Cannes Film Festival 2013

Oscarweb Round-up: Questioning the accuracy of 'Moneyball'

Also: Gold Derby kicks off its pundit poll and Roger Ebert's memoir gets some Gray Lady ink

<p>Chris Pratt stars as catcher-turned-first baseman Scott Hatteberg in "Moneyball."</p>

Chris Pratt stars as catcher-turned-first baseman Scott Hatteberg in "Moneyball."

Credit: Columbia Pictures

Are you a fan of Academy Awards?

Sign up to get the latest updates instantly.

Any time an Oscar contender comes along that dabbles in real-life situations and circumstances, you can see the take-down measures coming from a mile away: accuracy gripes. It's a story as old as time. Films like "The Hurricane," "A Beautiful Mind," "The Hurt Locker" and, just last year, "The Social Network" have come under fire during the Oscar race for liberties taken with the narrative, and it's always just such a tiresome, tedious argument. So you can bet baseball fan Steve Pond's recent piece, linked in today's round-up, which addresses the gripes from the sports world, will be the king of logic used by a smear campaign if one is even deemed necessary by "Moneyball" competition this year. Let me be clear that Steve is fair in his piece, but it simply reminded me of how touchy true stories can be for many, and how limp the ammunition of "but it didn't happen that way" can truly be. It rarely passes the smell test because, the fact remains, if people like a movie, they like a movie. Whether it "happened that way" or not. Now, let's see what's going on in the Oscarweb today...

Steve Pond accuses Bennett Miller's "Moneyball" of not telling the real story and trying to put one over on its audience. [The Odds]

Want More...

Academy Awards?
  • Oscar-statues-outside-the-82nd-academy-awards-at-the-kodak-theater-in-hollywood-ca
    Check out everything there is including photos, reviews, videos.

Jonah Hill, meanwhile, talks about the film, idolizing Joe Pesci and being all grown up with Mark Harris. [Vulture]

Tom O'Neil straw pulls a boatload of pundits and awards commentators, including our own Guy Lodge. [Gold Derby]

Maureen Dowd writes up Roger Ebert's new autobiography, "Life Itself." [New York Times]

Ryland Walker Knight and Danny Kasman engage in "a fittingly geographically separated, electronically connected conversation" about "Contagion." [MUBI Notebook]

Jonathan Romney talks to Kirsten Dunst about the Lars Von Trier Cannes controversy and her work in Von Trier's film, "Melancholia." [Independent]

Jeff Wells keeps banging the gong for Olivia Colman in "Tyrannosaur." [Hollywood Elsewhere]

Anne Thompson takes note of half-eaten movie poster designs. [Thompson on Hollywood]

Kristopher-tapley-sm
Kristopher Tapley
Editor-at-Large
Kristopher Tapley has covered the film awards landscape for over a decade. He founded In Contention in 2005. His work has also appeared in The New York Times, The Times of London and Variety. He begs you not to take any of this too seriously.

Comments

  • Option 1

    Comment instantly as a guest Guest
  • Option 2

    Connect
  • Option 3

    Login or create a HitFix account Login Signup
  • Default-avatar

    Ryan

    From an audience perspective, 'Moneyball' does get a lot of the essence right, but there are a few instances that just made me go "NO! STOP!" because it was just so completely illogical (Beane flying anywhere to negotiate) or completely against the theory of "moneyball" (telling Art he didn't care about defense, one of the biggest tenants in sabrmetrics is the under appreciation of defense.)
    From an awards perspective, I don't think it should or will particularly matter because I highly doubt there are a lot of people who are Academy and SABR members.

    September 26, 2011 at 10:28AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    wisconsinkel

    If they made a 100% accurate movie, these same people would be complaining about how boring and pointless this movie is. You just can't win with these people. However, with the case of "Dolphin Tale," I'm offended that they even put the words "Based on a true story" at the start of the movie because, regardless of accuracy, it played like a heavily cliche [dialogue] fairy tale...the way the story unfolded just seemed so artificial

    September 26, 2011 at 11:20AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Casey Fiore

    What's important in terms of the quality of a film and it's historical accuracy is whether or not the point of the story is justly true. Moneyball wasn't really about the Oakland A's 2002 season, it was about a man who faced the challenge of winning a game in which all the cards are stacked against him. It is about economics and character. And while I took notice during the film that the importance of Miguel Tejada and Barry Zito et al was a bit muted, this is ultimately an ancillary detail because the value of these players does not change or discredit Billy Beane's efforts or character arc. It's not the same as, say, A Beautiful Mind, because the omitted and altered facts in that film allowed for the presentation of a fundamentally untrue characterization. Ron Howard and friends tailored the character to make him safer and more palatable, whereas the people responsible for Moneyball tailored the setting to augment the characterization.

    My point is, the ideas and characterizations of Moneyball are not rendered untrue by its differences from objective history, as A Beautiful mind's characterization is.

    September 26, 2011 at 11:34AM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Matthew Starr

    The film should have at least mentioned Zito/Hudson/Mulder.

    September 26, 2011 at 12:43PM EST Reply to Comment
    • The thing was that the movie emphasized the contributions of the "island of misfits" undervalued by MLB becuase of their age, pitching in an unorthodox way, etc - and given a second chance. It didn't focus on the A's stars like conventional movies - that's what I liked about it. We did see the back of Hudson's jersey, Tejada coming home, and the radio announcers acknowledging them. :-)

      September 28, 2011 at 9:23PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    me, yo

    What's up with that headline?

    September 26, 2011 at 2:19PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Krispic3_talkback_profile

      Kristopher Tapley Awesome typo, that's what's up.

      September 26, 2011 at 3:10PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    me, yo

    what up with that headline?

    September 26, 2011 at 2:20PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    JLPatt

    Then there's the fact that the song the girl sings in the movie, a song that becomes quite crucial to the story, wasn't released until 2008. Lots of people are jumping on this if they're not bothered by the sports stuff.

    P.S. It doesn't bother me at all, just saying

    September 26, 2011 at 2:39PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Default-avatar

      Matthew Starr I didn't even realize it was a real song but it annoyed the hell out of me, especially during the final shot.

      September 26, 2011 at 8:50PM EST
    • Default-avatar

      JLPatt Why? For me it provided two really beautiful moments of levity and pathos. The closing in particular is one of the film's best moments.

      September 26, 2011 at 11:54PM EST
    • @JLPATT: totally agree.
      @MATTHEW STARR: At the end, I think they should have cut the first stanza and just kept the 2nd stanza with its ending - which was very apropos to Billy Beane, and spoke to the sweet relationship father and daughter had.

      Anne Thompson did a great interview with Bennett Miller referring to Billy Beane wondering if he should have been living a different life - kind of like "being stuck in the middle." so I think it's appropriate.

      September 28, 2011 at 9:32PM EST
  • Com_truise_talkback_profile

    Chase Kahn

    People are complaining about the creative license of "Moneyball"? Haven't they seen "Killer Elite"?

    September 27, 2011 at 8:49AM EST Reply to Comment

Get Instant Alerts on In Contention

2012-2013 OSCAR PREDICTIONS

oscarside.jpg

Best Picture

Best Director

Best Actor

Best Actress

Best Supporting Actor

Best Supporting Actress

Best Adapted Screenplay

Best Original Screenplay

Best Cinematography

Best Costume Design

Best Film Editing

Best Makeup And Hairstyling

Best Original Score

Best Original Song

Best Production Design

Best Sound Editing

Best Sound Mixing

Best Visual Effects

Best Animated Feature Film

Best Documentary Feature

Best Foreign Language Film

Latest Posts
More Posts
Recent Activity on Facebook
Most Popular on Facebook