Leonardo DiCaprio complicates the best actor race in speculative 'J. Edgar'
Is it George vs. Leo for the gold?
- Critic's Rating C+
- Readers' Rating A+
It may surprise viewers of "J. Edgar" to hear this, but J. Edgar Hoover, the longtime director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, was actually one of the most feared men of the 20th Century. Many of his tactics while running the FBI, such as the illegal use of wiretapping, destroyed people's lives and reputations. He illegally taped many of his superiors and their families as well as some of the greatest political figures of the day including Martin Luther King. He also had the FBI provide information to Sen. Joseph McCarthy to make the notorious McCarthy Hearings possible, one of the darkest periods in our nation's history.
Of course, Hoover is also responsible for the FBI's war against the Mafia and Gangsters in the 1930s which helped justify the need for the FBI. And then President Truman credited the FBI for making sure the nation was almost completely free of foreign espionage during WW II (at the same time Hoover also wanted to suspend the writ of habeas corpus and detain 12,000 "suspected" Americans). And through it all Hoover was a private and complicated man taking many secrets about his own life to the grave. However, the idea that he was in power for over 37 years, under six presidents, is quite remarkable. Now, 39 years after his death, enter Clint Eastwood and Dustin Lance Black's "J. Edgar," an epic and very, very speculative biopic about the director.
"J. Edgar" wants to tell Hoover's story, but because so little of his personal life has been corroborated (or even discredited) it mostly feels like a fantasy. Did he have a relationship with his longtime no 2. Clyde Tolson (Armie Hammer)? Did his mother (Judi Dench) really put a seed of self hate over his possible homosexuality in his mind? Was he really driven to protect the country from whomever he considered a "radical" more than any other domestic threat? Did he plan on asking Dorothy Lamour to marry him? Did he really blackmail every president except Nixon, Johnson and Eisenhower to stay in office? Your guess is as good as Black's best guess. It's certainly all possible and makes an intriguing portrait, but it's about as "true" as a film or mini-series about Queen Elizabeth I set in the 16th Century. Moreover, the film tiptoes around so many of his more nefarious deeds (the '50s and McCarthy are barely mentioned) that the picture slowly transforms into a portrait meant to justify Hoover's controversial life. It's troubling to realize some audiences who don't know that much about Hoover's history before seeing the film, will take a good chunk of it as fact. That's not the sort of film you'd expect from Clint Eastwood, is it? Well, luckily for the industry icon, Leonardo DiCaprio almost completely saves the day.
DiCaprio, Hammer and Eastwood hit the 'J. Edgar' premiere
AFI Film Fest kicks off with a major premiere
Leonardo DiCaprio ages 50+ years in 'J. Edgar' photos
Is this make up work Oscar worthy?
In the context of Oscar, it's now obvious the best actor race will come down to Clooney and DiCaprio. This pundit prefers the startling work of Michael Fassbender in "Shame," but that performance's win will likely be the nomination. DiCaprio has never won an Academy Award, but Clooney arguably is the best he's ever been in "The Descendants." He also is a prime contender for the two-time Oscar winner club (not that it will be at the forefront of most voters minds). DiCaprio is a three-time nominee who many mistakenly assume is already a winner when he isn't. Is it his time to actually grace the Kodak Theater stage? The Weinstein Company will have a legitimate shot with Jean Dujardin, but it's just hard to see him overtaking Clooney or DiCaprio in the last lap.
As for the rest of the cast, Hammer is fine as Tolson, but his "Oscar" scene is not his finest moment (over the top and out of character). I honestly don't see him getting a nod at this point. As for Dench, she's very good, but she'll likely be remembered by voters more for her upbeat and scene stealing role in "My Week with Marilyn." Naomi Watts is fine as Hoover's longtime assistant Helen Gandy, but there isn't much of an arc to her character and you forget she's in the film most of the time.
In other categories, the original screenplay category is always the weakest of the two screenwriting awards and this year is no different. "Edgar" could sneak in on Black's notoriety alone. And if the movie is a hit? Chances are it will find a way into the five. Make-Up is actually very competitive this year, but the work on DiCaprio's Hoover deserves some recognition.
"J. Edgar" opens nationwide on Nov. 7. It expands nationwide on Nov. 9.
For year round entertainment commentary and awards season news follow @HitFixGregory on Twitter.
News From Our Partners
- Crosstalk: How does Chris Brown get away with it? For Our Consideration: What do we mean when we call music pretentious? Interview: Michael Cera on the evolution of George Michael Bluth and working in Arrested Development’s writers’ room
- What to Watch Tonight: SYTYCD, Awkward., and the Finales of Grimm, The Game, and DWTS What to Watch Tonight: The Season Finales of Rectify and Hawaii Five-0 and the Series Premieres of The Goodwin Games and Motive Mad Men "The Crash" Review: Uppers Give You Wings!
- 'Bates Motel' Season 2: Will Norman Go Full 'Psycho?' FX's 'The Strain' Taps 'Alias' Star Mia Maestro as Female Lead FX's 'Tyrant': Ang Lee Drops out of Directing the Pilot, Cites 'Life of Pi' Exhaustion
- The Telefile - Veep: The Episode's Best Insults The Telefile - Saturday Night Live: Straight Outta 8H The Telefile - Game of Thrones: Our Weekly Westeros Scorecard
- 'Hansel & Gretel: Witch Hunters': Jeremy Renner Never Read the Script Before Signing On 'Angry Birds' Movie Flies Forward Jennifer Lawrence as Mystique: First Look at the Actress in 'X-Men: Days of Future Past'
- Ranking the Blockbusters with Summer Movie Scorecard 2013 RT on DVD & Blu-Ray: The Last Stand and Side Effects Box Office Guru Wrapup: Star Trek Softer Than Expected at #1
- 'The Voice' Live Round Recap: The Top 10 Perform Beyonce Is a 'Grown Woman' in Leaked Track Ultra Music Festival Dates Announced, Tickets Go on Sale May 21
- Heather Wagner: 'Hot In Orange County' John Barrowman's Surprising New Role WATCH: How A Frog Transformed Kerry Washington's Thinking
T Bone Burnett spills the beans...a bit earlyMonday, May 20, 2013
Is it possible to make these kids sympathetic?Monday, May 20, 2013
Where was Peeta?Sunday, May 19, 2013
Love and radiation in a nuclear worldSaturday, May 18, 2013