Film Festival

Oscar Watch: Has Disney permanently cut Miramax out of the awards season game?

A legendary label may be a prestige force no more

Oscar Watch: Has Disney permanently cut Miramax out of the awards season game?

The theatrical poster for Best Picture nominee "The Queen." Excellence in marketing that will be missed with a new scaled down version of Miramax in the works.

Credit: Miramax


Friday is becoming the day for Disney to break dramatic news over the past few months.  First, the surprise acquisition of Marvel Enterprises in August, then the not-so surprising departure of studio head Dick Cook (at least to those on the Disney lot) and now the expected and disheartening restructuring of Miramax (and at any moment, the not so secret revelation of Rich Ross as new head of the studio).

In a statement today, Disney announced the specialty division would be restructured with marketing and distribution moving to the companies Burbank headquarters.  The talented Daniel Battsek, who took over Miramax when the Weinstein brothers departed a little over four years ago in Sept. 2005, will remain in New York to run creative, development and production.  More importantly, the studio also said the company will reduce the number of films its releasing a year although what that means exactly is still unclear.

It's no secret Miramax had a difficult 2009 with disappointing results for Kristen Stewart's "Adventureland," Michelle Pfeiffer's "Cheri" (a truly botched campaign), the recent comedy "Extract" and Clive Owen's "The Boys Are Back" which opened with barely a whimper in limited release last weekend.  The studio still has the Robert DeNiro "Everbody's Fine" set for release in November. although whether Disney theatrical marketing and distribution will take over the marketing on the dramedy or if it will be the New York team's last gasp remains to be seen (will update with an answer when provided).

The writing on this move had been on the wall for sometime, however.  Disney's partnership with Steven Spielberg and Stacey Snider's DreamWorks is expected to produce between four and six non-family releases a year, many of which could be in the prestige vein.  Just at Paramount alone, DreamWorks released Oscar players such as "Dreamgirls," "Sweeny Todd," "Flags of our Fathers" and the upcoming "The Lovely Bones." That's a lot of adult fare when you brought Miramax into the mix.  Clearly, someone had to go or be downsized.  Additionally, Miramax had barely been in the acquisitions game having made no significant since Peter O'Toole's "Venus" out of the 2006 Telluride and Toronto Film Festivals.

Sadly, besides most of this year, Miramax had a tremendous amount of success under their current set up even rivaling (much to their dismay) the "glory years" of the Weinsteins.  Between 2006 and 2008 Miramax released Best Picture winner "No Country for Old Men," Best Picture nominee "The Queen," multiple nominee "The Diving Bell and the Butterfly," "There Will Be Blood" (internationally), "Becoming Jane" (a summer indie hit), "Happy-Go-Lucky" and Meryl Streep's "Doubt" (which would have been a best picture nominee if the ten nod system was in place last year).  Still, the disappointing, but mediocre returns for quality fare such as "Gone Baby Gone," "The Hoax" and "Smart People" could not have sat well with the parent company.  And the botched attempt to sell "Blindness" last year as a genre thriller had to be  a huge eyesore on the books in particular.

With Disney not providing details on how many films Miramax will now shepherd, it's just another sign of a dramatically changing prestige picture landscape.  Picturehouse was already missed (although reconstituted thankfully in a smaller set up at the new Apparition) and the brief shining life of Paramount Vantage is almost an afterthought in movie history.  Fox Searchlight is still in the game, but without Peter Rice to protect it, can it still thrive under its new bosses at big Fox?  Overture Films wants to be a serious player, but hasn't broken through beyond a few nominations (although that could change this year).  The Weinstein Company's financial troubles are well documented, but somehow they still manage to stay in the game.  Summit is certainly a player this year with "The Hurt Locker," but is that really part of the "Twilight" studio's long term strategy?  Right now, the most stable prestige player appears to be the incredibly consistent Sony Picture Classics, the broadening its base Focus Features (thank you "Coraline") and Lionsgate (and many would have laughed at that assertion for the mini-Lion just a few years ago). 

Oh, how times change.  Makes you almost afraid to see what the awards season game will resemble a year from now.

Comments

  • Option 1

    Comment instantly as a guest Guest
  • Option 2

    Connect
  • Option 3

    Login or create a HitFix account Login Signup
  • Samourai_talkback_profile

    kamikaze

    They're not big awards season spenders, but IFC and Magnolia have emerged as the top prestige distribs, now that some of the bigger indie players have fallen by the wayside (plus Sony Pictures Classics, which, as you point out, has consistently delivered quality films for years).

    October 2, 2009 at 5:54PM EST Reply to Comment
    • Yes, but they don't produce their own films. They only acquire. That's significant. If Apparition begins to develop their own films it will be an interesting mix. Also, until Magnolia or IFC has a major win it's hard to see them as significant players.

      October 2, 2009 at 6:48PM EST
  • Default-avatar

    caw

    Magnolia and IFC happen to find something that is/was marketable, hardly a dependable business plan. Disney is much better suited to develop film, commercial or art, and have the expertise to market and distribute which have been Miramax week points.

    October 2, 2009 at 8:55PM EST Reply to Comment
  • Default-avatar

    Comedy director

    Searchlight is fine as long as Tom Rothman is chairman - he started the division in the mid 90's. If Peter Rice is being groomed to be the next Chernin as people suspect, then he'll also be around to protect the label.

    October 3, 2009 at 8:26AM EST Reply to Comment
    • One of the reasons Searchlight did so well was because Rice pretty much had free reign with no interference from the big fox guys. It will be interesting to see if Utley and crew get that same breathing room. Amelia and Fantastic Mr. Fox (which was made by big Fox actually) will tell the tale.

      October 3, 2009 at 4:43PM EST
Gregory Ellwood

About This Blog

With over a decade of experience in the movie industry, Ellwood survived working for two major studios, launched the Hollywood Hitlist on MSN Movies and revamped The Envelope for the 07-08 season. A co-founder of HitFix, Ellwood spends his time relaxing on the basketball court. And even at his advanced age, can still hit a clutch 3 and keep up with those youngin's on the defensive end.

Get Instant Alerts on Awards Campaign

Latest Posts
More Posts
Recent Activity on Facebook
Most Popular on Facebook