Who contributed the best and worst moments of FOX's big night?
'American Idol' Finale Loser: Scotty McCreery against Tim McGraw
Lucky Scotty McCreery got to sing "Live Like You Were Dying" with Idol Tim McGraw. Unfortunately, the duet only exposed Scotty's inexperience and lack of nuance against McGraw's confident professionalism. None of the other duet stars left their Idol comrades in the dust so thoroughly.