Cannes Film Festival 2013

Review: 'Friday Night Lights' - 'Texas Whatever': There can only be one

Tough choices abound in the series' moving penultimate episode

<p>Tim (Taylor Kitsch) and Tyra (Adrianne Palicki) brought an old-school vibe to tonight's "Friday Night Lights."</p>

Tim (Taylor Kitsch) and Tyra (Adrianne Palicki) brought an old-school vibe to tonight's "Friday Night Lights."

Credit: NBC/DirecTV

(I originally posted this review back when "Friday Night Lights" was doing its exclusive DirecTV run. The comments from that period have been preserved. For the sake of people who are watching the episodes as they air on NBC, I will ask anyone commenting from this point forward to only discuss plot events up to the episode in question. Do not discuss, or even allude to, anything that has yet to air on NBC. Thank you.)

"Friday Night Lights" has only one week to go in its final season, and I have a review of the series' penultimate episode coming up just as soon as I try to write down a speech while driving...

"You know, it's kind of like this drug: When you get outside of it, you see it for what it really is. But when you're in it, seems like there's no other possible reality." -Tyra

Tyra Collette returns to Dillon just in the nick of time. Not only is the series almost over, not only does Tim Riggins desperately need a little love and tenderness and understanding(*), but in "Texas Whatever" we find several of our regulars seriously contemplating a life away from Dillon. And if ever there was a character who personified the desire to get the hell out of this devil town by any means necessary and not look back, it was Tyra. She mostly got her escape (though the presence of her family and of close friends like Tim and Julie have kept her from running away altogether), and a lot of this episode is spent wondering whether Tami Taylor and Tim Riggins will get theirs.

(*) As Tim dated Lyla for far longer on the series than Tyra (who dumped him in episode 3 of season 1), I suppose she could have filled that role. But I thought Tyra worked better, because A)Tim and Tyra have a much longer history, B)Even after they broke up, the two still had an obvious bond and still looked out for each other, C)Tough, seen-it-all Tyra seems far better equipped to handle the broken post-prison Tim than Lyla would have been, and D)I always found Adrianne Palicki to be a terrific actress on the show, and Mika Kelly to be someone whom the show at best learned how to use properly.

And as good as it was to see Tyra come back, and temporarily ease Tim's pain, and seemingly point him in the direction of not going anywhere (her "Alaska, Tim?" while they gazed at Tim's ranch property was just perfect), it was a particularly necessary ray of sunshine, because boy did this episode feature a lot of darkness.

Whether Tim stays or goes, he still doesn't seem close to forgiving Billy. The school board does the horrible but unsurprising thing and decides to erase the Lions from existence as they're on the verge of a state championship. Luke finally gets a sniff of a college scholarship and realizes that he cares less about it than he'd expected to. And the Taylor marriage is at one of its lowest points after Eric refuses to even consider, for a moment, the idea of pulling up stakes for the sake of Tami's dream job.(**)
 
(**) These DirecTV seasons have had to rush their storytelling at times, and I really wish there had been a way to put more distance between Eric turning down Shane State and Tami getting the Braemore offer. Not only does it feel like too much happening too closely together, but it felt wrong that Shane State wouldn't come up once during their arguments here - for Eric to try to shoot Tami down by saying he gave up his own college dream because he didn't want to leave this town, and for Tami to perhaps retort that he didn't consult her on that decision, either.

I swear, this show is making me a wreck in these final episodes. It really is.

Three moments in particular in "Texas Whatever" raised the dust level in the Sepinwall household. One was Tim in the parking lot begging Tyra to stay with him. (And to a lesser extent, I was also really moved by Tyra's reaction to Tim's reason for going to jail. Not only does that remind her of why she cared about this jailbird in the first place, but it sounds like a foreign language to her, because Tyra is too much about self-preservation to ever sacrifice herself in that way for the sake of someone else, up to and including Mindy.)

Want More...

Friday Night Lights?
  • Check out everything there is including photos, reviews, videos.
The second was Matt coming home to greet a Grandma Saracen whose senility is worse than ever - specifically, seeing how in stride Matt takes all of it now, which is both a good thing for him but also a comment on how much he's suffered over the years. (Sooner or later, all that pain had to lead to him building up these walls, or else it would have killed him.)

The third was also in a parking lot, as Coach told Vince the words he needed to hear about his new life as a Dillon Panther, to which Vince responded with a big, unapologetic hug.(***) That moment said so much about how far their relationship has come, but also about the cruelty of what the haves of this town are doing to the have-nots, and about why Eric would turn down a college coaching job and why he would be so reluctant to leave this place, no matter how much the Buddy Garritys of this world jerk him around.

(***) Unsurprisingly, Michael B. Jordan and, especially, Kyle Chandler played the hell out of that scene. Coach is not a hugger by nature, but there are times when you just have to hug back, and when your QB One - who is, still, barely older than a kid, and who has struggled so much in his brief life - hugs you, then by golly you hug him back.

And it's because of moments like that that I can empathize with Eric, even as I also understand why Tami feels so hurt. He hates the boosters, hates the entitled, instant-gratification fans, hates Slammin' Sammy Mead and all the rest of the nonsense that comes with coaching in Dillon. But he loves coaching these kids. He loves giving them purpose and discipline and character. He loves those moments - like listening to the guys bond on the hotel balcony in "Kingdom," or hearing Tim Riggins call him sir, or being hugged by this kid whose life he more or less saved - that remind him why he's willing to be a sucker again and again and again for the games played by this town's less-than-perfect adults.

But one of the reasons why the Taylors are my all-time favorite screen couple is that when they fight, there's usually a good argument from each side, and Tami sure as hell has a good one this week. If Eric had already taken the Shane State job (which would relocate the family and give them money and security like they'd never had before), that might be one thing. But for her to set aside her own dream job for him to play puppet to the Panthers boosters one more time? And for Eric to not only disagree with her plan but act like it's not even worthy of discussion? That hurts. When she gives him the congratulations he couldn't be bothered to give her, that really hurts.

It's been often said that "Friday Night Lights" is about football, but also about so much more than football. And when the show is truly great, it finds a way to make the football team integral to everything else - where every person and event in Dillon is in some way tied to what Eric is doing on that field with his kids. The team is the town, and vice versa.

Eric and Tami's "So you're rooting against us" argument turns that idea on its head. Suddenly, it's possible for the coach's wife - who has been a coach's wife for 18 long years - to divorce the idea of the family from the idea of the team, to make a not unreasonable argument that her husband doesn't have to stay joined at the hip to this place for the rest of their life together.

But if Mrs. Coach can think of the Lions as something other than "us," how fractured are things going to get in next week's series finale?

And how the hell are we going to live without this great, great series?

Some other thoughts:

• Glad to see the writers finally acknowledging that a scholarship would, indeed, be an option for Luke, even if it wasn't at a football factory like TMU. And I thought that scene where he met with the Warrenfield State recruiters was very well-drawn. If you take the glamor out of the game and send him to a town that doesn't sound any more big-time than Dillon, then how much does Luke really care about football? Last year, he said he viewed it as his escape route, but if the place he escapes to is basically the same, then maybe he does need to think hard about a different future.

• Speaking of Luke, his response to Becky's explanation of her feelings for Tim - "Well, that's really pretty. You should put that in a poem." - was among the episode's cruelest moments, and something of a shocker from the unfailingly polite Luke.  

• Billy and Mindy are having twins? Three little Rigglets under the age of two crawling around that house? Yikes.

• At first, Julie's surprise appearance had me wondering if she had, once again, flaked on life at Burleson, but there's nothing about that in the rest of the episode. So I guess we're just supposed to assume that Julie left Matt in Chicago, went back to school, dealt with the humiliating blowback from the "Julie Taylor is a slut" incident and buckled back down. I guess? Didn't love that story arc, so on the whole I'd rather we not spend more time on it versus life in Dillon, but it does feel like a large piece was missing. On the other hand, I was glad to see Julie with Tyra again, and to be reminded of that friendship.

• Speaking of stories being dropped, it seems clear that the McCoys left town sometime after the humiliating loss to the Lions last season, and there needed to be at least a throwaway line at some point or other about that. Because Joe's absence from any Panthers booster scene, and the lack of discussion of Vince pushing JD aside as QB One, is just distracting without it.

• This was Kyle Chandler's second directing job ever, and the first since an "Early Edition" episode over a decade ago. Coach done good behind the camera, yes? I particularly liked the heated atmosphere of the town hall meeting, which nicely set up Mr. Carvill's relief at hearing Vince and Jess' calm, sincere plea for the Lions in his office.

• Also, kudos to whoever decided to dust off "Devil Town" to play on the soundtrack as everyone gathers to hear which team is about to be erased from existence. That song brings back so many season one memories, and also seems the perfect one to use under these circumstances.

• Tyra's return inspired me to use Netflix Instant to quickly skim through some of her big moments in season 1, which quickly spun out of control into a weekend "Friday Night Lights" Greatest Hits marathon, which climaxed on Sunday night with a viewing of "Mud Bowl." And after watching Tyra fight off her would-be rapist, I couldn't help thinking this: while the Lance/Tyra murder storyline was the biggest blunder in the history of the show, and season 2 still didn't happen... some people just need killin'.

• Also, I worried that going back to watch scenes with the original characters wouldn't be flattering to the newcomers, but I really feel like the torch was effectively passed. I watched Smash, Matt, Tim and Lance hanging out on Herrmann Field at the end of "Hello, Goodbye" not long after I watched Vince and Tinker and company doing something similar near the end of this episode, and the new guys don't seem like pale imitations, but worthy successors.

• Also interesting to rewatch Coach and Mrs. Coach's argument about the TMU job - where Tami didn't want to leave because, quote, "I'd feel bad for those kids" she'd be leaving behind - in light of these last couple of episodes.

The finale is going to air in a 90-minute timeslot next Friday. I'm going to bump up my post looking back over the series' greatest moments so it'll reappear that morning, my review of the finale will reappear Friday at 9:30, along with my series post-mortem interview with Jason Katims, and Fienberg and I will find some easy way to relink to the long all-"Friday Night Lights" podcast we initially released the day after the finale aired on DirecTV. Lotta content for a great, great show.

What did everybody else think?

Alan-sepinwall-sm
Alan Sepinwall
Sr. Editor, What's Alan Watching
Alan Sepinwall has been reviewing television since the mid-'90s, first for Tony Soprano's hometown paper, The Star-Ledger, and now for HitFix. His new book, "The Revolution Was Televised," about the last 15 years of TV drama, is for sale at Amazon. He can be reached at sepinwall@hitfix.com

Comments

  • Option 1

    Comment instantly as a guest Guest
  • Option 2

    Connect
  • Option 3

    Login or create a HitFix account Login Signup
  • 1
  • 2
Next 121 Comments
  • Default-avatar

    Jonsamon

    Fantastic. And dusty. Great callback to the jumbotron.

    February 2, 2011 at 11:13PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Billy

    A couple thoughts. The McCoy/Aikman absence all year with no mention has really bugged me.

    I'm from a small live for HS football town in Texas and I can absolutely see a community meeting turning into something that out of control.

    What happened to Riggins Rigs? Tim goes down for this thing and they can't even show Billy there once or twice during the day. When he said he was gonna support his family on a coaching stipend that really bothered ms because all they had to do was just show Billy working there once or twice during the day throughout the season.

    The first thing Julie said was that she finished her finals. So we are to assume she went back from
    Chicago for her act together and finished the semester. But she did mention it which is all the Julie at college story I need.

    The coach/Vince hug and matt/grandma scene are what make this show special.

    Also being from a small Texas town ita easy to see tyras quite you used as something that really resonates true.

    Texas Forever..

    February 2, 2011 at 11:24PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      StvMg When they didn't show up in the Dillon-East Dillon game, I assumed that Aikman and JD had transferred elsewhere in Texas, and that their school would meet Dillon sometime in the playoffs (like Voodoo in Season One). I guess it's too late for that to happen now, or else it would have been mentioned this week when they were preparing for state.

      February 3, 2011 at 12:06PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Mike

    Still have to watch the episode, but hopefully there's at least a throwaway line giving some kind of ending to the Landry/Tyra relationship, it cheapens her moment of essentially "saving" Tim if we know she couldn't even give Lance a proper "we're breaking up" call.

    February 2, 2011 at 11:44PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Tavernwenchlogo_talkback_profile

      TavernWench Totally agree. Tyra broke Landry's heart, and if she's back for the finale next week (hopefully?), maybe we can see Landry again, and maybe... just maybe...

      These last few eps have been gut-wrenching. Guess it never really hit me until now that my favorite show pretty much ever is ending.

      February 3, 2011 at 4:43AM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Karen

    Just reading your review made me tear up again. This one had so many great moments packed into it.
    I can logically understand both sides of the Taylor's dilemma but my heart cannot stand the thought of this show ending with that 100% resolved. Their relationship is so real but I need the Taylor's to ride into the sunset happy. I can't lie and say I'm anxious for the finale. I am going to miss this show so much. It's too bad more people never gave this one a try because it's one of the best shows ever to be on tv.

    February 2, 2011 at 11:59PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Rick

    It would be very unlikely that a small D3 school would offer football scholarships. They still recruit, but at schools like that student/athletes still pay tuition.

    February 3, 2011 at 12:06AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Nick In fact by NCAA rules, D3 schools can not offer scholarships to athletes. They could have added that into the conversation but there was enough there to get the point across what that school was going to be like.

      February 3, 2011 at 1:28AM EST
    • There are a lot of ways D3 schools give scholarships to athletes that aren't athletic scholarships.

      February 3, 2011 at 10:27AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Brian I was a basketball player in high school and recruited by mostly D3 schools who wanted me to play ball for them. While I was never offered an athletic scholarship by these schools because that as Nick here posted is against NCAA rules, I was offered "Aid" and "Academic Scholarships" that were really athletic scholarships that added up to about 2/3 of the tuition. So I can only assume that Luke would have a similar opportunity

      February 3, 2011 at 12:04PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Jim

    Why can't Coach save high school kids in Pennsylvania? It's slightly less prestigious than Texas high school football (though not much), but the saving-kids part is available anywhere.

    Also: We still have little to no idea what Tyra has been doing since she left Dillon, but boy was it good to see her back. I could watch a season's worth of her standing on the ponderosa with Tim Riggins and sitting on a pickup tailgate with Julie Taylor. There is a character history there that goes beyond the "last goodbye" aspect of this final season and gives those scenes an emotional depth we just don't get with Vince and Jess and Luke and Becky, no matter how well the younger characters are written and acted. Like Lost or any number of other beloved dramas, the show's power comes from the time we've invested with these characters. In my opinion.

    February 3, 2011 at 12:11AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      peaches Reply to comment...

      February 3, 2011 at 12:50AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      peaches I get the "coach could help kids in PA" line of reasoning but I think he is bitter he didn't stick with the college job and he didn't make it out of the high school ranks. There are some coaches who aspire to be a Hugh school coach and that's perfectly fine, but I feel coach thought he wanted more for himself. So he is punishing mrs. Coach for pursuing her dreams when it would
      mean a lateral move for him. He doesn't want her to make the leap when he couldn't do it himself. Of course he couldn't leave bc he loved his family and team but I think the fact he couldn't makes him resent people that do. In the end he's trapped in dillon like everyone else.

      February 3, 2011 at 1:02AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Lindz LOL! I read this exact same comment at the AV Club. Looks like you are putting that new thesaurus to good work, buddy. Keep on keeping on.

      February 3, 2011 at 1:59AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Lindz Sorry! My above reply wasn't meant for this comment, rather the one below yours! I agree with coach saving kids in PA to give Tami her dream for once.

      February 3, 2011 at 2:02AM EST
    • Tavernwenchlogo_talkback_profile

      TavernWench Isn't "Friday Night Lights" before all other things really a show about Texas, and Texans? Texas is Texas, and Penn is Penn, and never the twain shall meet, I'm thinking.

      Of course it makes sense to me, a lifelong Ohioan, that kids can be saved everywhere, and football is everywhere. But Texans, you know, they're a rare and stubborn breed. It seems totally in character for Coach Taylor to not just buck at the idea of a move to Philadelphia; he seems to refuse to even discuss such a thing.

      The scene with Tyra and Julie on the tailgate made the ep. I got a little misty-eyed. Ahhh, I'm gonna miss this Devil Town.

      February 3, 2011 at 4:47AM EST
  • Default-avatar

    striped white jets

    Melodramatic mumbo-jumbo. Exuberant, gorgeous nonsense. Fun? Of course. A profound work of art? Hardly. It takes more than bombastic rhetoric, gaudy visuals, and scenery-chewing performances to make a masterpiece.

    Friday Night Lights is an all-American triumph of style over substance. It substitutes razzle-dazzle for truth and hopes no one notices the sleight of hand. Critics obviously enjoy being told what to think or they'd never sit still for the hammy acting, cartoon characterizations, tendentious photography, editorializing blockings, and absurdly grandiose (and annoyingly insistent) metaphors. This means this. That means that. Get it? Got it! Everything's shifted one notch to the side of reality. It's all a metaphor. Wow. What an original idea. Don't you just love it when things are big and bloated with meaning? That's what art does. A big house symbolizes loneliness. A sled, the uprooting of your youth. That sure is profound. I sure learned a lot from that! Heavy. Pass the J, dude.

    February 3, 2011 at 1:16AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      MTW Simmer down, Francis.

      February 3, 2011 at 1:44AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Brett I like how you've posted the same comment here and on the AV Club. Enjoy being a troll?

      February 3, 2011 at 1:45AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Lindz LOL! I read this exact same comment at the AV Club. Looks like you are putting that new thesaurus to good work, buddy. Keep on keeping on.

      February 3, 2011 at 2:01AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      John This reads like one of those nonsensical rants from people who hated on 'Mad Men' in its first couple of seasons. That gives me a warm, fuzzy feeling since I'm a fan of both shows.

      February 3, 2011 at 5:03AM EST
    • Tavernwenchlogo_talkback_profile

      TavernWench Perhaps a marathon of "The Defenders" is more up your alley.

      February 3, 2011 at 5:05AM EST
    • So, Citizen Kane sucks? Hope you are enjoying graduate school.

      February 3, 2011 at 6:28AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      jaf "Friday Night Lights is an all-American triumph of style over substance." - your response is the beginning of a "B"ish undergraduate paper that relies on a boring, predictable, ranting post-modernism framework (fill-in-the-blank) of attacking a singular viewpoint using language like "absurdly grandiose (please, I can smell the scotch and feel the plush carpet)and "tendentious photography," which, by the way, doesn't really work as a proper adjective when you think about the alternative: "unbiased photography?" But this response is sort of cute, the way it attempts to bring into existence this brilliant fictional critic, suffering from a incurable-terminal case of ennui at the hands of popular TV. OMG -- maybe a TV show staring you! You could conflate every stereotype and hollow attempts at symbolism ever put forth on mainstream TV, and all in the pilot episode. I know a few amaaaaaaaaazing young directors from Bushwick.

      February 7, 2011 at 1:03PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    CK

    So excited for next week but one point. I work in college athletics. D-III schools can't offer athletic scholarships. That's the entire concept of Division III.

    February 3, 2011 at 1:27AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Dave P I'll give the writers some leeway on that one. I'm thinking there's a good chance they know that D3 schools can't offer scholarships, but they also know that 98% of the public don't know that. But when we hear "D3", we envision a third rate program that wouldn't be exciting to a kid with big time football dreams. If they said D2, we'd think "that's not so bad, it's just one notch below TMU". D3, on the other hand, makes me think of Troy playing QB at Greendale.

      February 3, 2011 at 4:58AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Tim There are ways the schools get around it. Academic and Financial assistance is given to players who may not have the means to pay for school themselves.

      February 3, 2011 at 10:05AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      jaf I believe D3 schools have ways to generate scholarships for their athletes. Book scholarships etc.

      February 7, 2011 at 1:09PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Murph

    Incredible ep. So many amazing moments. The one thing that was bothering me was Coach & Tami. This didn't feel like them, how they handle things, how they talk or fight. Tami was so hurt much of the episode and I didn't get it. The Tami I love would know Coach is dealing well with all the chaos. She would be making a plan on how to approach this. I didn't get it. Then that moment. "I'm going to say to you what you haven't had the grace to say to me: congratulations, Eric". It wasn't just that he wasn't willing to talk about it. It was that he hadn't even acknowledged her accomplishment. And I got it. So much of what happens on this show isn't seen, they are conversations we aren't privy too and so I assumed that was what was happening here. And I was wrong. I'm gonna miss this show so much. But I have total faith that these folks will end the show in a way the fans deserve.

    February 3, 2011 at 1:39AM EST Reply to Comment


  • This is my favorite season since the first. Loved the Coach/Vince hug, seeing Grandma Saracen, and the Tyra/Tim reconnection. Can't wait for the finale.

    February 3, 2011 at 2:04AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Betty White is massively overrated. Louanne Stephens has been simply delightful/devastating as Lorraine Saracen. Is this the best top to bottom cast ever on TV?

      February 3, 2011 at 6:35AM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Lindz

    I'm gutted after this episode. I can't imagine how I'll make it through next week's finale! No other show on television has reached out and grabbed me as much as this one has. I want to visit these characters each week and I'll need to find a distraction to get over this loss.

    Grandma Saracen brought a huge smile to my face... even if her condition has deteriorated.

    Eric and Tami gutted me this episode. The avoidance, the bitterness... we aren't used to this!

    Thanks, Alan, for championing this show for so long.

    February 3, 2011 at 2:06AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Tavernwenchlogo_talkback_profile

      TavernWench "18 years."

      They gutted me, too. Also, "Congratulations, Eric."

      Sigh. :-(

      February 3, 2011 at 3:27AM EST
  • Tavernwenchlogo_talkback_profile

    TavernWench

    When I saw the DirecTV listing for this ep, with the little spoiler about one of Tim's ex-flames returning to Dillon, I just gotta say I was disappointed when it was Tyra, and not Lyla Garrity.

    If Tyra's gonna hang around for the finale, please, please, give me one long last look at Landry. Is that too much for a girl to ask? Matt Saracen's back, and I want the whole damned gang back. Jason's due a reprise in the finale too.

    I can't believe how emotional I'm getting just thinking that this show is almost over.

    February 3, 2011 at 3:26AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      "WHATRUDOIN" And Santiago!

      February 3, 2011 at 2:11PM EST


  • So, so going to miss this show, terrific episode this week.

    The other night I imagined a final end montage to "Devil Town" and was wondering when or if it might be re-used (a la "Way Down in the Hole" was used in "-30-"). Guess they beat me to the punch by an episode!

    I know you don't want to/can't reveal plot details on next week's finale, but I'm curious as to who wrote/directed it?

    February 3, 2011 at 3:54AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    NoHoGreg

    Alan, any chance you land Berg or Katims for a post show mortem ala Chase and Simon?

    February 3, 2011 at 4:24AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      NoHoGreg Post show post mortem would be the correct phrasing I guess.

      February 3, 2011 at 4:26AM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Dave P

    Great ep, great writing, great acting. I'm watching these later and later at night now, just to delay the inevitable final episode.

    I have to throw a yellow flag on Mrs. Coach. "18 years" suggests there some sort of turn taking dynamic in a relationship, and there really isn't. You try to do what's best for both at all times, and there's definitely a great amount of sacrifice. But it's not 5 years you, followed by 5 years me, then 5 years you...

    Also, there's no doubt she's an awesome wife, but her timing if dreadful. In S1, right before state she drops an I'm pregnant bomb on Eric. Then she didn't leave her job and follow Eric to TMU, which had to contribute to his unhappiness and eventual quitting. I guess she was on break after 15 years. And now, before state again, she fires the Philly Dean Dream Job Missile and follows that up by lobbing some 18 Years Grenades. All right as he's also distracted by the town nuking his entire program.

    Don't get me wrong. Mrs Coach has a legit beef here. Eric was incredible unsupportive and outright dismissive. But her timing was bad and it really did feel like she was rooting for him to lose his program so it would be easier to move East.

    College life has been good to Tyra. She looked great. Not just Palicki great but more in the way that it seems like her character would come back to Dillon with more confidence and a better sense of self. Not sure if she is hanging around to save Tim tho. That had a just-released-from-prison mercy fuck quality to it. YMMV

    February 3, 2011 at 5:15AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      John I don't believe Tami was talking about it being 'her turn'. What's she's saying is that she's been a coach's wife for eighteen years, and now she has the opportunity to become more. She has ambitions of her own now, and she would like to persue them. She now wants to be more than "coach's wife".

      February 3, 2011 at 7:07AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Dave P I agree that she's got the right to have ambitions of her own and not only pursue them, but have Coach be supportive and try to accommodate them. But when she says "18 years" she's implying that it's her turn now. Or that maybe 18 years was a good run and now she needs to fly on her own.

      Also, I'm sure at some point she was a coaches wife. But in the run of the show, she's been a counselor, a principle, and then chose to be a dean. It's not like she's been home baking cookies all day for the practices.

      Coach took the news terribly and was really nasty, but in fairness to how humans actually react to things, it was about right. We haven't seen Tami pursue anything outside of Dillon this whole time, and she didn't even pursue the Dean position. There was a conference that Levi signed her up for, she impressed a random person at the conference, and the random person offered her a random job, then the head of the school randomly made her an offer that she'd but crazy not to consider and take. But it came so completely from left field Coach could only be expected to recoil, especially with the unfortunate timing. In the middle of his program being cancelled while he's preparing for State, he was asked to reconsider his job, his career, and even what it means to be a capital M Man.

      February 3, 2011 at 1:03PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Andrew Tami didn't follow Eric to TMU because she didn't want to rip Julie out of school yet again. It is good for a teenager to have some semblance of foundation.

      Eric did not handle the situation well, but ultimately they will move. Dean of admissions roles do not come around every day. Also, there are plenty of Colleges in Penn that have strong football programs too.

      February 4, 2011 at 6:09PM EST
  • Tavernwenchlogo_talkback_profile

    TavernWench

    In honor of the looming finale, I just can't resist posting a link to the intro of "Music + Lyrics", which is forever linked to the one, the only, Jason Street. :-)

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xVkU8dDSC9w

    February 3, 2011 at 5:36AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    adam

    Way back when in Season One - on the occasion of Matt and Julie's first date - the scene at Grandma's house when Matt has to serenade her thru the locked bathroom door to get her to come out - and when she does so she thinks he is his grandfather (her late husband) absolutely broke my heart. It also left me wondering how neither of the actors involved earned nominations for their work on this show.

    Last night, as we drive towards the series finale, when Matt surprises Grandma with the Christmas tree and she is initially unable to recognize him and thereafter does not recall that her son (his father) is dead and does not even seem to know it is Christmas, they simply broke my heart all over again.

    It is really disappointing to me that FNL no longer exists as a show and will air its final episode next week. There is so much dreck - both scripted and unscripted - on TV one would think that quality, entertaining programming would be encouraged. Guess not.

    February 3, 2011 at 7:04AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Tim

    I cannot believe it's almost over. I do not know what I will do without it. I don't know if I can say it's the best series ever, but I think i can honestly say it's the most "emotionally engaing" series I have ever watched.

    Tami is way out of line here. She talks about all the work she and Eric have put into Eric's career and then asks him to simply walk away from it?? Eric has built soemthing over the last 18 years and it is completely unfair of her to ask him to just walk away and leave it behind. She knew what she was getting into when she married a Coach and has played the Coach's wife perfectly up until this point. I completely disagree that she has a relevant argument here. I will never forgive her if the Coach walks away from football, and it will destroy me as I held her in such high esteem, and this is basically assassinating her character in my opinion. Coach left TWO jobs in college to stay in Dillon because SHE wanted to (TMU QB Coach & SHane State).

    February 3, 2011 at 10:02AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Tim Engaging***

      February 3, 2011 at 10:07AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Brett She certainly has a relevant argument. Their lives have been built around Eric's career up to this point. And it's not true at all that Coach turned down Shane State because Tami wanted him to. Eric came to that decision on his own, and Tami was actually excited about the prospect of him taking that job. I don't begrudge Tami for having ambitions of her own.

      February 3, 2011 at 2:33PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Chris Finally, someone saw it as I did... At the very least Tami could acknowledge that it is the TMU-situation in reverse: one of them offered a great job elsewhere, the other wanting to stay, largely because of a sense of duty towards the kids of Dillon.
      As someone commented on an old episode, can't the show, just once, let Eric win a single argument with his saintly wife? As far as I kno, it never happened, even when (like now) she is clearly at least as wrong as him...

      May 6, 2011 at 5:55PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Col Bat Guano It's funny how easily the sexism pops out when debates like this take place. What has the 18 years they spent on Coach's career gotten them? A chance to go back to the Panthers after being humiliated two years ago? She has the chance of a lifetime and even bringing up the idea that maybe he could make a sacrifice is greeted as outrageous.

      July 10, 2011 at 1:36AM EST
  • Default-avatar

    lopey

    As I mentioned back in the review of the episode where the Lions cream the Panthers, there was a black kid playing QB for the Panthers so we know for certain that the McCoys were run out of town which explains all of them missing this season (still surprised they didn't even mention them, sort of like how they don't mention Oz in American Wedding despite how close he was to all those guys).

    February 3, 2011 at 10:38AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    kbh5202

    Matt is my favorite character and I hope the focus is on him next week. We all know a Matt, odds always stacked against him. I unfortunately watched some of the promotional trailers (don't do it) and I will not discuss now. However, I hope there is conversation next week about Matt and Coach Taylor. These two have never had a great relationship, which is sad.....as Coach Taylor should want Matt in Julie's life. Her other choices in men has been less than stellar. Matt did everything that coach asked from him, plus took care of his grandma. Still think "SON" is the best episode. His amazing break down of his hate for his own father.

    February 3, 2011 at 10:47AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Wheat Matt and Coach never had a great relationship? They had a strong relationship the entire show. Coach really was like a surrogate father figure to Matt in a similar way as he was to Vince. Of course it was complicated by a couple of benchings and Matt dating his daughter, but they always seemed to get through it with great respect for one another similar to Coach and Mrs. Coach.

      February 3, 2011 at 8:13PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Andrew The best scene in the entire series was when Matt was drunk and told Coach not to give him one of his dad, coach, speeches and Eric dragged him into the shower. Another great scene was when Vince was in Coach's office and yelled that he doesn't know how to be a better man because no one taught him how.

      February 4, 2011 at 6:15PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Bryan

    I'm so conflicted right now - I simultaneously cant' wait for next week yet never want it to come.

    Re Speaking of Luke, his response to Becky's explanation of her feelings for Tim - "Well, that's really pretty. You should put that in a poem." - was among the episode's cruelest moments, and something of a shocker from the unfailingly polite Luke.

    Yes it was cruel and a shock but exactly what a jealous 18 year old in love would say.

    February 3, 2011 at 11:43AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Anna Not if that 18-year-old in love is Luke Cafferty.

      February 4, 2011 at 12:10PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      fez when you have to be polite to everyone everyday, it's easy to take out frustration on those closest to you

      February 6, 2011 at 2:01AM EST
  • Default-avatar

    jared

    Giving Billy and Mindy more to do and making them into real characters (and people) instead of comic foils for Tim and Tyra was one of the best moves this show ever made.

    February 3, 2011 at 1:04PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    debora

    Alan please!!! I can't wait until next wednesday... I know you didn't spoil anything but I need to know if there is one more "shopping with Landry" scene before the show dissapear forever!!!!!!!!!!
    Also...maybe they could launch a 16/17 episode season in dvd, using the deleted scenes and reediting the timing... just saying. I love that, I´m surely buy the blu ray.

    February 3, 2011 at 1:54PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      debora More things that I need to know...please tell me that Hastings have a 15 minute monologue that justify his name in the opening credits...so far panther's "red crotch" from season 1 and 2 had much more air time than him.

      February 3, 2011 at 1:58PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Tim

    are we sure this episode is called "texas whatever", because some sources have it titled "small town"....can i get a confirmation on this?

    February 3, 2011 at 2:21PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Ian DirecTV called it "Texas Whatsever" in all the on-screen graphics, and "Texas, whatever" was in the dialogue. It's an obvious callback to "Texas Forever", and fits the theme of leaving Dillion quite nicely.

      February 3, 2011 at 5:06PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    Chris

    Wow Amazing write up! I got hooked on this show a month ago watching 4-5 episodes daily and now all caught up just in time for the finale. I just wish this show would go on so much more they could do

    February 3, 2011 at 4:43PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    francesca

    For you guys that don't quite get it: lots of real-life couples consist of two talented people, each with individual hopes and dreams. Sometimes they take turns. I've loved these two characters & their marriage but have always seen Eric as a bit less liberated than a lot of guys I know and love, and chalked it up to being small-town Texas. His career needs have always come first in their relationship.

    February 3, 2011 at 6:08PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Joan H I didn't think this is a question of Eric not being liberated, it's a question of Tammy being insane. First of all, Eric is dealing with taking his team to the state championship, which is the culmination of his coaching responsibilities for the year. At the very least, she could've shelved their discussion for *after* the games were over.

      Frankly, I think this storyline is out of character for Tammy. She quit being principal in W Dillon to go back to being a guidance counselor because she missed working with the students. Now she wants to be Dean of Admissions at a PA college? Neither Tammy nor Eric have ever lived anywhere but TX there entire lives. Heck, have these people ever had to shovel snow?
      I'm not saying it's wrong for Tammy to want this job (although I doubt she's qualified, and I really doubt she'll be happy there), I'm just saying it's weird for her to jump into this offer so whole-heartedly without thinking it through. Yes, she has followed Eric for 18 years, but that was a mutual decision, and Eric has provided for the family. She shouldn't go throwing those 18 years in Eric's face now as if he *made* her do it. If she felt trapped, she should have said so -- in fact that's how she ended up going back to work in the first place, right? Eric has never tried to hold her back, but what she is asking him to do is to entirely give up his career, because you know that high school football in PA is nothing like high school football in TX.
      Still love the Taylors as a couple and am holding out hope that this resolves in some believable way, but I'm really surprised by how obnoxious Tammy is being right now at what is probably the most stressful time Eric has ever had in his career. Her "Congratulations, Eric" was so bitter! She didn't even notice that he was NOT happy with the situation at all, didn't stop to consider that Eric doesn't want to go back to West Dillon after the way he was treated there -- all she can see is what *she* wants, and that's just not reading right to me.

      February 3, 2011 at 8:43PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Brett "She quit being principal in W Dillon to go back to being a guidance counselor because she missed working with the students."

      Not true. Tami was forced out as principal because of the backlash from the abortion situation and accepted a demotion at East Dillon in order to avoid a drawn out lawsuit. She did it out of necessity, not because she missed being close to the students.

      "but I'm really surprised by how obnoxious Tammy is being right now at what is probably the most stressful time Eric has ever had in his career."

      I hardly think this situation is as stressful for Eric as the McCoy ambush was in Season 3. He's about to play for the state championship, and the school that betrayed him is now begging him to come back and is ready to shower him with a hero's welcome. On top of that, he now has an opportunity to coach a team that is even better than his current one by combining the best players from both teams. Now, this certainly isn't Eric's first choice. He'd rather stay where he is and let the Panthers' players come to him. Plus I'm sure he feels bad for the lesser players on his team who will be left behind. But from a career perspective, this is a pretty sweet scenario for him.

      As far as Tami only considering what she wants, well, that's not much different from how Eric handled the TMU offer at the end of Season 1. I know it sounds like I'm on Tami's side here, but I'm not. I just think both sides have a valid argument.

      February 3, 2011 at 9:56PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Joan H Tammy wasn't forced out as principal -- she herself came up with the idea to transfer to East and become guidance counselor as a way out of the mess that the abortion scenario had created. The fact is, she followed the protocols and did nothing wrong, and she could've sued West for wrongful termination if they fired her or forced her out. But she was gracious and left for East where she felt she could do the most good.

      Eric's situation -- it's a mess, and I didn't see any positive attitude in him at all re going back to West Dillon. At this point he's just listening and trying to figure out what realistic options are.

      I do think that both sides have valid points, but I just think that Tammy's timing really stinks, and that's not like her.

      February 4, 2011 at 2:31AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Brett Yes, Tami came up with the idea, but only after it became clear she was going to be fired. It was either take the East Dillon job, or go through with the wrongful termination suit and be tied up in litigation for years. Either way, it was clear that she was no longer going to be principal at West Dillon. I agree with you that the timing of this situation stinks, but Tami can't control when she gets the offer. Was she supposed to hide it until Eric decides what he wants to do with his offer?

      February 4, 2011 at 4:11AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      Danie On the TMU issue, Eric was going to turn it down when he learned about the baby, but Tami told him not to. He was willing to put his career goals aside for his family. Tami refused to go to Austin because she didn't want to leave the Dillon high kids in the ditch. So, seems like the end of season 1 has been reverse between them as Eric now wants to stay because of the kids.

      February 4, 2011 at 9:14AM EST


  • The scene with the announcement of the Panthers being the only team and how Taylor handled it in front of Vince maybe my new favorite scene of the series.

    February 3, 2011 at 6:25PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    qbnon

    all the way from the north west of england. just want to add that i got all smiley when i saw the guest starring list. i'm going to miss this show. going to watch s1 ep1 now for old time sakes. Alan, was that some online plugging for Netfix Instant? not very subtle, but whatever pays the bills.

    February 3, 2011 at 8:18PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Midnight_run_mca255950_talkback_profile

      sepinwall We don't get ad money from Netflix. In fact, I paid them for the privilege of watching old episodes of the show.

      If HitFix is getting paid to advertise, you will see it in the form of, you know, ads.

      February 3, 2011 at 9:03PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      ddnnll Sheesh, not every proper noun is 'product placement.' @QBNON, would "video streaming service" make you happier? Do you know anybody who really talks like that?

      February 5, 2011 at 11:57AM EST
    • Default-avatar

      qbnon sorry for sounding like a twat, just that nowadays every article i read seems to have some unnecessary plug for something.

      February 6, 2011 at 5:10PM EST


  • Wonderful review and dead on! Major depression going on here to that this most wonderful series is coming to an end. An amazing twist to the end and just admire Coach Eric Taylor so much. We are expecting our second son in July and very likely he will be named Dillon Taylor Crumpton. Loved this episod and the waterworks were definitely on during the hug you mentioned. Acted wonderfully by all. Just so so sad it is all about to be over.... Forever. Thanks again for your detailed review!

    February 4, 2011 at 12:40AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    isaacl

    I always enjoy immensely scenes with Matt returning--he was the heart and soul of the show, and any opportunity to see him is a pleasure. The writing was excellent in his scene with Grandma: in just a few concise sentences and reactions by Matt, the viewers are shown how time has treated both of them (for the worse with Grandma, and with Matt, a greater capacity to deal with the vicissitudes of life). Can't wait to see how the series will wind up!

    February 4, 2011 at 3:41AM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      kbh5202 Couldn't agree more....
      Chicago has treated him well....

      February 4, 2011 at 10:32AM EST
  • 1
  • 2
Next 121 Comments

Get Instant Alerts on What's Alan Watching

Latest Posts
More Posts
Recent Activity on Facebook
Most Popular on Facebook
Top Stories From Around the Web