Cannes Film Festival 2013

'The Wire' Rewind: Season 3, Episode 4 - 'Hamsterdam' (Newbies edition)

McNulty goes rogue, Carcetti announces a plan, and Cutty looks for work.

<p>A tense moment at the MCU on "The Wire."</p>

A tense moment at the MCU on "The Wire."

Credit: HBO

Once again, we're spending Fridays this summer revisiting season three of "The Wire." (You can find my reviews of all the other seasons at my old blog.) Two versions each week: one for people who have seen the whole series and want to feel free to discuss things from first episode to last, and one for relative newcomers who haven't seen all the way to the end yet and don't want to be spoiled past the episodes we're discussing. This is the newbie version; click here to read the veteran-friendly one. (Last week's newbie review is here.)

A review of episode four, "Hamsterdam," coming up just as soon as I have to tinkle...

"Game done changed." -Cutty
"Game the same. Just got more fierce." -Slim Charles

A couple of weeks ago, I noted that season three is unique to this point in the series in that it opens up with Lt. Daniels' unit intact and operational from jump. Four episodes into the season, though, it's now clear that this is a less notable distinction than it seemed at first. Yes, the show doesn't have to spend time on the usual gathering of the team scenes we got in the first two years, but the Major Crimes Unit has accomplished as little as the original Barksdale or Sobotka details had by this point in their respective seasons. They blew the wire on Cheese in episode two (and even there were taking a very roundabout approach towards Stringer), are technically assigned to work Kintell Williamson and are so behind the eightball on the state of the West Baltimore drug trade that they assume Marlo is working for Stringer, not against him.

And that lack of progress eats at McNulty, and at Lester, to the point where the two men nearly come to blows. In many ways, Lester and Jimmy are the same cop, born a couple of decades apart, but age has tamed whatever demons Lester had just enough that he doesn't feel the need to "put fire to everything you touch" the way McNulty does. Backed into a corner, Lester will figure out how to live in that corner, where Jimmy would try to blow up the room.

It's a hell of a scene, very nicely played by both Clarke Peters and Dominic West, and one that plays comfortably in that moral grey area "The Wire" loves so much. McNulty was our point-of-entry character, and he's so smart and charming that we like him in spite of his multitude of flaws. Lester, meanwhile, is the wise old man who is nearly always proven right. When these two fight, and when it gets this ugly, whose side are we supposed to take? Given our investment in seeing the cops take down Stringer, I suppose McNulty - and even Lester comes around as soon as Jimmy and Kima are out the door and it becomes about the case and not Jimmy being an ass - but I love that the show was willing to go there, and to show McNulty unafraid to put even his closest allies behind his personal demons. By the end of the episode, he's seen where he stands with Elena (preferably far away, as far as she's concerned), and learned about the Pearlman/Daniels affair, and he's all alone at a bar with no one to call and nowhere to go at closing time. Lester and Bunk argued last year that putting Jimmy back on real cases wouldn't put out the fire that burns inside him, but might lower it to manageable levels. We see throughout "Hamsterdam" that this isn't entirely the case - that in some ways, in fact, working these kinds of cases only makes Jimmy's extremes even worse.

Jimmy, Lester and Kima aren't the only characters battling frustration in this episode, though. Bunny Colvin suffers through a pointless community relations meeting and at least temporarily quiets the angry crowd(*) by being as candid with them as he is with Rawls at Comstat.

(*) Whose membership includes The Big Man, Clarence Clemmons, from The E Street Band. Steve Van Zandt's not the only member of the band who can hang on HBO, right?

What he can't tell them, though, is that he does have a solution in mind, and unfortunately for him, that solution doesn't work out as well in reality as it did in Bunny's head. Nothing on "The Wire" ever comes easily, or quickly, so of course the slingers and hoppers wouldn't understand or believe the cops' explanation of "Hamsterdam"(**). As Poot tried to tell Stringer in the meeting in the season premiere, and as Fruit tries to tell Herc and Carver here, there's a way that The Game is played, everyone is used to it, and no one is interested in trying anything different. Bunny ultimately scoops up as many street-level dealers as his men can find and tries to explain the new world order to them, but they respect him far less than they do the school principal (quieting only when she addresses them, and then heckling Bunny once he's back at the mic). How does a smart, mature man like Bunny deal with a completely upside-down world that produces these boys? Early in the episode Lt. Mello suggests Bunny's lost his mind, but maybe insanity is the only proper response to West Baltimore.

(**) Interestingly, at one point the episode was titled "Amsterdam" (that's what it's called on the original season 3 DVD set), but is now recorded (on HBO's website, the complete series DVD set, etc.) as the dealer's malapropism.

Cutty, meanwhile, needs only a few weeks to lose patience with his attempt to go straight. It's not that he especially wants to go back to being a soldier, but when even his landscaper boss admits how little reward there is to the honest life for men like them, how can he not backslide? But like Bunny, he seems a man out of time. He let Fruit hustle him out of his homecoming package and is uncomfortable with both the semi-automatic pistol Slim Charles gives him and the pot-fueled bacchanalia Slim and Bodie take him to. He's been in prison a long time, and so he's not unhappy with the two women steered towards him, but he still looks a little lost as the door closes.

Four episodes into this season, this is what amounts for progress: Jimmy gets a phone number for Stringer phone number (as does the equally-clever Lester) that the man only seems to use for legitimate business, Bunny has the real estate for Hamsterdam but no occupants, Cutty has a job in the Barksdale crew he's not sure he wants, and Tommy Carcetti has announced a plan to run for mayor that everyone thinks is as foolish an idea as Bunny's plan to legalize drugs in his district.

But this is David Simon and company laying the usual foundation for what's to come. And, as always, what they're building will begin to take shape quickly from here on out.

Some other thoughts:

  • We know Stringer has always aspired to use drugs as a springboard for more legitimate business, but it's still somewhat startling to see him enjoying a power lunch with Clay Davis and Valchek's developer buddy Andy Krawczyk to talk about developing all the real estate he and Avon were buying in season one. The man does not dream small, does he?
  • Stringer's also smart enough to nip the Donnette situation in the bud before she goes telling someone - say, a member of the actual Barksdale family like Avon, who with Maury Levy's help aces his parole hearing in spite of Ronnie's strongly-worded letter - what McNulty told her. And he clearly finds her attractive enough that it's not a complete ordeal for him to keep her quiet.
  • This one was written by George Pelecanos (but, as it's not the penultimate episode and nothing horrible happens to anyone we care about, it doesn't qualify as a Pelecanos Episode), and he incorporates a bit of detail from his first Nick Stefanos novel, "A Firing Offense," as Bubbs talks about his former life as a stock boy at an electronics store. Even after all his time as a dope fiend, it's nice to see that Bubbs still has a work ethic - and is hustler enough to ask for a bonus on top of his hourly wage in exchange for giving Marlo's tag number to Kima.
  • Our director, meanwhile, is Ernest Dickerson, who goes outside the series' usual house style for the party sequence at the end, which is filmed in a much more impressionist, point-of-view style to illustrate just how alien the place seems to Cutty.
  • In the first season, the Barksdale crew used pagers because Simon and Ed Burns were borrowing liberally from a case Burns worked in the '80s when that technology was still widely-used. By season three, the show's "'yo tech" has essentially caught up to the real world, as we discover that guys like Marlo and Poot are now using pre-paid "burners" that they can throw out when done using, and which are all but impossible to get a tap on.
  • For the sake of the newbies, and any veterans who weren't watching the show at the time the third season originally aired, there was some confusion when this episode aired about whether Theresa D'Agostino, the old classmate Tommy asks to run his campaign, is the same woman he had sex with after the campaign fundraiser in episode three. Though there's some faint resemblance (hair color aside), they are not the same; the redhead at the fundraiser was just a one-night stand.
  • As Bunk continues to get nowhere in the futile search for Dozerman's gun, we see some of the boundaries of the Bunk/Jimmy friendship. The two will help each other pick up women at bars, but Jimm's not going to help Bunk find Omar yet again, having already paid his debt on that subject from the first season. (In fairness to Jimmy, the only way he has to find Omar is via Bubbs, and I doubt Bubbs would do that again after how Omar treated him the last time.)

Coming up next: "Straight and True," in which Bunny has a reunion with Bushy Top, Stringer chairs a meeting, and Santangelo plays tour guide.

 

What did everybody else think?

Alan-sepinwall-sm
Alan Sepinwall
Sr. Editor, What's Alan Watching
Alan Sepinwall has been reviewing television since the mid-'90s, first for Tony Soprano's hometown paper, The Star-Ledger, and now for HitFix. His new book, "The Revolution Was Televised," about the last 15 years of TV drama, is for sale at Amazon. He can be reached at sepinwall@hitfix.com

Comments

  • Option 1

    Comment instantly as a guest Guest
  • Option 2

    Connect
  • Option 3

    Login or create a HitFix account Login Signup
  • Default-avatar

    avner

    great episode!

    been waiting all week for this...

    June 25, 2010 at 2:26PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Mo

    Thanks for doing this Alan

    Can you or anyone remind me of a typical Pelecanos episode

    July 1, 2010 at 1:07PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Bertrum376183_283071751727043_186933131340906_993200_1940268190_n_talkback_profile

      Angela Finally a question I can answer. :)
      One is "Bad Dreams" episode 11, Season 2.
      You can read about Pelecanos' episodes in general here: http://sepinwall.blogspot.com/2009/08/wire-season-2-episode-11-bad-dreams_21.
      That one is also the recap of "Bad Dreams" by Alan.
      And another is "Cleaning Up" Episode 12 in season 1, here: http://sepinwall.blogspot.com/2008/08/wire-season-1-episode-12-cleaning-up.html
      Geesh. I started reading the recaps again and realized how much I didn't catch the first go around. A lot like watching "The Wire" I imagine.

      July 1, 2010 at 9:43PM EST
  • Bertrum376183_283071751727043_186933131340906_993200_1940268190_n_talkback_profile

    Angela

    Do I dare say I'm not loving this season thus far without regret later? Partly because as you said Alan, not much has been accomplished thus far for the MCU, or on the side of the various high and mid-level drug dealers. Their still fighting over turf. Maybe there is something up with Stringer having a power lunch with the developers Clay and Andy, but he was into real-estate way before now, so even though it is disturbing it's still feels like a very low key plot.

    Also many of the new players, like Marlo or Fruit for example don't seem real to me yet.
    When we first met Avon, and Stringer and my favorite, D'Angelo, I immediately cared about these characters, and soon understood to a degree why they did what they did, even if I didn't like what they did. And now that I see how cold blooded and calculating Stringer is, it's driving me crazy that there is nothing the MCU or anyone else on the side of the law can do! They way Stringer plays Donnette is as a great example of how uncaring and easily he manipulates people. And I don't like Donnette much either because of the way she treated D'Angelo once he was in prison. I admit I am in critical mode as I write this.

    My favorite character aside from Omar thus far is Bunny and I was really looking forward to seeing how Amsterdam played out, but now it looks like it won't happen? Never say never with "The Wire", but so many ideas lead to dead ends. It's realistic and I love that, but it *is* frustrating as hell to watch at times too. Now I understand why Alan said that one must have patience with "The Wire".

    So far, the "bang out" scene in last weeks episode "Dead Soldiers" with Omar, is my all time favorite of this season. Simply watching Omar and his crews' facial expressions while reloading behind the car said miles about how they felt about their circumstances and their lifestyle at that moment. Amazing acting by all. And Omar at least has a conscious because he takes full responsibility for Tosha's death. He and D'Angelo had a lot in common in my mind.

    Carcetti is another character that's hard for me to care about even though at least his character is clearly impressed in my mind as compared to the newer dealers.

    And that's my rant against The Wire. Don't get me wrong. Over and over I am reminded of how incredibly smart and honest this show is. I've never watched anything else come even close to being this well thought out. I really do love watching it. But right now I'm ready for things to come together as they always do.

    July 1, 2010 at 10:04PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    HK

    True story: A friend of mine attended a performance of Romeo and Juliet. After the curtain, the man in front of her turned around, with his eyes full of tears. "They died?" He was stunned. Can you imagine not knowing how Romeo and Juliet turns out and seeing it for the first time? My roundabout way of saying thanks for having a newbie version so that those of us who have only recently stumbled upon the series can watch it without spoilers. Just finished season three and wish that I had been reading your reviews all along. Definitely missed a few things! Looks like I will have to put my family through a rewind!

    July 9, 2010 at 3:17AM EST Reply to Comment


  • Love the reviews Alan! Just started watching The Wire 2 months ago and have read everyone of your newbie reviews up until now.

    I also noticed the free fall of McNulty's character when he's being a "real cop" compared to season 2 working on the boat. In season 2 he was trying to be a family man, now he's back working cases and spends most of his off time at the bar looking like a train wreck.

    August 30, 2010 at 10:53PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Q

    Many thanks for this. Just started watching Season 3, and find these great next-day reading.

    September 17, 2010 at 10:06AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Erdi

    hey bro you seem to forget about mentioning an important scene in this episode. herc and carver, the funniest duo on show imho, talks to a dealer called peanut who has the same name which bunk is after but they seem not to remember him.

    February 16, 2011 at 9:06PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    TonyC

    Started the Wire after putting it off for some time last month. Read each newbie recap as soon as I'm done with show. I'm watching on iPad hbogo app and on there this episode is calle Amsterdam without the H. Just checked the xfinity app too, same on there.

    ... I'm hoping we see more of the principal. Very very intrigued by her power over those kids. Also, that was the other point that really really stuck w me. In that setting, in the gym, just how juvenile these hardened slingers were blew my mind. Like watching 200 Wallaces and I couldn't help but imagine a similar fate for all of them.

    Love Bunny, intrigued by political story, but least into this season than first two at this point. Sure that will change.

    June 5, 2011 at 3:50PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    tom

    Finally getting around to watching the greatest tv drama ever and really enjoying reading your recaps/thoughts after each episode Alan, thanks for doing it for latecomers like me. Quick questiion re: Hamsterdam - How did McNulty know that Stringer is enrolled in the community college?

    November 14, 2012 at 11:57AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Sam McNulty had followed Stringer to the college in season one, when they were just starting the case.

      April 25, 2013 at 9:20AM EST
  • Default-avatar

    James

    Just wanted to chime in that I started watching the series a few weeks ago and these recaps are invaluabe. Look forward to reading them as I get through the series (which at this point may be next week with the way I'm burning through them).

    December 26, 2012 at 9:05PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      John Will someone remind me what Omar did to bubs?

      January 17, 2013 at 1:03AM EST

Get Instant Alerts on What's Alan Watching

Latest Posts
More Posts
Recent Activity on Facebook
Most Popular on Facebook
Top Stories From Around the Web