Madonna attends a special screening of "W.E." at the Museum of Modern Art in New York City.
Madonna attends a special screening of "W.E." at the Museum of Modern Art in New York City.
Credit: AP Photo/Evan Agostini, file

Why is Madonna's 'Masterpiece' ineligible for the Best Original Song Oscar?

One major factor kept the 'W.E.' tune out of contention

Though Madonna is clearly beloved by the Hollywood Foreign Press Association - having been nominated for a total of six Golden Globes (five for Best Original Song - Motion Picture and one for Best Actress in a Motion Picture - Comedy/Musical) and won once (in the latter category for "Evita") - the venerable performer simply can't catch a break from the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences.

Case in point: "Masterpiece", the Material Girl's now-Golden Globe-nominated song contribution to her second directorial effort "W.E.", was not among the 39 tunes announced by the Academy today as eligible for next year's Best Original Song Oscar. So what gives? Was it something she said?

As it turns out, the snub isn't personal - "Masterpiece" really isn't eligible. See, in order to qualify for the category, the song in question needs to:

a) Consist of words and music, both of which are original and used specifically for the film; and

b) Be used either in the body of the film, or as the "first music cue" in the closing credits (i.e. the first song that plays once the screen fades to black).

The latter of the above two criteria appears to be the problem for "Masterpiece", which isn't featured in the context of the film itself and also happens to be the second song featured during the movie's closing crawl. (The first being a continuation of composer Abel Korzeniowski's score.)

Maybe the Oscar-obsessed Weinsteins figured the Academy would overlook the established rules when coming up with the Best Original Song eligibles - you know, because they're the Weinsteins? Or were they simply unaware of the Academy's specific requirements before sending out those "Masterpiece"-touting "W.E." screeners? 

In any case, looks like poor old Madge is once again being denied the opportunity to add "Oscar nominee/winner" to her substantial list of accomplishments (particularly given that "W.E." isn't expected to pick up nods in any of the major categories), a designation that I can't imagine she isn't at least a little bit hungry for (she is Madonna, after all).

But hey, buck up kiddo; there's always next year. And just remember - the Hollywood Foreign Press Association loves you no matter what.

What do you think of the Academy's Best Original Song rules? Should the eligibility requirements be loosened? Sound off with your comments below!

Read Full Post
<p>Marion Cotillard and Owen Wilson star in Woody Allen's &quot;Midnight in Paris.&quot;</p>

Marion Cotillard and Owen Wilson star in Woody Allen's "Midnight in Paris."

Credit: Sony Classics

Contender Countdown: Is 'Midnight in Paris' now 'The Artist's' biggest competition?

A rundown on where we are in the best picture race

Well, that was a surprise.  After a breakneck week of SAG Awards nominations (important), critics groups honors (important) and Golden Globe nominations (least important), the race to Oscar ended up becoming even more convoluted than before.   

Read Full Post
<p>Kenan Thompson and Jimmy Fallon in a 'War Horse' sketch on 'Saturday Night Live' on Dec. 18, 2011.</p>

Kenan Thompson and Jimmy Fallon in a 'War Horse' sketch on 'Saturday Night Live' on Dec. 18, 2011.

Credit: NBC

'SNL' takes on 'War Horse' and misses out

Perhaps they should have waited to see the movie?

After you watch this bizarre parody of "War Horse" from last night's "Saturday Night Live," a few observations.

Read Full Post
<p>Shailene Woodley has landed her first Golden Globe nomination this year for &quot;The Descendants.&quot;</p>

Shailene Woodley has landed her first Golden Globe nomination this year for "The Descendants."

Credit: AP Photo/Chris PIzzello

Golden Globes: 'The Descendants'' nominee Shailene Woodley feels every emotion rolled up into one

Plus: Producer Jim Burke on the film's awards season success

With "The Artist" breathing down its neck and buzz growing for "Hugo," "Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close" and "War Horse," the beginning of December wasn't the best of times for Team "Descendants."  The critically acclaimed film had lost both the best picture honors of the NYFCC and the National Board of Review and while box office was fantastic, best picture hopes were fading fast.  What a difference the last week has been.

Read Full Post
<p>Viola Davis, Emma Stone, Octavia Spencer and Tate Taylor during a photo call for &quot;The Help&quot;&nbsp;in Spain this past October</p>

Viola Davis, Emma Stone, Octavia Spencer and Tate Taylor during a photo call for "The Help" in Spain this past October

Credit: AP Photo/Paul White

Golden Globes: Tate Taylor makes it hard not to root for 'The Help'

The filmmaker discusses his talented cast and friendship with Octavia Spencer

Tate Taylor is living the dream.  The screenwriter and director of "The Help" has seen his surprise blockbuster turn into an awards season darling.  The film's biggest kudos so far came over the past two days as it was nominated for best ensemble at the SAG Awards, best picture - drama at the Golden Globes and three of his actors, Viola Davis, Jessica Chastain and Octavia Spencer, received both SAG and Golden Globe acting nominations.  For a Hollywood lifer who spent over a decade trying to land his big break in the business, it sounds like he's still pinching himself.

Read Full Post
<p>Ryan Gosling in &quot;The Ides of March.&quot;&nbsp; George Clooney's political thriller received a surprising four nominations including best picture - drama, best director, best screenplay and best actor - drama for Gosling.</p>

Ryan Gosling in "The Ides of March."  George Clooney's political thriller received a surprising four nominations including best picture - drama, best director, best screenplay and best actor - drama for Gosling.

Credit: Sony Pictures

Did the Golden Globes make themselves absolutely irrelevant in this year's Oscar races?

Beware 'The Ides of March'?

No one has ever taken much stock in the Hollywood Foreign Press Association's best of the year picks as a reliable precursors to the Academy Awards.  At best, they are a well timed marketing tool that provides awards-centric films a publicity boost at the box office.  And, this year in particular, for small films such as "We Need To Talk About Kevin," "Albert Nobbs," "The Artist" and "My Week With Marilyn" and "Shame," that could be significant.  But after the SAG Awards were announced yesterday, an actual indicator of industry and AMPAS member sentiment, have the Globes ever seemed less relevant?

Read Full Post
10 shorts advance in Oscar's live action shorts race
Credit: AMPAS

10 shorts advance in Oscar's live action shorts race

Three to five nominees will be revealed on Jan 2r

The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences announced this morning that 10 short films have advanced to the next round of voting for the 2012 Live Action Academy Award.  107 short films originally qualified and out of that pool the following 10 were selected.

"Je Pourrais Être Votre Grand-Mère (I Could Be Your Grandmother)," Bernard Tanguy, director-producer (Rézina Productions)

"Love at First Sight," Michael Davies, director and Sandra Gorel, producer (Spellbound Films)

"Pentecost," Peter McDonald, director (EMU Productions)

"Raju," Max Zähle, director and Stefan Gieren, producer (Hamburg Media School/Filmwerkstatt)

"The Road Home," Rahul Gandotra, director-producer and Ameenah Ayub, producer (London Film School)

"The Roar of the Sea," Ana Rocha Fernandes and Torsten Truscheit, directors (Niama Filmproduktion GmbH)

"Sailcloth," Elfar Adalsteins, director-producer (Berserk Films)

"The Shore," Terry George, director-producer (All Ashore Productions Limited"

"Time Freak," Andrew Bowler, director and Gigi Causey, producer (Team Toad)

"Tuba Atlantic," Hallvar Witzø, director (The Norwegian Film School/Den Norske Filmskolen)

At this point, the Academy's Short Films and Feature Animation Branch members will now review the finalists and select three to five nominees from among the 10 titles on the shortlist for nomination. Branch screenings will be held in Los Angeles, New York and San Francisco next month.

The 84th Academy Awards nominations will be announced live on Tuesday, January 24, 2012, at 5:30 AM, 8:30 AM PT.
 

Read Full Post
<p>&quot;The Descendants&quot; is realistically one of only two pictures - including &quot;The Artist&quot;&nbsp;- who can win best picture this year after landing an outstanding motion picture ensemble nomination.</p>

"The Descendants" is realistically one of only two pictures - including "The Artist" - who can win best picture this year after landing an outstanding motion picture ensemble nomination.

Credit: Fox Searchlight

Analysis: SAG pushes 'The Artist' and 'Descendants' to the front of the Oscar race

No. 1 lesson: Don't screen late

In one respect the film nominations for the 2012 Screen Actor's Guild Awards were not that surprising.  They were broad.  They were populist.  And, for the most part, they didn't rock the boat.  Before we go through each category, however, there are some major lessons already being learned from today's results.

Read Full Post
<p>Melissa McCarthy is crowned best actress in a comedy queen at the 2011 Emmy Awards. &nbsp;Will McCarthy find the same amount of love from SAG&nbsp;voters?</p>

Melissa McCarthy is crowned best actress in a comedy queen at the 2011 Emmy Awards.  Will McCarthy find the same amount of love from SAG voters?

Credit: AP Photo/Mark J. Terrill

2012 SAG Nominations: 10 things you should look for

What surprises are on deck from Hollywood's thespians?

Early tomorrow morning the Screen Actor's Guild will get a jump on the HFPA and announce the nominees for the 2012 SAG Awards.  Unlike the Golden Globes, the SAGs are held in much higher esteem by most actors because they are being honored by their peers.  Of course, with such a large group of voters on the nominating committee(4,200 randomly selected members) you're bound to get a few strange nods here and there.  Moreover, as the largest branch in the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, how the actors (er, SAG) falls is generally (but not always) a good indicator of where the Academy Award nominations will land.  That being said, before you get up bright and early to hear Regina King and Judy Greer announce this year's nods, keep these 10 things in mind.

Read Full Post
<p>&nbsp;Seth Rogen</p>

 Seth Rogen

Credit: AP Photo

Seth Rogen to host Independent Spirit Awards

Producer-star's '50/50' also nominated for best feature

Funnyman Seth Rogen will host the 27th annual Independent Spirits Awards next year, lending his brand of smart-stoner sass to the proceedings.

He'll also have an interest in the show's results; Rogen co-produced and starred in this year's "50/50," with Joseph Gordon-Levitt, which is up for multiple Spirit Awards including Best Feature. Also nominated in that category are the films "Drive," "The Descendants," "Take Shelter," "Beginners" and "The Artist."

He also recently co-starred in the Toronto Fest hit "Take This Waltz," with Michelle Williams.

Rogen, whose first break was on TV's "Freaks and Geeks," has been everywhere in the last few years, and may be best known for his handful of films with "Freaks" producer Judd Apatow, including "The 40-Year-Old Virgin," "Superbad," "Knocked Up" and "Funny People." 

“We’re incredibly excited to have Seth as the host for the 2012 Film Independent Spirit Awards and join us in celebrating this year’s exquisite films and talented filmmaking artists. Seth’s charm, intelligence and quick wit are sure to light up the room and will make for a truly entertaining afternoon,” said Film Independent's Sean Mc Manus in a release.

The 27th annual awards ceremony is scheduled for Saturday, February 25, and will air that evening at 10:00 p.m. ET/PT on IFC. 

Rogen's pal and frequent co-star James Franco did a less-than-stellar job of co-hosting the Oscars last year with Anne Hathaway, but we can assume that The Spirits and Rogen are a better match. 

Last year's Spirit Awards show was hosted by "Community: star Joel McHale. Previous hosts have included Eddie Izzard, Steve Coogan, Rainn Wilson, Samuel L. Jackson, Queen Latifah, Jennifer Tilly, Sarah Silverman and frequent host John Waters.

Do you think Rogen's a good choice to host?

Read Full Post