'Top Chef' - 'Advantage Chef': I'm trying to tell you now, it's sabotage!
Is it a flaw that Jamie has survived two elimination challenges where she didn't serve a dish?
A quick review of last night's "Top Chef" coming up just as soon as I freeze things so I can smash them...
Again, because Liane Bonin's been doing regular recaps of the show for our Monkeys as Critics blog, my "Top Chef" check-ins are going to be irregular. I would've written about last week's episode - which featured one of the most thoughtful and entertaining elimination challenges the show has ever done - except I was taking a few days off mid-week. But though I didn't like "Advantage Chef" as much, I probably have more to say about it.
Specifically, I'm bothered as hell that Jamie has now survived two separate eliminations in which either didn't make or didn't serve a dish to the judges.
There are certain quirks to the judging system, wherein great chefs can go home relatively early, and/or mediocre chefs can last a very long time simply by making the second-worst dish week after week (Lisa from season 4, I'm looking at you). But that's just the way the show works, and if the judges really are only considering that week's dish, that sort of thing is going to happen on occasion.
This feels different, though. A few weeks ago, Jamie bailed on the elimination challenge because she cut her finger, and while that's an understandable move, she still didn't help make a dish, and we've seen in the past, and in this very episode with Carla, that the cheftestants are used to slapping on some duct tape and barreling through. But Jamie went to the hospital and got a pass from the judges.
This week was even more annoying, as the challenge was designed so that every chef wouldn't necessarily have to serve a dish. And by hanging back and consistently refusing to serve her undercooked beans, Jamie got to duck elimination in a week where she seemed to clearly have the worst dish. And that just doesn't seem fair. If the judges ate it and felt that Spike's shrimp was still worse, so be it. But one of the things that distinguishes "Top Chef" from many other reality shows is that every contestant is supposed to be judged on their work every single week. It's not supposed to be like "Survivor" where someone can sit out tons of challenges and just keep hanging around. If a challenge is constructed in such a way that one or more chefs won't have to serve a dish, then that challenge should be scrapped or reconceptualized until everyone has to go. (Had the other team gone on a 4-0 sweep, then a bunch of the losing team wouldn't have had to serve.) I'm not actually that broken up about Spike's elimination on its own. He always struck me as someone who was cast more for personality than for talent, but it would sit much better if he'd gone home because his was the actual worst dish on his team, as opposed to the worst dish that anyone bothered to put in front of the judges.
Beyond that, it's interesting to see that the field is so deep that there isn't a clear favorite, or even a clear handful. For a while, it looked like Blais was going to run away with the contest, and the other chefs still seem to view him as the one to beat, but he hasn't stood out for a couple of weeks. Angelo's the only repeat elimination challenge winner, but one of those was a shared win with Richard and Marcel, and I'll be curious to see if the reputation for sabotage eventually bites him. (I didn't watch his season, but if he's really done this a lot? Ugh.)
What did everybody else think? And how are you finding the All-Star season so far?
News From Our Partners
- EA Teases Possible Star Wars: Battlefront Return Tom Cruise Leaves 'Man From U.N.C.L.E.' to Focus on 'Mission: Impossible 5′ Black Ops 2 Revolution DLC Free This Weekend
- 'Fast & Furious 6': The Reviews Are In! 'Return Of The Jedi' Turns 30: Secrets Of Ewok Language Revealed! 'Fast & Furious 6' Expected To Lap 'Hangover III' At Box Office
- "Fast & Furious 6" vs. "The Hangover: Part III": Which Movie Should You See? (VIDEO) 'Fast and Furious 6' Review: 10 Things You Should Know About the Action-Packed Sequel 'After Earth' Unscripted: Will and Jaden Smith on Filming With Deadly Snakes & On-Set Parenting (VIDEO)
- The Telefile - The Most Heinous Person on Reality TV This Week The Telefile - Does Someone Have to Go?: Work Sucks.... If You Are On This Show The Telefile - Save Me: Lightning Strikes NBC
- Critics Consensus: Fast & Furious 6 is Certified Fresh Red Carpet Photos with Vin Diesel, Michelle Rodriguez, Gina Carano and More Video: The Hangover Part III Cast Interviews
- Hear This: “Second Best” reflects a pivotal moment all serious bands face Watch This: The wages and the fear remain high in William Friedkin’s Sorcerer Cannes Film Festival: Cannes 2013, Day Nine: James Gray and Joaquin Phoenix reteam for a compelling period drama
- Why He Fell Asleep During That Interview Alex Trebek Has Gone Completely Insane Arrested Development Could Really Teach Politicians A Thing Or Two
- fun. Hit the Jersey Shore for 2013 'TODAY Show' Summer Concert Series Jennifer Hudson Reportedly Confirmed as 'American Idol' Judge Meet the Woman Who Won PopCrush's Autographed Pink Guitar!
Steven Soderbergh biopic about Liberace is HBO's best movie in yearsFriday, May 24, 2013
Will gets lost in a case, and Lecter tries to protect Abigail HobbsThursday, May 23, 2013
Announcing this summer's blog rewatch seriesThursday, May 23, 2013
The Dunphys and Pritchetts head to Florida for the funeral of Phil's momThursday, May 23, 2013