Next gallery »Alan Sepinwall and Drew McWeeny Pick Parenthood's Greatest Tearjerkers
« Previous galleryWho Needs Lorne Michaels? 14 sketch comedy stars who skipped 'SNL'
Why it was unlikely: The craggy noir icon certainly wasn't an obvious choice for an "SNL" hosting stint, particularly since his career had peaked decades earlier.
How'd it go? Not bad! Mitchum's casual energy was a better fit for Studio 8H than anyone could have anticipated. Never underestimate a good pair of glasses.