Roman Polanski's 'Ghost Writer' faces its critics: Are they being fair?
Having seen Roman Polanski's "The Ghost Writer" last month, the mixed reaction to the film's premiere at the 2010 Berlin Film Festival today is something of a surprise. It's not that "Writer" is up there with Polanski's classics such as "Chinatown," "Rosemary's Baby" or "The Pianist," but it's clearly one of his most commercial and entertaining pictures since he went into exile over 30 years ago.
Adapted from Robert Harris' best selling 2007 novel "The Ghost," the picture finds Ewan McGregor playing a ghost writer recruited to help finish the autobiography of a former disgraced British Prime Minister played by Pierce Brosnan. As McGregor's character travels to the remote U.S. retreat the PM has been held up on, he encounters his longtime personal assistant who may know too much but is too loyal (a slick Kim Cattrall) and his frustrated and possibly more politically keen wife (a fantastic Olivia Williams). As the days go by, the PM's life story is not what it seems and it has dangerous consequences for all.
One of the most positive complete reviews so far is Fionnuala Halligan's take in Screen International. The Brit describes it as "A stylish, precise salute to Hitchcock’s thrillers but still bearing all the hallmarks of Roman Polanski’s distinctive style." She also throws out a publicity friendly quote calling it a "film lover's delight." Halligan has praise for the Brosnan making the British PM not "another tedious impersonation of Tony Blair." Moreover, she gives her biggest praise to star Ewan McGregor noting it's "his best performance in years."
A little less enthusiastic, but still positive was Kirk Honeycutt of The Hollywood Reporter. This pundit rarely agrees with Honeycutt and is not sure the thriller is a "surefire box office hit domestically" (possibly), but we agree "[unlike 'Chinatown'] this is a slicker, shallower exercise. It's hypnotic as it unfolds, but once the credit roll frees you from its grip, it doesn't bear close scrutiny." And that last point is clearly not a swipe at its artistic accomplishment. The film is just a very good, intriguing and solid thriller.
A much more cranky take comes from Derek Elley of Variety. He immediately rips the "weak" performance by McGregor in the film and seems to dismiss the whole endeavor as a straight book-to-screen adaptation. Elley also criticizes the film for a "lack of real action or thrills" (sorry, this isn't a "Bourne" movie Mr. Elley). Brosnan's role, one of his best in quite awhile in this writer's opinion, is described as "hardly believable" and Elley even goes so far to rip the art direction assuming there are no modern designed homes on Martha's Vineyard (the location is just described as "an island off the Atlantic coast"). Mr. Elley might need to get out more.
What the critic did praise -- and boy, judging from the tone of this review, it must have killed him to do so -- is Tom Wilkinson's "beautifully played scene" as a "hint of what the movie could have been."
On the other hand, Peter Bradshaw of The Guardian calls it "the director's most purely enjoyable film in years" and awards it four out of five stars adding it's "a Hitchcockian nightmare with a persistent, stomach-turning sense of disquiet, brought off with confidence and dash." Ditto that.
The question really is, will critics across the world give Polanski a fair shake on "Ghost"? It seems almost everyone conveniently forgot why he was living in exile as he heaped praise and an Oscar for "The Pianist" or the ignored "Oliver Twist" a few years later. But the controversy over Swiss authorities extraditing him back to the United States (which they seem in no rush to do), the industry from top to bottom is once again uncomfortable with how to deal with the iconic filmmaker. And as reviewer, do you judge the film independent of that predicament or do you let your opinions on the filmmaker affect your cinematic judgement?
With "The Ghost Writer" opening in New York and Los Angeles on the 19th, it will be curious to see how some of the more well known critics from the papers and magazines of record respond to it. As for audiences, Polanski controversy or not, word of mouth should be strong. Whether that means a hit depends on your definition of success, but a $35-40 million gross isn't out of the question.
As for this pundit, I am certainly looking forward to seeing it again and hope Wilkinson's great supporting turn is remembered a year from now.
Do you have any interest in seeing "The Ghost Writer"? Share your thoughts below.
1997 | Crime | RSummary: Quentin Tarantino adaptats an Elmore Leonard novel into this story of a few increasingly desperate people scraping to get by. It has deep soul, a wicked sense of humor, and Samuel L. Jackson, Robert De Niro, Pam Grier, and Robert Forster.Director: Quentin Tarantino
Cast: Pam Grier, Samuel L. Jackson, Robert Forster
1995 | Mystery | NRSummary: Denzel Washington plays an out of work WWII vet who takes the wrong job and is soon neck-deep in a mess of politics, murder, and jazz in '40s Los Angeles.Director: Carl Franklin
Cast: Denzel Washington, Tom Sizemore, Jennifer Beals
2007 | Comedy | PGSummary: Newlyweds Nick (Ice Cube) and Suzanne (Long) decide to move to the suburbs to provide a better life for their two kids. But their idea of a dream home is disturbed by a contractor (McGinley) with a bizarre approach to business.Director: Steve Carr
Cast: John C. McGinley, Ice Cube, Nia Long, Aleisha Allen
2013 | Thriller | RSummary: Based on the true story of Daniel Lugo (Mark Wahlberg) a Miami bodybuilder who wants to live the American dream. He would like to have the money that other people have. So he enlists the help of fellow bodybuilder Adrian Doorbal (Anthony Mackie) and ex-convict, Christian bodybuilder Paul Doyle (D...Director: Michael Bay
Cast: Mark Wahlberg, Dwayne Johnson, Anthony Mackie, Tony Shalhoub
2013 | Comedy | NRSummary: Insanely funny comedy show created by Amy Schumer, who stars in brilliantly funny sketches about sex, city living, dating, and friendship.Director: Daniel Powell, Amy Schumer (creators)
Cast: Amy Schumer, Kevin Kane, Mike Houston
2013 | Drama | RSummary: Leonardo DiCaprio and Jonah Hill have boundless energy in the story of a real-life commodities crook who earned millions through scummy small-time stock trades.Director: Martin Scorsese
Cast: Leonardo DiCaprio, Jonah Hill, Margot Robbie
1993 | Sports | PGSummary: Emotionally powerful sports classic featuring Sean Astin as a skinny high school kid with big football dreams and the determination to make his way towards his dream team at Notre Dame.Director: David Anspaugh
Cast: Sean Astin, Jon Favreau, Ned Beatty
1996 | Crime | RSummary: Jerry, a small-town Minnesota car salesman is bursting at the seams with debt... but he's got a plan. He's going to hire two thugs to kidnap his wife in a scheme to collect a hefty ransom from his wealthy father-in-law. It's going to be a snap and nobody's going to get hurt... until people start ...Director: Joel Coen, Ethan Coen
Cast: William H. Macy, Frances McDormand, Steve Buscemi, Peter Stormare
2008 | Science Fiction | PGSummary: Animated series continues the story of Obi-Wan Kenobi and Anakin Skywalker as they battle the Emperor Palpatine, Count Dooku and General Grievous, but also takes time to explore other smaller characters in the Star Wars universe.Director: George Lucas (creator)
Cast: Tom Kane, Dee Bradley Baker, Matt Lanter
Let Streaming Genie help you.