Sundance review: Midnight horror film 'Silent House' innovates technically, not narratively
Is that enough to win over an audience? The filmmakers behind 'Open Water' hope so
PARK CITY, UT -- It is unusual for Sundance to open with a midnight movie, and especially with a press screening of a midnight movie. I'm glad they did, though, even if I think "Silent House" is an exercise more than a movie. And that's not a dismissal… just an observation.
I haven't seen "La Casa Muda," the film by Gustavo Hernandez, which was produced and released in Uruguay. It played Cannes in 2010, and I remember seeing a trailer for it online and being impressed by what looked like a fair degree of technical polish and the clever idea of shooting the entire thing in one take. Most of the reviews I read for the film liked the film up to a point, but the script seemed to pull some gymnastics that derailed the film for a number of viewers. Considering the film only made its international premiere in May, it's sort of remarkable to be in January of the following year, already reviewing the remake. It's also sort of remarkable that they made some major revisions to the structure and the characters, and yet they still have some of the same issues that irritated viewers in the original.
Chris Kentis and Laura Lau were accused by many of making a film that was all gimmick when they released "Open Water," but I think they showed skill and ambition with the way that film was put together. It's a simple idea, yes, but that's one of the things good indie filmmakers do… they find ways to make movies that don't require $100 million budgets in order to work. Evidently, they were offered this remake mid-summer, and now they're here at Sundance with it, the film already finished, and the room I saw the film in during the small hours of Friday morning was positively packed with buyers. I would imagine someone's going to pick this one up at some point this week, and if they make a smart deal in the process, they could make a fair amount of money with it.
- Check out everything there is including photos, reviews, videos.
The film is built on a foundation of secrets, of course, and one of the things the film does well is escalation. Building the right series of scares in the right sequence and milking each one to its maximum potential is the goal, and the film does it well on a mechanical level. Not perfectly, but well. For the film to really pay off, we have to believe the choices that Sarah makes, and that's the biggest problem in the film for me. Some audience members will be frustrated by her near-determination to stay in the house long past the moment she should leave and never look back, and they should be. It's one of the most fundamental problems in horror films… how do you maintain the isolation or the seclusion or the claustrophobia without also denying the simple logic of what a real person would do.
The answer is that not everything you're seeing is what you're seeing, and without spoiling the film narratively, I'll just say that the film tips its hand early. I think they offer up the explanation to things pretty much from the moment the characters start talking and I wasn't remotely surprised by the revelations the film had to offer. What kept me interested was the technical accomplishment, and even if you don't like the script, you can't outright dismiss what Chris Kentis has done here. It's an exceptionally well-choreographed film, and the idea of doing everything in one long uninterrupted take, making this a sort of "Russian ARRRRRGGGGH!", pays off in the way the film feels experiential. I remember seeing an early preview screening of "Jurassic Park," and during the T-Rex attack scene in the car, the temperature in the Alfred Hitchcock Screening Room on the Universal lot actually went up. It was a purely primal physical reaction to what people were watching, and during this morning's screening, the same thing happened. There was a noticeable shift in temperature in the room, and people were having visceral, almost involuntary reactions to the tension level of the film.
There are a number of moments in the film where the staging pays off in clever ways, and I give credit to Olsen for holding the film together. I don't think any of the other performers are particularly good, so it all falls on her, and she comes close to making the entire thing work just because of how much she invests in it. I think the film's narrative resolution is suitably unpleasant, but it's also a fairly standard reveal. I don't think anyone will be shocked or surprised, and in a film that makes such an effort at being technically bold, I wish the script had matched it in innovation.
As it stands, "Silent House" worked for me as an experience. I have my reservations about it from a distance, but in the room, it will affect audiences. I'm curious to see who picks this up and how they handle it. I'm fairly sure that one way or another, you'll get a chance to see "Silent House" for yourself, and soon.
It's a full day of screenings today, and I'll be reporting in as I can.
News From Our Partners
- 'Star Trek Into Darkness' Takes Box-Office Crown With $84 Million 'Arrested Development' Gang: Where Are They Now? 'Star Trek Into Darkness': What's Next For J.J. Abrams And The Cast?
- The Telefile - Veep: The Episode's Best Insults The Telefile - Saturday Night Live: Straight Outta 8H The Telefile - Game of Thrones: Our Weekly Westeros Scorecard
- 'Hansel & Gretel: Witch Hunters': Jeremy Renner Never Read the Script Before Signing On 'Angry Birds' Movie Flies Forward Jennifer Lawrence as Mystique: First Look at the Actress in 'X-Men: Days of Future Past'
- What to Watch Tonight: The Season Finales of Rectify and Hawaii Five-0 and the Series Premieres of The Goodwin Games and Motive Mad Men "The Crash" Review: Uppers Give You Wings! News Briefs: CBS Is Pulling Mike & Molly's Season Finale Due to a Tornado Storyline
- FX's 'The Strain' Taps 'Alias' Mia Maestro as Female Lead FX's 'Tyrant': Ang Lee Drops out of Directing the Pilot, Cites 'Life of Pi' Exhaustion NBC's 'Siberia': New Reality-Skewing Drama Ordered for Summer
- William Bradley: Mad Men: 'Chevy Is Spelled Wrong!' PHOTOS: The Bluth Banana Stand Is Here! WATCH: Elisabeth Moss Was Nervous About Peggy's Future
- Ultra Music Festival Dates Announced, Tickets Go on Sale May 21 Girls' Generation's Jessica Poses With Purses in Vogue Girl [Pics] Austin Mahone vs. Jonas Brothers – Pop Clash
- Ranking the Blockbusters with Summer Movie Scorecard 2013 RT on DVD & Blu-Ray: The Last Stand and Side Effects Box Office Guru Wrapup: Star Trek Softer Than Expected at #1
The final film in the trilogy changes the way we look at the seriesTuesday, May 21, 2013
Plus he describes how he's like his character in the filmsMonday, May 20, 2013
One of the strangest moments of my online career involved the legendary musicianMonday, May 20, 2013
Instead, he explains how he feels the new film defines the whole trilogyMonday, May 20, 2013