When a TV show isn’t working creatively, executives will sometimes bring in a new lead producer in hopes that he or she will be able to take the idea the network liked and turn it into an overall show the network will like. That can work on occasion - see AMC’s “Rubicon,” which parted ways with its creator after a single episode - but more often than not, the new boss has inherits too much baggage from the old boss to do more than make minor, unsatisfying tweaks.

That seems to be the case with ABC’s “V,” which begins its second season - and first full one under the aegis of producer Scott Rosenbaum - tomorrow night at 9 p.m.

Scott Peters, the man originally in charge of remaking the fondly-remembered ‘80s alien invasion series, was replaced after a handful of mediocre episodes filled with thin characters and scripts that couldn’t make up their mind about what viewers might know/remember about the original “V.” Rosenbaum, a veteran of “The Shield” and “Chuck,” took over, and in the handful of his episodes I watched last spring, it seemed like he was struggling to make Peters’ two-dimensional characters seem interesting.

My hope was that with eight season one episodes under his belt, and a full hiatus in which to course correct further, Rosenbaum might have finally wrangled “V” into something that worked. But he’s still stuck with too many bad concepts and/or characters from Peters’ brief run.

(Minor spoilers follow.)

The premiere opens with a sequence oddly reminiscent of “FlashForward” - ABC’s other much-hyped, much-more-disappointing sci-fi show from last season, which died so that “V” could live - in which FBI Agent Erica Evans (Elizabeth Mitchell) wakes up on a city street where all the people around her are either asleep or dead. She runs around frantically searching for her dim-witted son Tyler (Logan Huffman) only to find him on the verge of a horrible death...

… but before I could enjoy the impending demise of not only the biggest anchor on “V” itself, but one of the most annoying characters introduced anywhere last season, Erica woke up from her dream, Tyler was still fine, and “V” was still stuck with him, Erica’s sketchy maternal issues and the rest of what didn’t work with the show last year.

If anything, Rosenbaum seems to have accepted that he’s in charge of a show that should be enjoyed ironically, and has upped the cheese factor in year two.

Ryan (Morris Chestnut), the alien who has joined with the human resistance, begins the season in the custody of V queen Anna (Morena Baccarin), whose scientists can’t figure out how he and his human wife produced a hybrid baby.

Ryan snarls, “She was born by something you’ll never understand: love.”

Anna spends much of the first three episodes of the new season struggling to understand love and other bits of humanity, particularly because her mother Diana - played by Jane Badler, who was the main villain in the ‘80s “V” - has been overcome with emotion after too many years wearing human skin over her reptile body. In the second episode, Diana tries to teach Anna about the concept of the human soul, and Anna replies - as straight-faced as Baccarin can make her - “The soul is the single greatest threat to our species. If it’s there, I’ll find it, and I’ll destroy it.”  

Baccarin seems to relish those moments when Anna is at her most alien (beware the queen’s tail), and some of the other actors occasionally get to remind you that they have real talent. (As fighting priest Jack Landry, Joel Gretsch has a nice subplot in the third episode.) But because the V’s goals - and their reasons for pretending to be nice rather than invading and taking over right away - are so vague, there’s surprisingly little sense of urgency to the different storylines. Everyone’s running in place, participating in unexciting missions that are part of some big picture we still can’t see, trying to seem like characters and not just types.

Bret Harrison from “Reaper” comes in for a recurring role as a scientist who’s of some use to the underground. He gets some funny moments - told the true nature of the V’s, he laments, “Anna’s a lizard? That sucks. She’s so hot.” - but doesn’t seem to fit in on a show whose other humorous moments are either accidental or just entirely deadpan.

I understand why ABC wanted to remake “V.” The original, though not a great show, endures in the memories of those who grew up with it, and the networks are going to keep trying with these big sci-fi epics from time to time in hopes that the next one will somehow replicate the success of “Lost.” But this one’s not working, and it doesn’t matter how many fresh coats of paint or new showrunners they try to slap onto it.

Alan Sepinwall may be reached at sepinwall@hitfix.com
 

Get Instant Alerts - Latest Posts from What's Alan Watching
By subscribing to this e-alert, you agree to HitFix Terms of Service, Privacy Policy and to occasionally receive promotional emails from HitFix.

Follow Alan Sepinwall and Whats Alan Watching on

RSS Facebook Twitter