Cannes Film Festival 2013

My BluRay Shelf: 'Benjamin Button' Criterion sets the new standard

Sound and picture are stellar, but the extras really go above and beyond

<p>Brad Pitt and Cate Blanchett star in 'The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button,' now available as a Criterion BluRay</p>

Brad Pitt and Cate Blanchett star in 'The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button,' now available as a Criterion BluRay

Credit: Paramount Home Video

I'm amazed at how many people I know who not only do not have BluRay in their homes yet, they've never even watched a movie on BluRay.  And they don't see any real reason to do so.  And while I understand that not everyone is as uber-nerdy about sound and picture presentation as I am, I have to believe that if people were able to sit down and check out a great presentation of a great transfer, they'd realize just how much it can enhance the viewing experience.

And right now, if I were going to use any live-action film to demo my system for someone, it would probably be "The Curious Case Of Benjamin Button."  No surprise for anyone who saw Paramount's amazing transfer of "Zodiac" on BluRay, and logical if you consider that Fincher shoots with the Viper camera, so you're looking at a high-def transfer of high-def material, with no film involved in the process at all.  It makes a huge difference, and it allows you to really marvel at how much texture and color and warmth Fincher and his photographers manage to wring out of these cameras.  He's a pioneer in terms of how far he pushes HD photography right now... there's no one else shooting films like this right now, with the possible exception of Michael Mann, and even he hasn't really pushed the HD towards the same sort of lush and dreamy film look that Fincher has.  I think Mann actually likes the video qualities of HD, where Fincher seems determined to prove that it doesn't matter what camera you use... you can accomplish the same look, and that's all a matter of how your photographer approaches his job.

[more after the jump]

I've already written about the film at length in my original review at Ain't It Cool, and there's not much I'd add about the movie having seen it again a couple of times now.  Instead, let's address the actual BluRay package, put together by David Fincher's usual DVD team headed by David Prior (a great filmmaker in his own right, as anyone who's seen "AM1200" can vouch).  Even for Criterion, this is a better-than-average behind-the-scenes effort, and on a film as technically complicated as this one, it's great to get a look at how the entire thing comes together.  The film was in development for over 20 years, and the documentary traces each step of thta development, which would be interesting enough.  But then it also details exactly how the groundbreaking performance capture tech was developed and implemented, and that's what takes this into the real of essential viewing for anyone interested in the filmmaking process.  I don't love Fincher as a filmmaker because he uses all the toys... I love that he is a filmmaker who seems unafraid to try any of the toys if he believes that they're the best way to communicate an idea.  That's what impresses me about him... he may be cutting edge in terms of technique, but it's all in service of a classic set of storytelling skills.

Can't get enough of Motion/Captured? Don't miss a post with daily HitFix Blog Alerts. Sign up now.

Don't miss out. Add Motion/Captured to your iGoogle, My Yahoo or My MSN experience by clicking here.

Not part of the HitFix Nation yet? Take 90 seconds and sign up today.

Comments

  • Option 1

    Comment instantly as a guest Guest
  • Option 2

    Connect
  • Option 3

    Login or create a HitFix account Login Signup
  • Default-avatar

    Danger Mouse

    Count me in as one who does not have a Blu Ray player and has not seen any Blu Ray movies. For me it has more to do with cost than anything else. That, and I still have two conventional TV sets. I don't plan on buying a new TV until both of those die so there's not much point in buying a Blu Ray player and the movies that go along with it. It's all about money...

    May 12, 2009 at 7:13PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Thequestion_talkback_profile

    SilentBobX

    I have seen bluray movies, most notably Justice League: New Frontier, and The Illusionist, which look spectacular in bluray. Great stuff and highly recommended.

    May 12, 2009 at 8:46PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Xavier_s_talkback_profile

    lazygarfield

    It is mainly about the cost Drew. You can not imagine how much of a pain it is for normal middle-class families to but a +$200 player, a big HDTV, great speakers.. just so you can subsequently spend around $20-$40 for each movie then on... Watching movies and reviewing movies is ur job, so the cost factor doesn't come into u (that much), but for normal households, no way.... And that is the main reason, why people turn to piracy.. the cost for buying things legally is way too much... The other major reason being non-availability of things in the legal format. for example, I live in India and here, Benjamin Button is not available on VCD / DVD, leave alone BluRay. so, if I want to see the movie in Hi-Def, guess which path I will turn to?

    May 13, 2009 at 6:21AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    abcdefz

    Cost -- yep; me, too.

    Heck, I sold off about 400 DVDs once I realized I was really just collecting. It's cheaper, overall, to just rent the movies I want, even if that means renting MILLER'S CROSSING for the sixtieth time. Overall, it's way cheaper.

    The downside is that none of the rental services out there have very clean discs, so if I had kept all of mine, at least I would have been assured of their condition. Too many rental places stock stuff that's all scratched to hell....

    May 13, 2009 at 8:26AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    nick_r

    Interesting. Many people on AVSForum have given the disc a relatively low score considering its Criterion pedigree -- placing it somewhere near the top of the third tier in terms of picture quality.

    May 13, 2009 at 12:13PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    JoeK

    I'm sometimes worry that BluRay is almost too good to succeed over time. I worry most that whatever internet standard abolishes actually purchasing media will be inferior to it...and if you pay any attention to HD quality broadcasts already offered by those in the business of doing so you'll see why that is something worth worrying about. The price barrier could really come down though - the players and the software are still too much money for anyone but the early adopters and geeks/techies. With all the HDTV's being sold though it is surprising that these customers can't similarly be convinced to upgrade their DVD players. Standard still looks damn good upscaled and anyone taking a moment to look at a Blu on an HDTV should be convinced pretty quickly of its superiority. From that standpoint I don't think it's solely a price issue on the hardware (i.e. if someone is willing to upgrade their TV that much, their player should be a relatively easy convince too) but the software is definitely still in enthusiast only territory for now. Hope it changes in time for the format to thrive.

    May 13, 2009 at 2:23PM EST Reply to Comment

Get Instant Alerts on Motion/Captured

Latest Posts
More Posts
Recent Activity on Facebook
Most Popular on Facebook
Top Stories From Around the Web