Federal court strikes down FCC's fleeting expletive policy
NEW YORK (AP) — A federal appeals court on Tuesday tossed out a government policy that can lead to broadcasters being fined for allowing even a single curse word on live television, concluding that the rule was unconstitutionally vague and had a chilling effect on broadcasters.
The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan struck down the 2004 Federal Communications Commission policy, which said that profanity referring to sex or excrement is always indecent.
"By prohibiting all 'patently offensive' references to sex, sexual organs and excretion without giving adequate guidance as to what 'patently offensive' means, the FCC effectively chills speech, because broadcasters have no way of knowing what the FCC will find offensive," the appeals court wrote.
"To place any discussion of these vast topics at the broadcaster's peril has the effect of promoting wide self-censorship of valuable material which should be completely protected under the First Amendment," it added.
The court said the FCC might be able to craft a policy that does not violate the First Amendment.
FCC spokeswoman Jen Howard had no immediate comment.
"The score for today's game is First Amendment one, censorship zero," said Andrew Jay Schwartzman, policy director of Media Access Project, which joined the case on behalf of musicians, producers, writers and directors.
Carter Phillips, a Washington lawyer who argued the case for Fox Television Stations Inc., called the decision satisfying. He said the court had "sent the FCC back to square one to start over" by not only tossing the FCC's fleeting expletive policy but also a broader indecency policy as unconstitutionally vague.
The FCC fleeting expletive policy was put in place after a January 2003 NBC broadcast of the Golden Globes awards show, in which U2 lead singer Bono uttered the phrase "f------ brilliant." The FCC said the F-word in any context "inherently has a sexual connotation" and can lead to enforcement.
Fox Television Stations, owned by Rupert Murdoch's News Corp., and other networks challenged the policy in 2006 after the FCC cited the use of profanity during awards programs that were aired in 2002 and 2003.
The FCC found its ban also was violated by a Dec. 9, 2002, broadcast of the Billboard Music Awards in which singer Cher used the phrase "F--- 'em" and a Dec. 10, 2003, Billboard awards show in which reality show star Nicole Richie said, "Have you ever tried to get cow s--- out of a Prada purse? It's not so f------ simple."
The ruling by the three-judge panel came after the Supreme Court last year upheld the policy on procedural grounds and returned it to the 2nd Circuit for consideration of constitutional arguments. The 2nd Circuit in 2007 had found in a 2-to-1 ruling that the policy was "arbitrary and capricious."
AP Technology writer Joelle Tessler contributed to this report from Maryland.
Copyright (2009) Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
2012 | Drama | NRSummary: A bluegrass score is one of many elements that set apart this Dutch story of an intense romance between a tattoo artist and a musician.Director: Felix van Groeningen
Cast: Veerle Baetens, Johan Heldenbergh, Nell Cattrysse
1988 | Fantasy | PGSummary: 'Toon star Roger is worried that his wife Jessica is playing pattycake with someone else, so the studio hires detective Eddie Valiant to snoop on her. But the stakes are quickly raised when Marvin Acme is found dead and Roger is the prime suspect.Director: Robert Zemeckis
Cast: Bob Hoskins, Christopher Lloyd, Joanna Cassidy, Charles Fleischer
2012 | Animation | GSummary: Tinkerbell wanders into the forbidden Winter woods and meets Periwinkle. Together they learn the secret of their wings and try to unite the warm fairies and the winter fairies to help Pixie Hollow.Director: Roberts Gannaway, Peggy Holmes
Cast: Mae Whitman, Lucy Liu, Jesse McCartney, Lucy Hale
1946 | Drama | NRSummary: A widower gives his daughter Anne a colt, which she names Black Beauty, so that she may learn to care for herself as she cares for the horse.Director: Max Nosseck
Cast: Mona Freeman, Richard Denning, Evelyn Ankers
2014 | Mystery | TV-MASummary: You've never seen a detective pair quite like the one played by Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson, who must fight to retain their sanity while investigating a particularly heinous case.Director: Cary Fukunaga
Cast: Matthew McConaughey, Woody Harrelson, Michelle Monaghan
1997 | Comedy | TV-MASummary: Four foul-mouthed elementary-school friends are involved in bizarre capers featuring everything from aliens to Michael Jackson in the amazingly long-running animated TV show.Director: Trey Parker, Matt Stone, Brian Graden (creators)
Cast: Trey Parker, Matt Stone, Isaac Hayes
2014 | Documentary | PG-13Summary: A North Dakota pastor tries to help the lives of workers who travel to his town to take advantage of oil boom jobs in this surprising and deeply humanistic documentary.Director: Jesse Moss
Cast: Jay Reinke, Keegan Edwards
2011 | Drama | RSummary: A queasy, weird tale of two guys who dream of surviving the apocalypse who are tested when they encounter something their homemade car and flamethrowers can't handle: love.Director: Evan Glodell
Cast: Evan Glodell, Tyler Dawson, Jessie Wiseman
2002 | Documentary | NRSummary: The astounding rise, fall and rise Hollywood producer Robert Evans is packed with insider stories about Hollywood personalities and films like The Godfather and Rosemary’s Baby.Director: Nanette Burstein, Brett Morgen
Cast: Robert Evans, Eddie Albert, Peter Bart
Let Streaming Genie help you.