With Ryan Reynolds not interested, WB may be looking to replace Hal Jordan
- Next gallery - 3 new 'Star Trek Into Darkness' images
- Previous gallery - 10 Stories you might have missed: J.J. Abrams talks about his abandoned Superman idea
Ben Foster - Guy Gardner
Best known for: "3:10 to Yuma," "The Messenger"
Why: Foster often plays supporting characters on the fringe who have a way of getting under your skin ("30 Days of Night," "Yuma," "The Punisher"), and he would likely have a field day playing the petulant Guy Gardner, who grates on the nerves of fellow JL members like Batman. While the skinny Foster would have to do some serious bulking up, he's already done the superhero thing before, albeit for Marvel, in "X-Men: The Last Stand."