Spanish selectors ignore Almodóvar, as Sony picks up Lebanese Oscar hopeful
Spain instead submits 'Black Bread' for the foreign-language Oscar
Elena Anaya and Antonio Banderas in Pedro Almodovar's "The Skin I Live In," which will not compete for the Best Foreign Language Film Oscar.
Are you a fan of Academy Awards?
Sign up to get the latest updates instantly.
We'll lead this foreign-language Oscar update with a promising bit of news on a previously announced submission. Lebanon's entry, Nadine Labaki's feminist comedy "Where Do We Go Now?" has just been picked up for US distribution by Sony Pictures Classics.
This is hardly surprising news at this point: buzz on Labaki's film has soared since it surprised everyone by scooping the Audience Award at the Toronto Film Festival, and the folks at Sony, which has overwhelmingly dominated this Oscar category in recent years, know a prime contender when they see one. This seals the film's status as one of the favorites for a nomination -- a remarkably quick turnaround for a film that generated little chatter when it debuted at Cannes.
Meanwhile, regular observers of the Best Foreign Language Film Oscar race could have seen this next announcement coming. For the second time in a row, the latest film from Spain's most celebrated auteur, Pedro Almodóvar, has not been selected as the country's official submission for the award. His kinky, Cannes-endorsed thriller "The Skin I Live In" was one of three films shortlisted for the honor, but has been passed over in favor of Agustí Villaronga's Franco-era child's-eye saga "Black Bread."
Almodóvar's fanbase is such that the kneejerk media response to such news is that an injustice has been done, but my sense is that the Spanish selectors have chosen wisely. I haven't seen "Black Bread," which recently won an armload of Goya Awards (one year after taking Best Actress at the San Sebastian Film Festival) to rave reviews from local critics and mixed ones from the international crowd, but it sounds potentially right up the Academy's alley: serious-minded period dramas about the effects of war on children have found a home in voters' hearts on numerous previous occasions.
I don't count Almodóvar's enjoyable but emotionally hollow twistathon among his best films (check out my Cannes review here), but even if I did, its sexual and gender preoccupations probably wouldn't appeal to the foreign-language branch's more conservative voters; meanwhile, I suspect the executive committee prefers to reserve their "save" votes for fresher work from less amply rewarded directors. Whether the Spanish have chosen the better film I can't say, but they've clearly chosen their stronger contender.
Much is made of the Spanish selection panel's on-off relationship with the veteran director, but you can hardly blame them for wanting to give other filmmakers a turn: Almodóvar's represented Spain on five previous occasions, cracking the nominee list twice, and winning once. There's no denying that they screwed up by not submitting "Talk To Her" in 2002 -- a truth the Academy underlined by handing Almodóvar a Best Original Screenplay Oscar that year -- but there's no reason why his lesser works should get automatic preference.
In other news, two European countries have entered films that premiered at the recent Venice Film Festival. Italy -- the country that holds the record for most wins in the category -- has opted for Emmanuel Crialese's "Terraferma," a contemporary illegal-immigrant drama that played to tepid reviews on the Lido, but nonetheless wound up winning the Special Jury Prize from Darren Aronofsky's panel. I missed the film, but as a fan of Crialese's "Golden Door," I look forward to catching up with it at the upcoming London Film Festival and deciding for myself. On paper, it sounds like the film's alleged blend of sentiment and hot-button social issues could find favor among voters, particularly given the country's track record.
I have, on the other hand, seen Switzerland's entry "Summer Games," a tale of a broken, abuse-plagued family unravelling over the course of a summer camping vacation, viewed largely from the perspective of their oldest son. I'll write about the film at greater length in a future round-up of Oscar-submission reviews, but it's a modest, affecting, slightly overcooked piece that I don't see gaining much traction among voters, even with the ever-popular kid-protagonist angle.
Other countries that have submitted films since our last update include Cuba ("Habanastation"), Thailand ("Kon Kohn") and Uruguay ("The Silent House"). As always, any thoughts or information you might have on these or other submissions are most welcome in the comments. Here's the full list as it currently stands:
Albania - “The Forgiveness of Blood”
Austria - “Breathing”
Belgium - “Bullhead”
Bosnia and Herzegovina - “Belvedere”
Brazil - “Elite Squad 2″
Bulgaria - “Tilt”
Canada - “Monsieur Lazhar”
Chile - “Violeta"
China - “The Flowers of War”
Colombia - “The Colors of the Mountain”
Cuba - "Habanastation"
Czech Republic - “Alois Nebel”
Denmark - “SuperClasico”
Finland - “Le Havre”
France - “Declaration of War”
Germany - “Pina”
Greece - “Attenberg”
Hong Kong - “A Simple Life”
Hungary - “The Turin Horse”
Iceland - “Volcano”
India - “Adaminte Makan Abu”
Iran - “A Separation”
Ireland - “As If I Am Not There”
Israel - “Footnote”
Italy - "Terraferma"
Japan - “Postcard”
Lebanon - “Where Do We Go Now?”
Lithuania - “Back in Your Arms”
Mexico - “Miss Bala”
Morocco - “Omar Killed Me”
Netherlands - “Sonny Boy”
Norway - “Happy, Happy”
Peru - “October”
Philippines - “The Woman in the Septic Tank”
Poland - “In Darkness”
Portugal - “José and Pilar”
Romania - “Morgen”
Russia - “Burnt by the Sun 2: Citadel”
Serbia - “Montevideo, God Bless You!”
Slovakia - “Gypsy”
South Africa - “Beauty”
South Korea - “The Front Line”
Spain - "Black Bread"
Sweden - “Beyond”
Taiwan - “Warriors of the Rainbow: Seediq Bale”
Thailand - "Kon Khon"
Uruguay - "The Silent House"
Venezuela - “The Rumble of the Stones”
Vietnam - “Thang Long Aspiration”
2012-2013 OSCAR PREDICTIONS
Best Picture
Best Director
Best Actor
Best Actress
Best Supporting Actor
Best Supporting Actress
Best Adapted Screenplay
Best Original Screenplay
Best Cinematography
Best Costume Design
Best Film Editing
Best Makeup And Hairstyling
Best Original Score
Best Original Song
Best Production Design
Best Sound Editing
Best Sound Mixing
Best Visual Effects
Best Animated Feature Film
Best Documentary Feature
Best Foreign Language Film
Latest Posts
-
How has the franchise fared at the Academy Awards over the decades?Saturday, May 18, 2013
-
Competition's first outright dud is a major letdown from Arnaud DesplechinSaturday, May 18, 2013
-
Un Certain Regard entry sets pulses racing with surfeit of steamy gay actionFriday, May 17, 2013
-
Matthias Schoenaerts will also star in the Fox Searchlight co-productionFriday, May 17, 2013




Comments
Option 1
Comment instantly as a guest GuestOption 2
Option 3
Login or create a HitFix account Login SignupFrank Lee
September 28, 2011 at 10:08PM EST Reply to CommentCould there be a more ominous and dispiriting phrase than "feminist comedy"?
Guy Lodge Until I see the film, I'm just calling it as I keep hearing it described. Perhaps it isn't -- the rash of think-pieces about "Bridesmaids" this summer proved that many are overly quick to equate the terms "feminist" and "about women."
September 28, 2011 at 10:18PM ESTIn any event, I'm pro-feminist and pro-comedy, so I can live with it.
Mykill
September 29, 2011 at 12:39AM EST Reply to CommentI really really liked "The Silent House" quite a lot, but there is NO WAY in hell it will get nominated. It is basically a "semi"-handheld camera horror movie in the vein of Paranormal Activity that is said to have been filmed in one single take (a la Russian Ark) - but there are moments in pitch black which could have easily been done to hide an edit or two. Totally recommended for all the genre fans out there. I think it is pretty cool that Uruguay submitted that film, and I hope it gets some more attention for the original before the remake starring Elizabeth Olsen comes out.
Vn
September 29, 2011 at 2:53AM EST Reply to CommentHey Guy, just a note on your great article. 'Black bread' didn't win best actress at San Sebastian Film Festival. It was the other film shortlisted along with 'Black bread' and 'The skin i live in' which is 'La voz dormida' ('The sleeping voice').
The thing is that this time there really wasn't a feeling that Almodovar has been snubbed. 'The Skin I live in' is a box office success but everyone knows is not one of Almodovar's best, it divided critics not only here in Spain but around the globe. 'Black bread' is just an opportunity for Spain's industry to send a movie in catalan for the first time and a terrific film at the end. Don't forget how Academy loves a foreign film with children ('Kolia').
Guy Lodge Actually, the film won Best Actress for Nora Navas at last year's San Sebastian Film Festival -- I got my years mixed up.
September 29, 2011 at 4:35AM ESTAnd I'm certainly not forgetting how much the Academy loves foreign films with children -- I raise that point twice in this article alone!
Vn
September 29, 2011 at 2:53AM EST Reply to CommentHey Guy, just a note on your great article. 'Black bread' didn't win best actress at San Sebastian Film Festival. It was the other film shortlisted along with 'Black bread' and 'The skin i live in' which is 'La voz dormida' ('The sleeping voice').
The thing is that this time there really wasn't a feeling that Almodovar has been snubbed. 'The Skin I live in' is a box office success but everyone knows is not one of Almodovar's best, it divided critics not only here in Spain but around the globe. 'Black bread' is just an opportunity for Spain's industry to send a movie in catalan for the first time and a terrific film at the end. Don't forget how Academy loves a foreign film with children ('Kolia').
Vn
September 29, 2011 at 2:53AM EST Reply to CommentWrite a comment...Hey Guy, just a note on your great article. 'Black bread' didn't win best actress at San Sebastian Film Festival. It was the other film shortlisted along with 'Black bread' and 'The skin i live in' which is 'La voz dormida' ('The sleeping voice').
The thing is that this time there really wasn't a feeling that Almodovar has been snubbed. 'The Skin I live in' is a box office success but everyone knows is not one of Almodovar's best, it divided critics not only here in Spain but around the globe. 'Black bread' is just an opportunity for Spain's industry to send a movie in catalan for the first time and a terrific film at the end. Don't forget how Academy loves a foreign film with children ('Kolia').
John
September 29, 2011 at 7:53AM EST Reply to CommentSpain did well. Black bread is a great film, maybe one of the best ever made about the life after the civil war. And the performances of almost all the cast are terrific.
GlennAU
September 29, 2011 at 8:13AM EST Reply to Comment"The Silent House" is a (pardon the language) fucking joke of movie. I saw it at a film festival over a year ago and it still makes me angry. Some really scare scenes scattered about, but that ending spits in the face of anybody who actually likes horror movies.
In other news, I was happy to hear New Zealand have submitted their first ever film. It's spoken in Samoan, I believe.
Mykill The ending to "The Silent House" was rather divisive, but I kinda liked it b/c of how out of left field it was. I thought it was a fun viewing experience, but it was missing something that would've perhaps made the film even better.
September 29, 2011 at 9:24AM ESTglebe
September 29, 2011 at 9:43AM EST Reply to CommentBlack Bread didn't do very much for me. Even though I know a bit about the Spanish Civil War and Franco, I suspect some of it was lost in translation. The surreal elements bored me and the drama in the central conflict never grabbed me.
One review I read said all that results is that the boy learns adults can be awful and I was just as underwhelmed.
On the other hand, they seem to really love it in Spain. It may tap into something cultural and historical there that was hard to me to share as an outsider.
Mark
September 29, 2011 at 1:42PM EST Reply to CommentWhat countries are still expected to be represented that have not picked a film yet?
glebe
October 1, 2011 at 3:08PM EST Reply to CommentI saw Elite Squad 2 yesterday and it's absolutely fantastic. The action sequences are thrilling, but the real impact comes from the examination of political corruption. Great performances, beautifully shot. I saw the first and didn't care for it but I loved #2.
Salvatore
October 3, 2011 at 7:16AM EST Reply to CommentNot all reviews of Terraferma were tepid. There were some raving ones because the film, indeed, is poetic and beautifully shot. The final scene, for instance, is pure genius.