After the Merge, both sides are unsure of who to trust, leading to a wacky Tribal Council
Parvati of 'Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains'
Credit: CBS
Pre-credit sequence. Poor Courtney, voted out last week and barely mentioned in the pre-credit recap. Will anybody even notice she's gone? Heck, the episode doesn't even start with the Villains. Instead, the Heroes are sitting around the fire on Day 25 praying for a Merge. With all the momentum they've gained in recent weeks, you'd think they'd be confident, but all five Heroes are miserable. Amanda and Rupert go out for Tree-Mail and receive a locked chest warning them that company will be arriving soon with a key. Meanwhile, over at their camp, the Villains have discovered a key and a note. I wonder what the key is to! Sandra does a crazy little Merge Dance. Russell knows that he has to begin by going to JT to explain what happened at the previous Tribal Council. They concoct some elaborate story about multiple Idols being played and a strategy to get JT out. Weighted down with Idols, Russell and his alliance march off to Heroes camp vowing to send the Good Guys down in flames. But did Sandra overhear their nefarious plan? We'll see!
Full recap of Thursday's (April 22) Merge-tastic "
Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains" after the break...
Hell hath no fury like a Parvati scorned. Parvati is cocky. She thinks that she and Russell are the King and Queen, but she has her secret, specifically the Idol she found last week. The Villains arrive at Heroes camp and JT notices that Parvati is still there. That concerns him. For about two seconds. But then he sees that the Bandy-Legged Little Troll there and he makes the Double Immunity Idol all on his own. Stupidity, thy name is JT. Hugs are exchanged, new buffs are acquired and a feast begins. They appear to have a whole pig and piles and vegetables. Jerri suggests that they call the team "All Villains," which outrages Rupert. The early conversations range between boring and disgusting. Parvati, though, isn't happy with how unhappy people are to see her. She knows that she's going to be targeted. Parvati also doesn't understand why everybody thinks she's stupid. "They don't know it yet, but they're about to be picked off one by one," Parvati promises.
Two versions of the truth. Finally, Russell gets quiet time with JT and Rupert. Russell has an elaborate and complicated story explaining how things came to pass at the previous Tribal Council. He swears on his kids that he's allied with the Heroes. "He's a good-old country boy," says JT, who trusts Russell explicitly, tossing out and then disregarding the notion that Russell could possibly be leading a female alliance. "Hook, line and sinker," Russell says, "They're buying everything I'm selling them." But Sandra decides to throw a wrench into the machinery and she approaches Rupert and announces that she's the last of her alliance. "Russell's the kingpin and Parvati's the second-in-command," she tells Rupert. To his credit, Rupert actually believes Sandra. "Boy," Rupert sighs, "This is where the game gets crazy."
Banana Etiquette, Part II. The Villains are immediately impressed with how much food the Heroes have and they've decided to have five or six square meals a day. Rupert explains the rules: You can eat as many coconuts as you want, but don't mess with the bananas or papayas. Silly Parvati doesn't know about Banana Etiquette. She should ask James about it next time she sees him. Fueled by a paranoia so strong it's making him sweat, Rupert takes the Heroes off into the woods and he explains to them what Russell did and how Russell is playing them. JT refuses to believe it. Even Amanda refuses to believe. Rupert proposes a plan of changing up their first vote as a test of Russell's devotion. "There's a reason that I've been doing Rupert's strategical play for him so far," JT says. Wow. JT is really lobbying to get his picture appended to the definition of "dumbass hubris" in all future dictionaries. Again, he admits to the possibility that Russell might be lying and that he could be the next one out and again JT denies that it could be a viable possibility.
An alliance *and* a bikini calendar. Amanda and Parvati wander into the jungle. Amanda regretfully tells Parvati that she has no power and that Parvati has a target on her back. Amanda tells her Micronesia that the only alternative would be to get Sandra out instead. She also promises to tell Parvati how everybody's voting. After this proffer of potential honesty, Parvati admits to Amanda that she has an Idol. To the camera, Amanda shows a little more intellect and says that she's only telling Parvati so much, because she doesn't want to go to the Finals with her again. They spend several minutes ascertaining the other's trust and they close with a secret handshake, specifically an exploding fist-bump. Couldn't they have settled their alliance by making out or something? Just a suggestion.
Is anybody surprised Danielle knows how to work the pole? It seems "Yin Yang" was what the merged tribe chose as their name. Their first Immunity Challenge is pure endurance. The players have to cling onto a notched pole and not fall down. Colby bails first, followed quickly by Sandra. Russell goes out and then Rupert goes sliding down. Amanda hopps down. In an amusing moment, JT slides down the pole and catches himself and then climbs back. But it's false bravado. He goes out next, leaving Candice trying to hold out against Danielle, Parvati and Jerri. Parvati sports a one-handed posture that's both sexy *and* practical. After 90 minutes, Jerri goes out. Candice is about to go out, but Jeff Probst is having none of it. He stops her and asks her why she's quitting, but he can't stop the last Hero from bailing. Danielle reaches an agreement of some sort with Parvati, allowing Danielle to win Immunity. Rupert sees Parvati's move and suspects it's a sign that she already has an Idol. I've gotta say: Rupert had been stupid, physically weak and awfully embarrassing this season, but suddenly tonight he's offering a reminder of the Rupert of old.
Little Green Men. There are two whales in the water and two emaciated women leading the Yin Yang tribe back to camp. Even JT thought that Parvati's choice to step down was sketchy. They're planning a reverse to vote out Sandra, though Colby says he'd vote Jerri out as well. Sandra isn't sure, however, if she blew it by warning Rupert about Russell, who she knows she's stuck with. For his part, Russell is prepared to give Parvati an Idol for the second time in the game. "Oh you..." Parvati giggles. That gives Parvati two Idols. "I have two little green men protecting me," Parvati cackles, admitting that she may, in fact, be the strongest player in the game. Later, on the beach, Amanda laments to Parvati that she doesn't know how she can stay true to her tribe and to Parvati, warning her that playing her Idol might be a good idea. Amanda, however, says that she isn't sure how the vote is going, which Parvati isn't believing. "My head hurts," Amanda says, figuring out the possibilities. Parvati leaves for Tribal Council unsure of what comes next.
Tribal Council. Courtney has, as promised, gotten all prettied up for her first Jury appearance. Rupert begins by raising Banana Etiquette. His problem is with eating ripe bananas. Danielle's having none of it. When she wants a banana, she's gonna eat a banana, darnit. "There's two separate tribes... the game is on," Russell says, admitting that tonight's vote will dictate the rest of the game. JT's feeling hurt that nobody talked to him, feeling like his name is getting written down. Jerri, though, says that it was JT who put up a wall. Parvati says she feels like a leper to which Jeff replies, "Is that just used to the fact that you're used to getting attention all of the time in life?" Everybody admits that Idols are important, especially the Villains, who recall Tyson's game-changing blunder.
The vote. Russell writes JT's name down, "You seem like a real cool guy, but it was a real dumb move giving me the Idol," Russell tells him. Parvati also writes JT's name and blows him a kiss. Danielle writes JT's name down, while Amanda, Candice and Rupert write Jerri's name down. So this all comes down to whether or not Parvati plays the Idol and exposes everything? Jeff asks if an Idol is going to be played. Everybody turns to Parvati and Parvati hands one Idol to Sandra... and hands another Idol to JERRI. I have no idea who made the call, but that was flipping brilliant. JT and Rupert have no idea what to do. They're astounded. On one hand, Russell has been exposed, but it doesn't even matter. The votes: Jerri. Jerri. Jerri. Jerri. Jerri. JT. JT. JT. And JT is out of the game. "You have some explaining to do," Russell tells Parvati. "In a game full of crazy moves, that was one of the craziest," Jeff says. JT is properly chastened. "I feel like a total idiot right now. It's pretty terrible to be voted out by your own Idol." He adds that you can never trust women.
Bottom Line: OK. So that was interesting. In fact, that was insanely interesting. And I genuinely have no idea if what Parvati did was completely brilliant or brilliantly stupid. Probably the answer is, "Brilliant," right? Parvati entered with two Idols and left with Zero. That's not so good. She exposed Russell to the Heroes, but that was inevitable and she did it in a way that kept the Villain majority. That's brilliant. She made a move nobody in their right minds could have protected and effectively gave Immunity to three of her female Villain colleagues at once. That's BRILLIANT. But she also did it in a way that left *Russell* feeling blindsided, which isn't so brilliant. So maybe it wasn't brilliant? Because we all know that there's nothing Russell hates more than being made to look like a fool. So if Parvati had warned Russell beforehand, would that have made her move more brilliant or less brilliant? Seriously, readers... I'm having a hard time deciding. I do know that what Parvati did tonight was awesome television. Also, as a side question, is it better that we didn't see or hear anything about Parvati's plan beforehand? She couldn't really have decided to do that on the spot, could she?
Sound off... Brilliant? Idiotic? Brilliantly idiotic? Idiotically brilliant?
A long-time member of the TCA Board and a longer-time blogger of "American Idol," Dan Fienberg writes about TV, except for when he writes about movies or sometimes writes about the Red Sox. But never music. He would sound stupid talking about music.
Comments
Option 1
Comment instantly as a guest GuestOption 2
Option 3
Login or create a HitFix account Login Signupforg
April 22, 2010 at 9:48PM EST Reply to CommentI love you Parvati, you showed that Russel isn't the only running this game! For me it was a brilliant move, yeah Russel might be mad but I doubt that he would flip flop to the Heroes side or scheme to get Parvati off, Russel will think long term and will stick with her alliance with Parvati because he could probably win with the jury against Parvati. It was really good that they didn't hint that Parvati would give out her two idols because it made for a truly jaw dropping moment. And I wonder if there is a secret alliance between Parvati and Sandra, I mean they are former winners and they would probably think that the best shot of winning this game is to face the jury with a fellow winner.
And yes Rupert finally showed some brilliance this episode although the banana etiquette is still annoying. Colby is still meh.
CarolSD
April 22, 2010 at 9:48PM EST Reply to CommentFirst: JT so deserved to go. Excellent.
Second: Parvatis=Stupid. Should have kept one idol to save her butt next vote. Jerri gone-who cares? Russ will never trust Parvati (fully) again. Ding. Everybody will (er, should) be gunning for her next time. Ding. Sandra isn't with the old Villians tribe even if Parvati gave her an idol. (so there's no numbers advantage). Ding. It's all about new alliances and individuals now. I'm kind of hoping Colby has been 'playing' everybody the past several weeks. I'm waiting to see if he turns on the energy when it's the right time. He seems to be pacing himself and not being the "obvious one to beat."
April 22, 2010 at 11:03PM EST Reply to CommentIn JT's defense (sort of, though I have no problem calling him a bonehead for his love letter) if he had been right it would have been brilliant. So, he wasn't stupid, he was just *wrong*.
I'm going to say that everything Parvati did falls into the "brilliant" category. The Russell issue is a sensitive one because he's a gigantic, whiny baby when people dare to do something he hasn't orchestrated, but she gave Sandra and Jerri idols, ultimately saving Jerri from being voted out, which makes both of them a bit indebted to her. With Sandra, theoretically, comes Rupert in some small part. I fear that she'll stick with her Russell alliance (though Parvati's already rocked the girl alliance successfully in the past and could easily do it again) but she should be 100% safe for the next vote because I can't see the majority turning against her immediately. She just needs to worry about the vote after that one.
Rich
April 23, 2010 at 12:31AM EST Reply to CommentGiving away immunity is ALWAYS stupid. JT was very, very stupid to give it to another tribe. Was his logic sound? Yes. But he couldn't possibly have known what was going on at the other tribe and he said it best himself: can't trust a villain.
JT has to be the worst thinker of any former winner. Again he reinforced that Steven was the brains.
Sandra is a wild card at this point. I think she'll scheme to get Russell out next time and then she could very well flip back to the villains.
April 23, 2010 at 12:43AM EST Reply to CommentAs for whether that was brilliant strategy -- it's too early to say. But it was certainly brilliant TV, and I suspect that was (at least part of) what Parvati was concerned with.
I have to believe Parvati wasn't basing that decision on strategy as much as she was basing it on making great TV. She had the chance to make an epic move, the kind of shocking power play that will make her "Survivor" legend. It's too tempting not to do it.
And, from a strategy point-of-view, I don't think it really puts her in a bad position. She already had a ton of people gunning for her -- and with that move she managed to eliminate one of them (JT), tip the numbers in favor of the Villains, show that she's a team player who will stick her neck out for others, gain two new fans and likely votes should she make it to the end (although I could still see Sandra voting against her).
The *only* downside is that she pissed Russell off -- but she's absurdly charming, and he's been eating out of her hand for weeks. Sad as it may be, she knows she can just flirt her way back into his good graces. Besides, where else can he go? It's not like the Heroes will want him now, either.
I'll be honest: I can't stand Parvati. She reminds me of every girl who ever picked on me in high school. She's smug and arrogant to a nauseating degree.
But I've got to give her props. This was brilliant in every conceivable way.
MJ
April 23, 2010 at 1:19AM EST Reply to CommentCan hidden immunity idols be played on tiebreaks? If so, it was a REALLY bad move by Parvati. They had to know that they had 5 votes lined up against JT, so at worst, it was going to be a 5-5 tie based on tribes.
Therefore, if the HII CAN be played on the tie, the best play is to let it go to the tie, see which Villain the Heroes chose to go after, and give the HII on the tie break vote to the person who needs it. Because JT had given away the hero-side HII to the Villains (which they knew), there was no fear of a Hero playing the HII on a tie break vote.
This way, only one HII would need to be played, Russell wouldn't have freaked out, and Parvati could have kept her second HII.
This is, of course, all contingent on an HII being playable on the tiebreak vote.
reno
April 23, 2010 at 2:09PM EST Reply to CommentThe big mistake on the villians wasn't dumping the idol, it was dumping Courtney and keeping Sandrah. She was so tight with Rupert she threw away all their food when he got voted out of her tribe last time. Courtney would have gone where the wind blows, Sandra will gun for Russell and Parv till the very end, and if she makes it she will have the jury over the rest of the villians.
Jeff W.
April 23, 2010 at 4:01PM EST Reply to CommentI'm shocked:
http://www.theadvertiser.com/article/20100423/NEWS01/100423011/UPDATED-2-p.m.-Survivor-contestant-Russell-Hantz-arrested-in-Lafayette
steve
April 23, 2010 at 4:03PM EST Reply to CommentAbsolutely brilliant! I get the feeling, though, that there is a whole bunch we didn't see prior to TC but so what? Made the move that much more sweet.
The best part of the whole thing is that there is absolutely nothing Russell can do to her, regardless of how bruised his ego. Queen Parv is running the show again! Awesome. Parvati has now earned so much goodwill with Jerri and Sandra that even if it is temporary, Russell is Yin Yang enemy Numero Uno for EVEYONE! But, as we all know, Russell Hantz plays second chair to no one so I look for the King to start making contingency plans. But the gamne is Parvati's to win (or lose) right now...
My feeling is that it's far too early in the merge for Sandra to consider flipping sides. In Survivor, you make moves when there is an odd number of competitors remaining and while 9 is possibility, 7 seems more likely although she should start planting the seeds of Russell's destruction now. Depends on which Heroes are left at the time, of course.
The question now is, what do the remaining heroes do to save themselves? I have no doubt that Amanda and Candace will try to work something and Rupe might try to set something up with Sandra but who will the Villians target next? My best guess would be the old Pirate himself given his connection to Sandra. Colby's been a bust and a Jerri/Colby alliance ain't ever gonna happen given their history so he's not much of a threat. Candace hasn't done much of anything (that we've seen) so TC fodder, really. Or, did Amanda's attempts to play Parvati backfire placing a big target on her back. I guess we shall see and I, for one, can't wait!
April 25, 2010 at 5:05PM EST Reply to CommentInsanely brilliant would have been to share the plan with Russell, and then have him write Parvati's name down with his little signature, like he did on the Coach-vote (when he voted Courtney). Seeing as the plan already hinged on Parvati getting no votes, that would have left them in the same position as now, but with the Heroes actually STILL believing Russell was on their side, and that there was a woman's alliance!
Of course, that would have been a riskier move, as Parvati could then potentially have gone out if the Heroes' votes had been for her - as it was now, the only Villain who could have been voted out was Russell (5 votes Parvati-5 votes JT would have led to a split vote and a stone-pick, which all the Villain women and JT would've been immune from)