performances - Billboard Hot 100 Night Gallery
« Previous gallery'American Idol' Top 12 Interviews
The 'American Idol' Season Nine Top 12
TUESDAY'S BEST: I don't disagree with Simon. Siobhan was the clear winner tonight. But there were a lot of solid alternatives if you felt that Siobhan was too dramatic. I think Didi and Crystal were also standouts. Really, of the 12 performances, I'm not gonna quibble if people to get behind maybe seven or eight performances.
TUESDAY'S WORST: Done in by the arrangement (and, you know, his talent), Tim Urban was the night's worst. Then again, I also thought Andrew Garcia was pretty bad. And I *like* Andrew.