If I had an Emmy ballot: Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama
Katey Sagal leads a strong field
Connie Britton as Tami Taylor on "Friday Night Lights."
Emmy Week (and a Half) at HitFix continues, and today's category is Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama.
Once again, Fienberg and I are approaching this two different way. Dan is predicting which actresses have a good shot at a nomination (along with a few wishful thinking suggestions), while I'm saying who would be on my hypothetical Emmy ballot.
Dan's gallery is up, and my picks are after the jump...
This field isn't quite as jam-packed as its male counterpart (which we'll get to tomorrow morning), but there are still a bunch of outstanding performances, as well as a few who missed my cut but would be perfectly acceptable as actual nominations. (Instead, of course, most of the slots will go to Mariska Hargitay, Glenn Close, et al.) In alphabetical order:
That Connie Britton doesn't yet have an Emmy trophy for her work as Mrs. Coach on "Friday Night Lights" is unfortunate. That she's never even been nominated? Well, that's just embarrassing. She was fantastic as always this year, both in showing Tami under siege after the decision to split the high school in two, and then during the (storyline redacted for the sake of the non-DirecTV audience).
In previous years, Anna Gunn submitted herself as a supporting actress. This year, she promoted herself to lead, which feels right considering how much more important she was this season on "Breaking Bad." She and the writers combined to make Skyler a much more complicated, flawed and compelling character than ever before, and it would be great if the rising tide of Cranston and Paul could lift her boat, too.
I'm still not 100% sure how much of what makes January Jones effective on "Mad Men" is her actual performance and how much is the work of the costume, hair and makeup people, and on the opaque material that's written for her. Certainly, she didn't come off well when she hosted "SNL" (especially in comparison to Jon Hamm), but other good actors have been bad "SNL" hosts before. But since I haven't figured out a statistical formula to measure Jones' contribution to the role, I have to give her the lion's share of the credit for a season in which Betty became more central than ever.
I'm dubious that anyone on "Treme" other than John Goodman has even a chance at an acting nomination. Still, I'm assuming that Melissa Leo submitted herself as lead while Khandi Alexander and Kim Dickens went supporting in the hope that the show might get a couple of its actresses nominated rather than having them all split their modest votes. And while Alexander was arguably more prominent this season, Leo (who does have an Oscar nomination on her resume) was pretty great - it's not easy making character traits like nobility and persistence seem interesting, and she did - and she delivers her best work yet in the season finale on Sunday.
Of the six women on my list, Julianna Margulies is not only the most likely actual nominee, but the only one who was the unquestioned lead of her series. (The other five could have submitted themselves in the supporting category and no one would have blinked.) The kind of gravity and screen presence to carry an entire drama on your back shouldn't be underestimated. Margulies had that, and she got to do some very effective, subtle work at showing Alicia Florek trying to navigate a personal and professional life where everything had been turned upside down for her.
My clear favorite in the category, though, is Katey Sagal, who delivered one of the two best performances anywhere on television (Aaron Paul gave the other) this season on "Sons of Anarchy." The broad strokes of her storyline are the stuff blatant awards show bait is made of, yet Sagal brought such rawness and simplicity to it that it felt like no version of it I'd ever seen before. Sagal also had a homefield advantage, in that "Sons" creator Kurt Sutter is her husband and knows how to play to her strengths, but she still had to deliver on the material given, and she absolutely killed it.
Tough omissions: Lauren Graham from "Parenthood," Jeanne Tripplehorn from "Big Love."
Alan Sepinwall may be reached at sepinwall@hitfix.com
News From Our Partners
-
Critics Consensus: Men in Black III Is Solid Fun
Five Favorite Films with Director-Producer Oren Peli
Cannes 2012: Critics Scorecard
-
The Telefile - Today's TWoP News: Thursday, May 24, 2012
The Telefile - Modern Family: Best Lines of the Season 3 Finale
The Telefile - Today's TWoP News: Wednesday, May 23, 2012
-
Brandi Glanville Claims She Hooked Up With Gerard Butler
Charlie Sheen Talks Ladies – Onscreen & Off
Jonah Hill ‘Overwhelmed’ By ‘Moneyball’ Supporting Actor Nomination
-
'Dark Knight Rises' TV Spots: A Lighter Side Of Batman
Emma Stone Nabs First 'MTV Trailblazer Award'
One Direction Hit 'MIB 3' Premiere Armed With Toy Guns
-
Gateways To Geekery: There’s more to Russ Meyer’s films than breasts, though those are pretty important
Interview: Men In Black 3 director Barry Sonnenfeld on creating character and managing 3-D
The Walkthrough: 30 Rock showrunner Robert Carlock walks us through some recent series highlights
-
The Dandy Warhols Celebrate 18 Years Together
Lady Gaga Turns Yellow For The Simpsons
Dance Music Vocalist Susana Releasing New Album
-
'Twilight Breaking Dawn Part 2': Edward, Bella And Jacob Character Posters (PHOTOS)
Russell Crowe, Elvis Costello, Sing Elvis Presley And Johnny Cash In London
'Men In Black 3' Unscripted: Josh Brolin Doesn't Know Will Smith's Song 'Summertime'
-
Catherine McKenzie: The Bachelorette Games
'Idol' Continues Downward Ratings Spiral
'Idol' Winner Inspires Nation After Enduring 8 Surgeries During Season
About This Blog
All through his childhood, Alan Sepinwall's relatives told his parents, "All that boy does is watch television! How's he going to make a living doing that?" His career as a TV critic has been 15 years and counting of his attempt to answer their concerns. "What's Alan Watching" is a blog whose title is self-explanatory: Alan watches TV shows, then writes about what he watched. He can be reached at sepinwall@hitfix.com
Get Instant Alerts on What's Alan Watching
HitFix Poll
Will you still watch Community without Dan Harmon behind it?
Latest Posts
-
Our summer rewind will take us into season 2 of 'Deadwood'Thursday, May 24, 2012
-
Danny Masterson and friends don't do much of interest in Breckin Meyer-created sitcomWednesday, May 23, 2012
-
Celebrate the finale's anniversary with Jack, Sawyer, Hurley and friendsWednesday, May 23, 2012
-
Dan and Alan also review TBS' 'Men at Work' and announce their summer rewatchTuesday, May 22, 2012

Comments
Option 1
Comment instantly as a guest GuestOption 2
Option 3
Login or create a HitFix account Login SignupGaines
June 18, 2010 at 8:26AM EST Reply to CommentReplace January Jones (whom I liked better in the second season) with Regina King from Southland or Glenn Close, and voilá, my list. :) My vote also goes to Katey Sagal, simply no other female performance comes close to hers this season.
tigger500
June 18, 2010 at 8:30AM EST Reply to CommentJanuary Jones deserves this award. Period.
Wylie76
June 18, 2010 at 8:35AM EST Reply to CommentMy nominees:
January Jones (Mad Men)
Katey Sagal (Sons of Anarchy)
Melissa Leo (Treme)
Glenn Close (Damages)
Holly Hunter (Saving Grace)
Not much news in this field this year. I just hope that Katey Sagal gets nominated. I completely agree with Alan there.
June 18, 2010 at 9:03AM EST Reply to CommentSo tough to pick between Britton and Sagal, think Sagal just edges it though. The scene where she comes clean to Jax and Clay about the rape has to be the best scene on tv this year and she just seems to bring the best out of male characters.
To be honest she deserves an award for her work on Lost this season as well.
ZacharyTF
June 18, 2010 at 11:38AM EST Reply to CommentMy ballot:
Connie Britton for Friday Night Lights
Lauren Graham for Parenthood
January Jones for Mad Men
LJA
June 18, 2010 at 12:33PM EST Reply to CommentI can get behind your list with the exception of the gawdawful January Jones.
Ken Raining Amen.
June 21, 2010 at 3:13PM ESTChip
June 18, 2010 at 12:45PM EST Reply to CommentAhhh there's Katey
JustMe
June 18, 2010 at 1:40PM EST Reply to CommentJanuary Jones is far and away the weakest link on Mad Men. She's just lucky that her exactly one note is what the writers wanted for Betty to do (most of the time. Whenever they wanted more, she failed to deliver) & that she looks great in clothes.
Brett Agreed. I like the rest of Alan's picks, but January Jones shouldn't be anywhere near the list.
June 18, 2010 at 1:57PM ESTJohn
June 18, 2010 at 2:23PM EST Reply to CommentSome solid shout-outs. No wtf moments like in the supporting catagories. And yes, Jones deserves her due.
My nominees would be:
1. Connie Britton
2. Katy Sagal
2. Anna Gunn
4. January Jones
5. Lauren Graham
6. Glenn Close
Alanna
June 18, 2010 at 2:25PM EST Reply to Comment"Of the six women on my list, Julianna Margulies is not only the most likely actual nominee, but the only one who was the unquestioned lead of her series. (The other five could have submitted themselves in the supporting category and no one would have blinked.)"
There's something really sad about how few true lead roles are available for women these days, and that the best work is being turned in by women who are really more "supporting" than "lead". And I suspect that won't change anytime soon.
UnHoly Diver I think AJ Cook and Paget Brewster would wholeheartedly agree with you.
June 18, 2010 at 2:59PM ESTSusan
June 18, 2010 at 2:56PM EST Reply to CommentAlan, thanks for opting to redact Connie Britton's later-season storyline for us non-Direct Tvers. Those of us who've been watching FNL from the beginning already know exactly how much she deserves a nomination, at the very least!
UnHoly Diver
June 18, 2010 at 3:05PM EST Reply to CommentEven though I don't watch FNL(I gave it a shot when it first came out, but just couldn't hang in there), I have a special place in my heart for Connie Britton, since she grew up in my hometown. However, there was no one(IMO, of course) that gave a better performance than Katey Sagal. She not only deserves a nomination; she deserves the award itself.
Paul C
June 18, 2010 at 4:05PM EST Reply to CommentI agree with Alan regarding January Jones. When watching myself, I find it really hard to quantify January Jones' acting. It doesn't help that the character of Betty is just so frustrating and hard to warm to. But Jones is a conundrum and I always feel like I am under-rating her performances, and I certainly wouldn't begrudge her if she there was a nomination.
That scene though with Jon Hamm late in the season that lasted for like 20mins where Betty confronted him about his past and just pretty much ripped his balls off was pure magic.
If there was any justice then Katey Sagal would win hands down. She was jaw-droppingly good with a rather difficult storyline.
Anna Gunn I also wouldn't mind as she was great early in the season. Or even Connie Britton. Would have no disagreement over Julianna Margulies (since she is a cert for a nod).
Anna
June 18, 2010 at 4:21PM EST Reply to CommentAlan,
Is it completely up to the actor to decide which category to submit in?
For me, Lauren Graham in Parenthood seems more than a supporting role. It's such an ensemble show, though oddly I do buy Peter Krause as a lead actor in Parenthood.
sepinwall Yes, completely the actor's call. Sometimes, it's a political move (in terms of screen time, Rose Byrne is the lead on "Damages," but knows she has a better shot at a nomination in supporting), and sometimes it's an ego thing (Rob Lowe always submits himself as a lead on whatever show he does, even if he's a mid-tier member of an ensemble).
June 18, 2010 at 5:04PM ESTGuyITC
June 18, 2010 at 6:13PM EST Reply to CommentAlan,
I agree with your nominees except the omission of Lauren Graham. I'd take her over each of your last two and flip a coin for which of those got the 6th spot.
My winner? Connie Britton.
Quote of the year by a nominee? (paraphrasing)
"Sally Draper, if I come upstairs and find the dry cleaning bag on the floor of my closet you are going to be a very sorry young lady."
Shakti
June 18, 2010 at 8:56PM EST Reply to CommentKatey Sagal wiped the floor with these other broads! None of them came close, in a season's worth of work, to what Katey Sagal did when she revealed her rape to Jax and Clay! Ya heard?!
Chazz_Goodtimes
June 19, 2010 at 1:55AM EST Reply to CommentI think Katie Segal and Connie Britton should be at the top of the list- but as Gaines mentioned above Regina King should also be up there. Of the three I think Segal did the best work.
With January jones its not just her appearance on SNL that gives me pause in evaluating her acting talent, its also the interviews she's done and other appearances. Not sure if she's capable of more than she's given. I think she's great within the confines of the character- but her acting ability just isn't on par with King, Britton, and Segal.
rebecca There are plenty of good actors who have done badly on SNL or give bad interviews. The nomination is for her role on Mad Men, which she plays fantastically.
June 19, 2010 at 4:04AM ESTrebecca
June 19, 2010 at 3:54AM EST Reply to CommentAs long as Katey Sagal and January Jones get nominated, I'm happy.
JanieJones
June 19, 2010 at 11:56AM EST Reply to CommentI really feel that it should be Sagal, not just as a nominee, but as the winner. She did incredible work this season.
I have to agree with Alan's assessment of Jones and others. Regardless, she did elevate herself in this past season. I was a Betty defender in S3.
Close did her usual fine work but the work of male co-stars such as Short and Scott did override her performance in S3. I will miss Patty Hewes.
Gunn was quite good in S3. Her facade slowly chipping away along with sinking into Walt's world (even with her emasculation of Walt) was quite interesting.
I will be pleased if those are nominated, however it's Katey for the win at least for me.
Walt
June 19, 2010 at 3:02PM EST Reply to CommentMy vote would go to nominating Anna Paquin for True Blood. She gets nominated every year for a Golden Globe for the role, so I don't see any reason why she should not be nominated. She does play the role well in the show.
James I agree with Walt. Anna Paquin deserves to be nominated
June 19, 2010 at 4:59PM ESTjan
June 19, 2010 at 8:05PM EST Reply to CommentConnie Britton
Anna Gunn
Melissa Leo
Katey Sagal
Jeanne Tripplehorn
The Other Susan
June 20, 2010 at 5:23PM EST Reply to CommentI don't watch Damages, Treme, Sons of Anarchy or The Good Wife so with due respect to the worthy actresses on Alan's list, here are my top 5 picks:
1. Connie Britton
2. COnnie Britton
3. Connie Britton
4. Connie Britton
5. January Jones.
noypi
June 27, 2010 at 4:20AM EST Reply to Commentdo you happen to know which episodes january jones submitted for the emmys? i would love it if she had submitted the episode where betty and don went to rome. you can actually feel her light up when she was in rome that it was sad to see her back home and again live as a stifled, irritable, bored-with-her-life housewife
sepinwall No one has submitted anything yet. Right now, the potential nominees are just names on a very long ballot. Once someone gets nominated, they'll pick an episode to submit (or submit an episode they've already picked), and voters will get to see it.
June 27, 2010 at 6:08AM ESTnoypi oh, ok. thank you very much for the info! :)
June 27, 2010 at 9:17AM ESTkal
July 14, 2010 at 4:28PM EST Reply to Commentalan, i just came across an article that is so spot-on about january jones' performance. maybe this will help your uncertainty about jones' acting. http://www.npr.org/blogs/monkeysee/2009/10/complexity_beauty_and_the_unde.html